Heavy-handed police tactics, including using tear gas canisters that explode on impact, have left a toll of horror injuries from street clashes in Bangkok, investigators and rights activists said.
Provocation from protesters — some of whom were armed and violently attacked police — was also to blame for the worst unrest seen in the Thai capital for 16 years, they said. The injuries sustained by protesters have shocked the country.
Newspapers have published graphic photos of people lying on the ground with their feet or lower legs blown off, while the Nation reported yesterday that one woman was in a vegetative state after suffering head injuries.
PHOTO: AFP
Police have been heavily criticized for using excessive force, firing tear gas on demonstrators blockading parliament to protest at a government plan to amend the Constitution.
The bloody clashes that followed saw two people killed and 478 injured.
Witnesses as well as photographic and video testimony showed violence from both sides.
Sunai Phasuk, Thailand analyst for New-York-based Human Rights Watch, said neither police nor the People’s Alliance for Democracy (PAD) could claim to have acted responsibly.
“We are calling on both sides to cease the use of violence and for PAD in particular to disarm themselves,” Sunai said. “They need to show their respect for democratic legal process... [and] the government has a responsibility to prove that all the actions taken on Oct. 7 were carried out according to the due process of law.”
“It’s become very clear that excessive violence was used,” Sunai said.
Forensic experts point to the severity of injuries caused by tear gas.
“The tear gas was a Chinese make, which can cause injuries like this,” said Porntip Rojanasunan, director of the Central Institute of Forensic Science.
Such injuries do not happen with Australian or US-made tear gas, she said, although she is awaiting a police sample to confirm her findings.
Porntip was originally called in by the army to investigate PAD claims that the police used bombs, but is now doing so for the independent National Human Rights Commission of Thailand.
She said that unlike the Western brands, the Chinese canisters explode when they hit an object before releasing their tear gas.
“I don’t think the police should use this type of tear gas, because it’s dangerous,” she said.
“The way they shoot at the people, they aim the gun directly at people so there could be serious injury,” she said.
The PAD movement has been trying for months to unseat the government, which it claims is effectively running the country for former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra, who was ousted in a September 2006 coup.
For weeks now they have been occupying the central government offices, and have vowed to continue their rallies until Thai Prime Minister Somchai Wongsawat — a brother-in-law of Thaksin — and his administration step down.
Somchai, who on Saturday said he was considering resignation in the wake of the clashes, said the use of tear gas conformed to “international practice” but announced an independent investigation into the violence.
John Virgoe, Southeast Asia project director for the International Crisis Group, said an independent probe was important but unlikely to change anyone’s mind.
“My impression is that everybody has made up their mind about which version of events they adhere to based on their pre-existing views,” he said.
Society is bitterly divided between supporters of the populist government, mostly the rural poor, and the royalist elite who form the mainstay of support for the protesters.
A poll this week by Assumption University in Bangkok mirrored that gulf — half of those questioned supported the PAD and half were against.
Virgoe said police had not acted properly on Tuesday because they were not adequately trained in crisis management or properly equipped.
“Thai security forces just don’t have the range of techniques and the ability to respond to a security challenge in a nuanced and intelligent way. They either do nothing or they over-react. It’s a serious problem,” he said.
VIOLENT STANDOFFS: The government said 215 students have been injured since the start of the movement last month, including a teenager who lost a hand on Monday Thousands of demonstrators yesterday massed under heavy police surveillance in Paris and cities across France, as unions and teachers joined high-school students who for days have been demanding better conditions in protests punctuated by violent clashes. Students have blocked the entrances to hundreds of high schools for 15-to-17-year-olds since late last month, complaining of missing teachers, overloaded schedules, dilapidated classrooms and buildings that cannot cope with rising temperatures. In the Paris suburb of Creteil, where the protests started last month, students piled barriers outside the Saint-Exupery high school. “We are here to make our voice heard, all too often forgotten,” student Abderrahmane Abdelkader
As shark attack survivor Mel Ismail fought the predator that severed his leg, he noticed something odd. “I saw its eye ... a big black eye,” Ismail said. “But it was winking back at me — I was trying to get my fingers in its eye and just pushing its eye as I was being dragged.” When the shark swam off, he managed to struggle back to shore, the surfer and professional firefighter said in an Australian Broadcasting Corp interview broadcast on Thursday. He was surfing at Glenfield Beach near Geraldton on Australia’s west coast when he was attacked on Sept. 14. He
A Tuvalu government adviser yesterday said it felt like Australia had “taken over” the tiny country’s sovereignty during a visit by leaders to the Pacific island. The official — a senior government adviser who asked to remain anonymous because they were not authorized to speak to the media — said they were disappointed in Australia’s handling of the visit. The comments came during a visit by Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and other leaders to Tuvalu, which has become a symbol of the existential threat posed by rising seas and is a key partner in Canberra’s Pacific strategy. “Just because we signed the
Halfway around the world from Russia, in a Caribbean tourism hot spot, men young and old are being lured by Moscow with tantalizing job offers, only to find themselves en route to the front lines in Ukraine. Moscow and Kyiv have recruited thousands of foreign nationals into their armies since Russia launched its invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Moscow is accused, in some cases, of using fake job ads to hoodwink men from deprived backgrounds in Africa, Asia and Latin America into traveling to Russia and then forcing them to fight on arrival. From countries such as India, Kenya, Equatorial Guinea, Colombia and
RSS