Bad attitude, rashness, bias and incompetence are the main issues with Taiwan’s so-called “dinosaur judges,” a nickname bestowed for their being out of touch with society, Judicial Reform Foundation chairman Lin Yung-sung (林永頌) said.
The most common problem with “dinosaur judges” is their attitude, Lin said, citing his years of observing court proceedings and dealing with appeals.
Some judges speak loudly or harshly, while others mock or make fun of trial participants, or fail to give them a chance to speak, he said.
Photo: Chang Jui-chen, Taipei Times
A judge in Taoyuan told a defendant, on penalty of jail time, not to speak unless giving a confession, he said.
Next is rashness, Lin said.
Rash judges are overconfident and believe that reading the case before court begins is unnecessary, he said, adding that people can tell that the judge did not prepare and has no knowledge of the case.
These judges delay the trial by not asking crucial questions, he added.
Another common problem is judicial bias, Lin said.
Judges should be objective, gradually forming an inner conviction about the case as each court session leads up to their deliberation, but some have preconceptions due to their environment, personal or religious beliefs, or external pressures, he said.
Biased judges often interrupt litigants after one or two sessions in court, or even refute their claims, he said, adding that these judges have already made up their minds before hearing the case.
Some judges are incompetent — they are simply incapable of reviewing cases, Lin said.
Incompetent judges are usually not harsh, rash, or biased, rather they tend to be hardworking, but misinterpret cases and are unable to render judgements, he said.
They cannot provide a clear rationale for decisions and are clearly unqualified, he added.
Judges mostly learn from more experienced colleagues or other members on their panel, he said, adding that they have few opportunities to observe other courts or broaden their horizons.
The Judicial Yuan, to identify and get rid of so-called “dinosaur judges,” should study the complaints filed by litigants, he added.
Beijing finds “useful idiots” in every country as a means of confronting the West, an analyst said yesterday when commenting on a rumored meeting between former president Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) and Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) tomorrow. The meeting in Beijing would coincide with US President Joe Biden’s summit with Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida in Washington. Ma is being used as a pawn to arouse anti-Japan sentiment and advocate for unification with Taiwan, and could be discarded by the Chinese Communist Party at any time, said retired major general Yu Tsung-chi (余宗基), who served as the dean of the National Defense
SUPERIOR ERGONOMICS: The T112 combat rifle has improved functionality and stability during firing, and would replace the T91 the military is currently using The Taiwanese army’s new standard combat rifle, the T112, has entered mass production with 25,000 units in the pipeline, a military source close to the matter said. It debuted last year at the Taipei Aerospace & Defense Industry Exhibition, at which time were designated as XT112. The T112 combat rifle, which is scheduled to replace the T91 assault rifle the Republic of China Army currently uses, is a 5.56x54mm weapon weighing 3.5kg and measuring 940mm, with a fully extended telescoping stock, the Armaments Bureau’s 205th Arsenal said. Equipped with a single shot, two-round burst and fully automatic firing modes, the rifle is effective
The Modern Women’s Foundation yesterday urged prosecutors to charge entertainer Mickey Huang (黃子佼) and ensure he is punished more severely after being accused of sexual harassment and taking nude photographs of a minor. Prosecutors investigated Huang in June last year, but the Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office on Wednesday said he would not be prosecuted due to a lack of evidence. During the investigation, Huang was found to be in possession of seven sex videos featuring a minor, but was sentenced to two years deferred prosecution, and ordered to pay a fine of NT$1.2 million (US$37,433) and write a letter of repentance. While many
CASE IN POINT: After the entertainer Mickey Huang was found to be in possession of sex videos featuring a minor, the MOHW said it would never work with him again Premier Chen Chien-jen (陳建仁) yesterday said the government has a “zero tolerance” policy for sexual exploitation, and the Ministry of Health and Welfare (MOHW) said it would never again work with entertainer Mickey Huang (黃子佼) after he was accused of sexual harassment. Huang was investigated by prosecutors in June last year on suspicion of sexual harassment and taking nude photographs of a minor, but the Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office on Wednesday said he would not be prosecuted due to a lack of evidence. During the investigation, Huang was found to be in possession of seven sex videos featuring a minor, purchased