In the few days since a drama company in the Midlands canceled the run of a contentious play in the face of violent religious protests, British theater has been grappling with a range of uncomfortable and unusual questions about censorship, freedom and faith.
The cancellation, by the Birmingham Repertory Theater, challenged Britain's 400,000 Sikhs to contemplate the distinctions within their ranks as values change, separating a conservative old guard of immigrants from a newer generation born and reared in Britain. And the episode posed a near-unanswerable question for liberal-minded British theatergoers: What counts more, their commitment to free speech or their commitment to minority rights? Indeed, what kind of a society permits a mob to silence artistic expression in the first place?
"I think it's one of the blackest days for the arts in this country that I have ever experienced," said Neal Foster, the manager of another theater, the Birmingham Stage Company. "Violence is not part of the process we are used to. In the short term the thugs have won, and this has never happened before in the artistic community."
The furor centers on a play by Gurpreet Kaur Bhatti, the British-born daughter of Sikh immigrants. Her latest work, "Behzti" ("Dishonor"), used a Sikh temple as the setting for a harrowing scene in which a young woman is beaten by other women, including her own mother, after being raped by a man who claims to have had a homosexual relationship with her father.
As the play was being performed on Dec. 18, hundreds of Sikh protesters attacked the building, throwing bricks, smashing windows and fighting with police. Citing the threat of further disruptions, the theater canceled the run, which started Dec. 9, but that was only the beginning of a much broader drama.
In the midst of this impassioned debate, Bhatti went into hiding, fearing for her life after death threats. The situation has evoked comparisons with the fatwa by Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini of Iran in 1989 that sent the writer Salman Rushdie into hiding following the publication of his Satanic Verses, a novel the Iranian authorities regarded as insulting to Islam.
"This is the Sikhs' Rushdie affair," said Gurharpal Singh, a professor of inter-religious studies at the University of Birmingham. "There are overtones of religious censorship and the clash between community norms and liberal society."
The soul-searching has become even more tangled because the staging of "Behzti" intersects with another discussion in Britain over a new law that would make incitement to religious hatred a crime, in effect extending earlier legislation that outlawed incitement to racial hatred.
In some ways it is all the more perplexing that the incident should have taken place in Birmingham, England's second largest city, which has managed to achieve an ethnic balance with a large minority of people from an Asian background, most of them Muslims. Not only Bhatti, the playwright, is a Sikh, but so are several members of the cast.
The play's setting infuriated Sikh protesters, who argued that acts like rape and brutality could never happen in the sanctity of a temple. Sikh leaders labeled the drama an insult to their faith, which has some 16 million adherents. The religion, founded in the 15th century, is rooted in the Punjab region of India and has spread in a million-strong diaspora to Britain, Canada, the United States and other countries.
The play itself, with themes like arranged marriage and the clash of tradition with modernity, drew mixed reviews. It was advertised as a black comedy, but The Birmingham Evening Mail said that "what begins as a sharp and black look at a modern family dilemma sinks beneath its own weight." By contrast, The Birmingham Post called the play -- Bhatti's second after a 2001 work, "Behsharam" ("Shameless") -- "gripping and essential."
Whatever the faults and merits, though, they were lost in a debate that made headlines in British newspapers and on radio and television shows, and raised profound concerns about the consequences of, as some saw it, caving in to violence.
In the future, "theaters will not want to take the risk" of staging provocative works, Foster of the Birmingham Stage Company said. "It doesn't just affect theater. What about controversial books, art galleries, paintings?"
(Braham Murray, an artistic director of the Royal Exchange Theater in Manchester, which has commissioned a new play from Bhatti, said there would be "no prescription" about the theme of the play and "no doubts about staging it provided the play is a good play").
But many Sikh representatives argue that the issues have been misunderstood. Harmander Singh, a spokesman for the advocacy group Sikhs in England, said concerns about the setting of the play had gone unheeded for days before the violent protests. Sikh representatives had suggested that the play would be far less offensive if the setting were changed from a temple to a community center, a proposal the theater rejected.
"Rape and other things happen everywhere," Singh said in a telephone interview. "We know that is a reality."
The fact that Bhatti's play took place in a temple was at the center of Sikh objections. "It's nothing to do with the contents; it's the context," he said. "We are not against freedom of speech, but there's no right to offend."
Four people jailed in the landmark Hong Kong national security trial of "47 democrats" accused of conspiracy to commit subversion were freed today after more than four years behind bars, the second group to be released in a month. Among those freed was long-time political and LGBTQ activist Jimmy Sham (岑子杰), who also led one of Hong Kong’s largest pro-democracy groups, the Civil Human Rights Front, which disbanded in 2021. "Let me spend some time with my family," Sham said after arriving at his home in the Kowloon district of Jordan. "I don’t know how to plan ahead because, to me, it feels
The collapse of the Swiss Birch glacier serves as a chilling warning of the escalating dangers faced by communities worldwide living under the shadow of fragile ice, particularly in Asia, experts said. Footage of the collapse on Wednesday showed a huge cloud of ice and rubble hurtling down the mountainside into the hamlet of Blatten. Swiss Development Cooperation disaster risk reduction adviser Ali Neumann said that while the role of climate change in the case of Blatten “still needs to be investigated,” the wider impacts were clear on the cryosphere — the part of the world covered by frozen water. “Climate change and
Poland is set to hold a presidential runoff election today between two candidates offering starkly different visions for the country’s future. The winner would succeed Polish President Andrzej Duda, a conservative who is finishing his second and final term. The outcome would determine whether Poland embraces a nationalist populist trajectory or pivots more fully toward liberal, pro-European policies. An exit poll by Ipsos would be released when polls close today at 9pm local time, with a margin of error of plus or minus 2 percentage points. Final results are expected tomorrow. Whoever wins can be expected to either help or hinder the
DENIAL: Musk said that the ‘New York Times was lying their ass off,’ after it reported he used so much drugs that he developed bladder problems Elon Musk on Saturday denied a report that he used ketamine and other drugs extensively last year on the US presidential campaign trail. The New York Times on Friday reported that the billionaire adviser to US President Donald Trump used so much ketamine, a powerful anesthetic, that he developed bladder problems. The newspaper said the world’s richest person also took ecstasy and mushrooms, and traveled with a pill box last year, adding that it was not known whether Musk also took drugs while heading the so-called US Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) after Trump took power in January. In a
RSS