Nie Yuanzi (
Wang Rongfen, a student of German at Beijing's elite Foreign Language Institute, was imprisoned after writing a bold letter to Mao Zedong (毛澤東) challenging his judgment in unleashing the self-destructive frenzy of his young vigilantes, the Red Guards.
Even today, the history of that time has been shunted into a dark corner. There have been no news reports or public memorials of the catastrophe, in which hundreds of thousands of people were killed and China's economy devastated.
Yet, exactly four decades after the start of the Cultural Revolution, there remains a compelling symmetry to the experiences and reflections of the two women who played such prominent roles at the outset of this disastrous era, and had their lives tragically derailed as a result.
However different, they were both, in the phrase of Wang, "bold and straightforward" women.
Following the publication of an article criticizing Mao's political rivals, Nie, then the Chinese Communist Party secretary of Peking University's philosophy department, put up a poster that claimed the university was under the control of the bourgeoisie. Mao had the poster read over the radio, giving it his stamp of approval and encouraging attacks on authority figures.
Vaulted into the leadership of the Red Guard, she was detained only a year later after becoming disenchanted with its excesses, and was jailed for 17 years.
Now, she is an 85-year-old who survives on the charity of friends. Looking back, she insists she had no idea the poster she wrote would have such terrible consequences.
"I didn't know we were heading toward disaster," she said, describing herself as a party loyalist who executed orders. "Once I understood, I stopped following them. I opposed them, and for that I was punished."
Wang, then 20, was selected to attend one of the earliest mass rallies of the period at Tiananmen Square, when the Maoist personality cult was being whipped into a frenzy.
The speeches she heard there reminded her of the language of the Third Reich, and she watched, horrified, over the ensuing weeks as teachers committed suicide, students denounced one another and her own mother was assigned to forced labor.
"I was transported to the time the Nazis took power," she said.
Wang gathered her courage to write a fateful document of her own, a signed letter to then chairman Mao asking: "What are you doing? Where are you leading China?" It concluded with a judgment that the country's leaders shy from even now. "The Cultural Revolution is not a mass movement," she wrote to Mao. "It is one man with a gun manipulating the people."
The letter, which has never been published, earned her a life sentence, which was lifted after 12-and-a-half years, following Mao's death in 1976, which also spelled the end of the Cultural Revolution.
Though frail, Nie remains feisty. She recently published a book in Hong Kong about her experiences.
"The lessons," she said, when asked what she drew from her experience. "Democracy should be really promoted so that each person can express their opinions about state affairs and the work of others. Even if an opinion is not correct, it must be allowed, and allowed to be contradicted. Even today, posters should be allowed."
Nie readily acknowledges helping to visit suffering on others, like officials of Peking University, the target of her poster. They were paraded around the grounds of the university in a dunce cap and signboard. Others, labeled reactionaries, were beaten or tortured.
Deprived of a pension until recently, closely monitored and unable to publish inside China, she has dedicated her life to overcoming the official silence about the Cultural Revolution. The leadership, she said, has buried the memory of this period because "it is afraid of losing power. They would prefer for the Cultural Revolution to be forgotten."
taking a stand
Unlike Nie, who insists she was a pawn, Wang says she never had doubts about the consequences her fateful letter would have. She simply felt she had no choice but to take a stand.
Wang left China days after the slaying of demonstrators at Tiananmen Square in 1989, and has lived in Germany ever since, as a novelist and bureaucrat. Even today she weeps as she describes the suffering her actions brought to the people in her life -- from family members to her entire school, which became the target of purges and "struggle sessions" because of her letter.
Though they were on the opposite sides of the political chessboard and have never met, Wang expressed support for Nie.
"She is a tragic figure who was used by others," she said. "She was hot for a year or two and then lived an inhuman existence for the next decade. I am glad she is alive to tell her story."
Her only venom is reserved for Mao, who is still revered and officially deemed to have been a force for good 70 percent of the time.
"I'd say 30 percent good and 70 percent bad," Wang said. "The purges, taking China to the edge of bankruptcy, so many deaths -- these are unforgivable. They're not mistakes; they are crimes."
A glimpse of a possible Picasso in the home of Imelda Marcos filmed during a visit by her son after his presidential election win has set off a flurry of speculation in the Philippines, where the family that once plundered billions is set to return to power. Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr, the son and namesake of the late dictator, won a landslide victory in Monday’s presidential election, an outcome that has appalled those who survived his father’s regime. Images released by the family showed Marcos Jr visiting the home of his mother, who had displayed Picasso’s Femme Couche VI (Reclining Woman VI),
The images of a besuited Ferdinand Marcos Jr, clad in a top hat and leaning nonchalantly on a Rolls-Royce, dating from his time in Britain in the 1970s, are as you might expect from the playboy scion of a kleptocratic dictator. Yet as the Marcos family returns to power in the Philippines after a landslide presidential victory by Marcos Jr, he is facing calls to stop misrepresenting the circumstances of his studies at the University of Oxford. The university has confirmed that he did not complete his degree in philosophy, politics and economics after enrolling in 1975. “According to our records, he did
HATE CRIME: Officials were investigating a detailed ‘manifesto’ posted online before the livestreamed shooting, in which the suspect outlined his reasoning and plans A heavily armed 18-year-old white man on Saturday shot 10 people dead at a Buffalo, New York, grocery store in a “racially motivated” attack that he livestreamed on camera, authorities said. The gunman, who was wearing body armor and a helmet, was arrested after the massacre, Buffalo Police Commissioner Joseph Gramaglia told a news conference. Gramaglia put the toll at 10 dead and three wounded. Eleven of the victims were African Americans. The gunman shot four people in the parking lot of the Tops supermarket, three of them fatally, then went inside and continued firing, Gramaglia said. Among those killed inside the store was
‘UNITED AS ONE’: Photos showed people working on farms or walking in a North Korean town, indicating that a lockdown does not require people to stay home North Korea yesterday imposed a nationwide lockdown to control its first acknowledged COVID-19 outbreak after saying for more than two years that it had a perfect record keeping out the virus that has spread to nearly every place in the world. The size of the outbreak was not immediately known, but it could have serious consequences, because the country has a poor healthcare system and its 26 million people are believed to be mostly unvaccinated against COVID-19. Some experts say that the North, by its admission of an outbreak, might be seeking outside aid. The North’s Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) said that