A controversial art installation that pitted live caged animals against each other was to close yesterday, after the Chinese-French artist was accused of cruelty.
Internationally-known artist Huang Yong Ping, a Chinese who now lives in Paris, announced the animals in a enclosure will be removed "to maintain the integrity of the artwork."
The British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) had ordered Huang and the Vancouver Art Gallery to drastically modify the exhibit.
By provincial law, the agency can investigate and lay charges of animal cruelty.
Since opening a week ago, the "Theater of the World" housed lizards, scorpions, tarantulas and other animals together in a cage.
Kathleen Bartels, director of the Vancouver Art Gallery, said the installation "encouraged people to think seriously about the dynamics of power in today's society."
But a fierce dispute over animal rights and artistic freedom immediately broke out in this western Canadian metropolis.
"We were called in on an animal cruelty complaint," SPCA spokesperson Lorie Chortyk said. "People were concerned about different species coexisting in that habitat ... They are species from different parts of the world that would not normally be with each other."
The cage is an oval-shaped plywood table with a wire-mesh cover in the shape of a turtle.
When this reporter visited, chirping crickets swarmed over the cage floor, a lizard sat motionless near the center while scorpions and large black hairy tarantulas pressed near the outer edges.
A guard hovered nearby, telling people not to touch the cage as groups of schoolchildren pressed close and shrieked at the sight of the creatures.
Carol Gigliotti, a professor at the Emily Carr Institute of Art and Design in Vancouver with a specialty in animal ethics, said the display conveyed the element of chance, the reality the animals could kill each other, and the fact that "death is imminent and people have to accept this."
Gigliotti said she realized that Huang was trying to convey an abstract idea, "but the ethical choice would be to take out the animals."
The exhibit posted a disclaimer that all animals were bred in captivity and would be sent to good homes after the show closed.
"In my mind that doesn't make it right," Gigliotti said. "That's like saying, this woman was born into slavery so it's ok, she's used to it.'"
Gigliotti slammed the gallery for first displaying the animals "without water, without any place to hide, with one light source so it was very cold, they need a lot more heat."
After the SPCA's first visit the gallery provided water and hiding places, Chortyk said. Later, a veterinarian examined the animals and the SPCA ordered removal of the tarantulas and scorpions.
Instead, said Huang in the release, "we must remove all the animals in `Theater of the World' but leave behind the emptied physical structure, and to do so as a sign of protest."
The gallery said the controversy would be used "to encourage discussions about freedom of expression, power and censorship."
The live-animal display is part of House of Oracles: A Huang Yong Ping Retrospective, which was earlier shown in Minneapolis, Minnesota and the North Adams, Massachusetts with no changes.
PAST TACTICS: In what some see as a return to hardline strategies, the new Afghan rulers hanged the body of an alleged kidnapper from a crane as warning to criminals The Taliban hanged a dead body from a crane parked in a city square in Afghanistan on Saturday in a gruesome display that signaled the hardline movement’s return to some of its brutal tactics of the past. Taliban officials initially brought four bodies to the central square in the western city of Herat, then moved three of them to other parts of the city for public display, said Wazir Ahmad Seddiqi, who runs a pharmacy on the edge of the square. Taliban officials announced that the four were caught taking part in a kidnapping earlier on Saturday and were killed by police,
Kim Yo-jong, the influential sister of North Korean leader Kim Jong-un, reached out to South Korea for a second time in recent days, saying Pyongyang would consider taking part in another inter-Korean summit and declaring an end to the war if Seoul adopts a less hostile policy. “I felt that the atmosphere of the South Korean public desiring to recover the inter-Korean relations from a deadlock and achieve peaceful stability as soon as possible is irresistibly strong,” Kim Yo-jong said in a statement issued by the official Korean Central News Agency. “We, too, have the same desire.” Kim’s statement follows one she
A potential lurch to the left in Germany’s election on Sunday is scaring millionaires into moving assets into Switzerland, bankers and tax lawyers say. If the center-left Social Democrats (SPD), hard-left Linke and environmentalist Greens come to power, the reintroduction of a wealth tax and a tightening of inheritance tax could be on the political agenda. “For the super-rich, this is red hot,” said a German-based tax lawyer with extensive Swiss operations. “Entrepreneurial families are highly alarmed.” The move shows how many rich people still see Switzerland as an attractive place to park wealth, despite its efforts to abolish its image as a
‘SMOKESCREEN’: An agreement to declare an end to the Korean War would be ‘of no help at all’ and used to cover up ‘US hostile policy,’ a North Korean official said The influential sister of North Korean leader Kim Jong-un yesterday said it was “admirable” of South Korea to propose a formal end to the Korean War, but demanded Seoul first drop its “hostile policies” towards Pyongyang. Kim Yo-jong’s remarks, carried by the state-run Korean Central News Agency, were in response to South Korean President Moon Jae-in’s recent calls for declaring an official end to the 1950-1953 conflict that ended in a truce, not a peace treaty, leaving the two sides technically at war for more than half a century. In a speech at the UN General Assembly earlier this week, Moon proposed
RSS