Although the nation’s first 5G auction will not be concluded until its second phase ends on Feb. 21, the bids generated in the first phase of the auction — NT$138.08 billion (US$4.56 billion) in total — have sparked concerns about the future of the nation’s telecommunications industry and whether 5G services can be made available at an affordable price.
Bids quickly surged to NT$26.77 billion when the auction began on Dec. 10 and rose rapidly, prompting some industry observers to call the bidding process “a train that went completely out of control.”
The situation failed to improve even after the National Communications Commission (NCC), the agency in charge of the auction, on multiple occasions implored the five participating telecoms to stay “calm and rational.”
The Executive Yuan did not help the situation by announcing that it was considering launching a second 5G auction earlier than scheduled.
The bidding war could have raged on after the Lunar New Year holiday if it were not for Asia Pacific Telecom withdrawing from bidding on bandwidth in the most coveted 3.5 gigahertz (GHz) band.
Bids in the first phase auction not only exceeded the Legislative Yuan’s budget goal of NT$44 billion, but also surpassed the amount accumulated in the nation’s first 4G auction in 2013 — NT$118.65 billion.
A former commission official, who was involved in the 4G auctions and asked not to be identified, said that the result could have been predicted soon after the rules governing the 5G auction were made public.
“There was 270 megahertz [MHz] of bandwidth in the 3.5GHz frequency band up for grabs, and the maximum bandwidth that each telecom can buy is capped at 100MHz,” he said. “The bidding was fierce because there was simply not enough bandwidth for the three dominant telecom carriers. If two of them asked for 100MHz, the third would be left with only 70MHz, which would not be enough to offer a quality 5G service.”
Another reason was the commission’s decision to change the rules of the auction, he said.
The rules had previously stipulated that telecoms that failed to secure any part of the spectrum through the auction could still form partnerships with those who did, to offer a 5G service together.
However, the commission decided to change the rules by prohibiting those who did not participate in the auction from being a 5G service carrier.
“The change forced small telecoms to join the auction as well, which in turn boosted the bids,” he said.
“The NCC should take full responsibility for the whirlwind it caused, with the seed being sown the minute it set the rules,” he said. “This government is only interested in milking these large telecoms dry so that it can use the money collected from the auction and spend it on welfare programs.”
The former NCC official also criticized the Executive Yuan’s plan to launch a second auction sooner than expected.
This would place an additional financial burden on telecoms, given that they have spent more than NT$130 billion on the first 5G auction and have yet to fully recover the costs of building and managing 4G system, he said.
The NCC has tried to placate the public by saying that it would implement “administrative measures” to make sure that 5G service fees are affordable.
“What the NCC is trying to say is that telecoms should not expect to charge consumers high fees even after they have spent so much money bidding on the spectrum,” the official said. “It is a scare tactic.”
What happened at the first phase of the auction was “absolutely terrible” for the industry, he said.
Apart from bidding on the spectrum, telecoms also need to build many base stations before they can offer 5G services, he said, adding that telecoms would have to invest a huge amount of money in 5G infrastructure before they can use the technology for more profitable applications, such as the Internet of Things.
Telecoms could want to delay the launch of 5G services, but this might not sit well with the NCC, as it would require telecoms to gradually raise their service coverage rate based on the timeline stated in their business plans, he said.
Consumer demand for 5G services could also rise later this year with the launch of 5G smartphones, he added.
Former NCC chairman Howard Shyr (石世豪) said in his column on the Web site Taiwan Digital Convergence that the fundamental reason that bidding was driven up, apart from the auction rules, was that the government released the 3.5GHz and 28GHz bandwidth too early, so there was not enough available in the frequency band below 6GHz.
Telecoms that secure bandwidth in the 5G auction can use it for 20 years — another motivating factor for telecoms to jump on the bandwagon, he said.
Bad timing and a 5G license that is valid for two decades turned the 5G auction into an “overtime” for the 4G auction that was meant to weaken the competitors’ edge, Shyr said.
It also served as a “preliminary” — a ticket that telecoms simply must secure to enter the 5G competition, he said.
Contrary to what the NCC has said, Shyr said he found that telecoms were quite rational and calm in the way they bid for the 5G spectrum.
All of them were clearly aiming for the bandwidth in the 3.5GHz frequency band, as it makes better service coverage possible, which could lower construction costs for 5G base stations, he said.
