Sun, Sep 06, 2015 page3

• Chiang Kai-shek revered and reviled: report

  • By William Lowther / Staff reporter in Washington
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  The reputation of Chiang Kai-shek (蔣中正) is “paradoxically” falling in Taiwan and rising in China, according to a new article in Foreign Policy magazine.

  “While Beijing has expressed deeper respect for Chiang, his standing among the Taiwanese has steadily declined,” said the article by Richard Bernstein, a former Asia correspondent for Time and the New York Times.

  He said that during World War II it was sometimes hard to know who hated Chiang more — his sworn enemy the Chinese Communist Party and its leader Mao Zedong (毛澤東) — or the US.

  “It is a little-known fact that at least twice during the long course of the war, senior US officials considered assassinating Chiang, who was fighting the Japanese on the side of the Americans,” Bernstein said.

  He maintained that US Major General Joseph Stilwell plotted to throw Chiang out of a high-flying plane and senior US intelligence officer Carl F. Eifler planned to poison the Chinese nationalist commander with botulinum.

  In a May 1944 meeting at his headquarters in Burma, Stilwell told Eifler that he had changed his mind about eliminating Chiang and no action was taken, Bernstein said.

  This US “vexation” with Chiang persisted for decades, said the Foreign Policy article, “resulting in a widespread conventional wisdom that he was one of the great incompetents of history.”

  However, Bernstein argued that the view on Chiang in the US has softened in recent years.

  “There is the realization that getting rid of Chiang would in all likelihood have not produced a happy result,” he said.

  Bernstein said that Chiang mounted a brave, veritably suicidal resistance to the initial full-scale Japanese invasion of China in 1937 and his defiance tied down a million Japanese troops who otherwise would have been available to fight US forces.

  According to Bernstein, the 70th anniversary of the end of the war in the Pacific finds many in Beijing “seeming to recognize that Chiang was not only a patriot but that he deserved credit for the defeat of Japan.”

  He said that Chiang, who ruled Taiwan from 1949 to his death at the age of 87 in 1975, “exercised a regime of terrifying repression.”

  Bernstein said that tens of thousands of people, including much of the Taiwanese educated elite, were executed during in the White Terror era that lasted until 1987.

  Now, he said, Chiang is “less venerated” than before.

  Meanwhile, a more favorable view of Chiang emerging in China “fits China’s current goal, which is to lure Taiwan into such interdependency that a merging of the two societies will take place almost inevitably,” Bernstein wrote.

  “China’s recognition of Chiang’s heroic role in the anti-Japanese resistance is useful because anti-Japan enmity itself is a powerful symbol of Chinese unity. Even more useful to Beijing now is Chiang’s determined opposition to any suggestion of Taiwanese independence,” he added.

  Bernstein argued that the very reason Chiang’s reputation has declined in Taiwan is the same reason Beijing has refurbished it.

  “Despite the tremendous proliferation of contacts and relations between Taiwan and the mainland, Taiwanese are not buying the idea of unification,” Bernstein said.

  The “ruse of history” has turned Chiang into an ideological role model for Beijing — an embodiment of the goal of unification — even if the unification Chiang had in mind was not acceptable to Beijing, the article said.

  “Chiang’s loss of heroic status is a sign of the island’s drift toward a separate identity from that of the mainland. It will be a difficult one for Beijing to reverse, because it arises from something that China’s leaders do not generally have to take into account — a genuine expression of the popular will.”
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Suspect and two more dead after attacks in Taipei

  • 2

    Post office, driver’s license changes coming

  • 3

    Events get extra security after Taipei knife attacks

  • 4

    Car blast kills Russian general hours after US talks

  • 5

    Police to be deployed to crowded areas