Liberty Times (LT): About NT$113.8 billion (US$3.53 billion) has been spent on the Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) system, which has been marred by controversy, including six missed deadlines. Where do you think the crux of the problem lies?
Cheng Wen-tsan (鄭文燦): Work on the planning stage of the airport MRT began as early as 1996 when it was decided that it would be built as a build-operate-transfer (BOT) project, with Ever Transit International Co (長生國際開發) winning the contract bid. Financing problems resulted in constant delays, and in 2002, the Bureau of High Speed Rail ended its relationship with Ever Transit, turning the system into a publicly funded project.
The Legislative Yuan then contracted work out to the bidder with the lowest cost proposal, with Japan’s Marubeni Corp and Kawasaki Heavy Industries winning a joint bid for the project.
Photo courtesy of Taoyuan Metro Corporation
After construction began in 2006, the section of track between Sanchong Station and Taipei Main Station was changed to an underground track, pushing back the estimated time of completion. Adding to this, the cost of materials and property increased and initial cost estimates caused incessant disputes between Marubeni and its subcontractors.
There were problems with the quality of the signaling system and this delayed progress on network testing. This, combined with substandard construction materials, resulted in the six delays.
Marubeni’s contract with the bureau was found to be illegal and a fine of NT$2.5 billion was imposed.
After I took office I learned of all the problems marring the project and realized we were not able to immediately solve them. The greatest responsibility lies with Marubeni, who won the contract with the lowest-cost bid, but along with its subcontractors produced a sub-par system. The bureau, which was supposed to be supervising the project, as well as Sinotech Engineering consultants, who were supposed to be overlooking construction, are also responsible for the delays.
LT: Have appropriate solutions to these disputes been found?
Cheng: The bureau since 2013 has known that operations would be delayed, as the overall network tests, pre-revenue service running tests and stability tests together produced 4,822 anomalies since that time. By November 2015, the system was still only running at 70 percent operational readiness, which in practical terms means six hours of delays out of a day’s 19 hours of operation.
Then-premier Mao Chi-kuo (毛治國) suggested to the Ministry of Transportation and Communications that the system be put into operation with a reduced number of trains running at lower speed, but to do so would have meant lowering standards and helping contractors cover up their errors. The city government’s hands were tied, all I could do was criticize the ministry for helping the contractors hide their mess and handing a crippled network to the city — this is very irresponsible.
Previous systems tests revealed three core problems with the airport MRT.
The first was that the signaling system would randomly go offline leaving the control room with no way to determine a train’s location — the train would become a ‘ghost train.’ When that happens an emergency braking system is engaged to prevent the possibility of collisions.
The second core problem was that from 2011 until last year the steel wheels have not been regularly grinding against tracks as you would see with operational trains, so the wheels are misshapen. The trains have also accumulated residue from lack of use and high levels of humidity, meaning that trains are unable to stop when entering stations.
The third problem was that an insulating spacer between the tracks and the foundation underneath was cracked in more than 6,000 places, with areas around corners especially affected. This resulted in signaling system failure, as well as affecting the spacer’s ability to absorb vibrations.
With the transition of government in May last year, the ministry established a committee tasked with supervising progress on the airport MRT, formed by officials from the Taoyuan City Government and representatives from Marubeni and Siemens, the main subcontractor.
The four began on-site inspections with the city acting as the supervising body at their request. The Taoyuan Metro assumed management of the 21 stations on the line, the train depot, the cars and the line’s central control room. The city government also sent representatives to Siemens to talk about the project and bring Siemens engineers to Taiwan and assist with signaling problems. These three core problems have largely been solved.
LT: When the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) was in office there was a lot of criticism directed at the airport by the pan-green camp. Now with a change in government it looks like the line will finally be given the green light this year. How do you answer accusations of partisanship?
Cheng: The line should have become operational in 2014. During the KMT administration there were two points in time where there was hope for launching operations on the line. The first was at the end of 2015 during the presidential elections. The second was in May last year, just before former president Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) stepped down. There was the hope that it would be one of the legacies of Ma’s administration.
I certainly did not oppose the opening of the line on grounds of it being during Ma’s presidency, it was a choice made based on safety concerns, as the line had not yet met safety standards. The line was far from the 99 percent operational safety standard required by the Mass Rapid Transit Act (大眾捷運法). Beginning line operations is a decision made based on science. It is a professional issue that has nothing to do with politics.
Due to a lack of trust between the KMT and the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), I met with former minister of transportation and communications Chen Jian-yu (陳建宇) on two occasions and signed a memorandum stating that I would not allow the line to operate until safety issues were resolved.
The memorandum also said that Taoyuan Metro would be reasonably compensated for financial losses incurred due to the delay in the line’s opening. After this, things proceeded smoothly.
Before that the KMT suspected the DPP of intentionally postponing line operations, while the DPP suspected the KMT of deceiving the public about safety concerns to have the line opened during Ma’s tenure. The two sides could not see eye-to-eye.
However, after the new government took office, the bureau and the city began working together and the problems were fixed one by one. We have finally achieved 99 percent operational usability.
LT: Reflecting on your experience with the airport MRT, what advice would you have for projects of this magnitude?
Cheng: I feel that large engineering projects should not be contracted to the lowest bidder.