Manufacturers have already produced terminal and network equipment for the 3.5GHz frequency band, which would enable telecoms to launch 5G faster, Shyr added.
While telecoms have spent a huge amount on the 4G and 5G auctions, it might be a small price to pay to secure long-term prosperity, he said.
The 4G and 5G licenses are valid for 20 years, and they were released under the Telecommunications Act (電信法), which guarantees that telecoms’ rights over the use of the spectrum would remain unchanged even after the Telecommunications Management Act (電信管理法) replaces the Telecommunication Act in July.
“After the 4G licenses expire in 2030 and 2033, telecoms still have seven to 10 years of exclusive access to 5G spectrum. This is a really good deal,” Shyr said.
So far, Chunghwa Telecom, Taiwan Mobile, Far EasTone Telecommunications (FET) and Asia Pacific Telecom have said that they plan to launch 5G services in the third quarter. Taiwan Star has yet to decide when to launch the service.
Chunghwa Telecom, Taiwan Mobile, FET and Taiwan Star have accumulated 90MHz, 60MHz, 80MHz and 40MHz in the 3.5GHz band respectively.
The four telecoms would participate in a second round of bidding for locations on the band on Feb. 21, if they fail to negotiate a deal before then.
However, consumers might not want to migrate to 5G so soon.
“My first reaction [after hearing about the 5G bids] was that consumers would have to bear the costs. Telecoms might go out of business after the auction if they do not have deep pockets,” said Yvonne Lee (李穎芳), an engineer who specializes in mobile telecommunications.
Asked if she would change to 5G after her 4G contract expires at the end of this year, Lee said it would all depend on the service plans that are available.
She said an unlimited 4G data plan costs about NT$799, and even though 5G performs better than 4G, she can only accept a service plan that costs less than NT$1,000 per month.
As a subscriber of US streaming service Netflix, she does not experience any lag when watching content using 4G, she added.
POLAM KOPITIAM CASE: Of the two people still in hospital, one has undergone a liver transplant and is improving, while the other is being evaluated for a liver transplant A fourth person has died from bongkrek acid poisoning linked to the Polam Kopitiam (寶林茶室) restaurant in Taipei’s Far Eastern Sogo Xinyi A13 Department Store, the Ministry of Health and Welfare said yesterday, as two other people remain seriously ill in hospital. The first death was reported on March 24. The man had been 39 years old and had eaten at the restaurant on March 22. As more cases of suspected food poisoning involving people who had eaten at the restaurant were reported by hospitals on March 26, the ministry and the Taipei Department of Health launched an investigation. The Food and
The long-awaited Taichung aquarium is expected to open next year after more than a decade of development. The building in Cingshui District (清水) is to feature a large ocean aquarium on the first floor, coral display area on the second floor, a jellyfish tank and Dajia River (大甲溪) basin display on the third, a river estuary display and restaurant on the fourth, and a cafe and garden on the fifth. As it is near Wuci Fishing Port (梧棲漁港), many are expecting the opening of the aquarium to bring more tourism to the harbor. Speaking at the city council on Monday, Taichung City Councilor
A fourth person has died in a food poisoning outbreak linked to the Xinyi (信義) branch of Malaysian restaurant chain Polam Kopitiam (寶林茶室) in Taipei, Deputy Minister of Health and Welfare Victor Wang (王必勝) said on Monday. It was the second fatality in three days, after another was announced on Saturday. The 40-year-old woman experienced multiple organ failure in the early hours on Monday, and the family decided not to undergo emergency resuscitation, Wang said. She initially showed signs of improvement after seeking medical treatment for nausea, vomiting and diarrhea, but her condition worsened due to an infection, he said. Two others who
Taiwanese should be mindful when visiting China, as Beijing in July is likely to tighten the implementation of policies on national security following the introduction of two regulations, a researcher said on Saturday. China on Friday unveiled the regulations governing the law enforcement and judicial activities of national security agencies. They would help crack down on “illegal” and “criminal” activities that Beijing considers to be endangering national security, according to reports by China’s state media. The definition of what constitutes a national security threat in China is vague, Taiwan Thinktank researcher Wu Se-chih (吳瑟致) said. The two procedural regulations are to provide Chinese