Hiring such contractors will give rise to sloppy work, the use of shoddy materials and poor quality engineering. Work should be contracted to the most favorable bidder, to a company that is transparent, a company whose qualifications stand up to rigorous scrutiny. In this way there will not be suspicions of collusion and no need for subsequent bargaining, and it will be possible to avoid malpractice.
Companies like Germany’s Siemens and France’s Alstom that were competing with Marubeni for the bid were asking for about NT$2 billion more, but they came with highly competitive qualifications.
Conversely, lower-cost Marubeni used the wrong spacers under the tracks, and used low-grade electrical cabling and improper installation methods. Consequently there was fusion of the cables at 97 locations along the line. Other materials we found throughout the system were also of poor quality and were replaced after we discovered them.
We also have compliance management issues in dealing with international companies.
The government relies on supervision by professional construction management authorities, but they can only rely on supervision from manufacturers and cannot comprehensively supervise the project. This is one area of engineering that needs to be revolutionized.
Furthermore, if the construction team and the operators of the MRT are different companies, it is almost unavoidable that the two sides will be distrustful of each other.
I advise the government to establish a national engineering ministry that can fully take charge of MRT system projects. Just look at how New Taipei City established the Department of Rapid Transit Systems to build its own MRT stations, rather than allowing the Taipei City Government to handle the work. Having no projects to work on the Taipei City Government got permission to build the Taichung MRT system. Now we have separate MRT systems operating in Taipei, New Taipei City and Taoyuan. This is really strange. The system is bound to encounter problems.
LT: What will the opening of the airport MRT line mean for Taiwan’s development?
Cheng: The airport MRT line is 51km long. Aside from making that journey more convenient, the line will connect the three municipalities, bringing them within one hour of each other. And because the line will have stops for public gymnasiums, a branch of Chang Gung Memorial Hospital and Taoyuan and Taipei Taiwan High-Speed Rail stations, it will ease the pressure on the 9 million residents served by the metro. It will also be instrumental in spurring development of real estate and growth in the industrial zones. Specifically, the line will connect the New Taipei Industrial Park at station A3, the Hwa Ya Technology Park at station A7 and the Linkou Industrial Park at station A8.
The line will also connect Taoyuan’s Gueishan District (龜山), Lujhu District (蘆竹), Dayuan Township (大園) and Jhongli District (中壢) and eventually will connect to Taoyuan MRT’s green line, bringing considerable development opportunities to the city.
It is a milestone in “green” transportation for the three cities. The value of such public construction projects is in the promotion of “green” transportation. The airport MRT and the development of an underground metro system in Taoyuan will alleviate some of the congestion on the roads. If not for these developments there would be traffic jams every day, which building more expressways would be unable to solve.
Translated by William Hetherington, staff writer
Former Czech Republic-based Taiwanese researcher Cheng Yu-chin (鄭宇欽) has been sentenced to seven years in prison on espionage-related charges, China’s Ministry of State Security announced yesterday. China said Cheng was a spy for Taiwan who “masqueraded as a professor” and that he was previously an assistant to former Cabinet secretary-general Cho Jung-tai (卓榮泰). President-elect William Lai (賴清德) on Wednesday last week announced Cho would be his premier when Lai is inaugurated next month. Today is China’s “National Security Education Day.” The Chinese ministry yesterday released a video online showing arrests over the past 10 years of people alleged to be
THE HAWAII FACTOR: While a 1965 opinion said an attack on Hawaii would not trigger Article 5, the text of the treaty suggests the state is covered, the report says NATO could be drawn into a conflict in the Taiwan Strait if Chinese forces attacked the US mainland or Hawaii, a NATO Defense College report published on Monday says. The report, written by James Lee, an assistant research fellow at Academia Sinica’s Institute of European and American Studies, states that under certain conditions a Taiwan contingency could trigger Article 5 of NATO, under which an attack against any member of the alliance is considered an attack against all members, necessitating a response. Article 6 of the North Atlantic Treaty specifies that an armed attack in the territory of any member in Europe,
LIKE FAMILY: People now treat dogs and cats as family members. They receive the same medical treatments and tests as humans do, a veterinary association official said The number of pet dogs and cats in Taiwan has officially outnumbered the number of human newborns last year, data from the Ministry of Agriculture’s pet registration information system showed. As of last year, Taiwan had 94,544 registered pet dogs and 137,652 pet cats, the data showed. By contrast, 135,571 babies were born last year. Demand for medical care for pet animals has also risen. As of Feb. 29, there were 5,773 veterinarians in Taiwan, 3,993 of whom were for pet animals, statistics from the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Agency showed. In 2022, the nation had 3,077 pediatricians. As of last
XINJIANG: Officials are conducting a report into amending an existing law or to enact a special law to prohibit goods using forced labor Taiwan is mulling an amendment prohibiting the importation of goods using forced labor, similar to the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act (UFLPA) passed by the US Congress in 2021 that imposed limits on goods produced using forced labor in China’s Xinjiang region. A government official who wished to remain anonymous said yesterday that as the US customs law explicitly prohibits the importation of goods made using forced labor, in 2021 it passed the specialized UFLPA to limit the importation of cotton and other goods from China’s Xinjiang Uyghur region. Taiwan does not have the legal basis to prohibit the importation of goods