Fri, Sep 05, 2014 page3

• Reproductive assistance scheme faces criticism

  • By Stacy Hsu / Staff reporter
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Several civic groups yesterday criticized the Health Promotion Administration’s recently announced subsidy scheme for infertile couples seeking assisted reproductive technologies, saying it is cost-ineffective, poorly designed and will further force the traditional burden of involuntary childbearing onto women.

  “Despite Taiwan’s relatively sophisticated assisted reproductive technologies, the average live birth rate per embryo transfer cycle over the past decade is merely 27 percent in this country, which means a reproductively challenged couple may have to undergo three to four rounds of in-vitro fertilization [IVF] to achieve a successful pregnancy,” Taiwan Women’s Link president Huang Sue-ying (黃淑英) told a press conference in Taipei yesterday.

  Huang said based on the live birth rate, nearly NT$670 million (US$22.3 million), or 70 percent of the total funding of NT$940 million for the three-year scheme would be “wasted on failed IVF treatments.”

  On average, each of the 4,000 babies that the administration expects would be born as the result of the scheme would cost the government as much as NT$235,000, Huang said.

  “At a time when the country’s mammoth government debt continues to pile up, is it appropriate for the administration to squander taxpayers’ money like that?” Huang added.

  Taiwan Occupational Safety and Health Link executive director Huang Yi-ling (黃怡翎) said many other factors aside from late marriage could cause fertility problems, such as overwork, long working hours and consumption of tainted foods.

  “Sometimes, infertility problems can be addressed simply by cutting back on workload and adopting a healthier lifestyle or dietary habit. However, the subsidy project could prompt doctors to encourage women to jump straight into IVF without making the effort to change the way they live and work,” Huang Yi-ling said.

  That could lead to the gradual “medicalization” of pregnancy in the country, and put women who are able to conceive naturally through the discomforts of IVF, which could put them at risk of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome, premature labor and infections after fetal reduction, she said.

  National Health Insurance Civic Surveillance Alliance spokesperson Eva Teng (滕西華) said infertility is not the only challenge facing young couples nowadays.

  “The first stage of the subsidy scheme is to cover fertility-challenged couples from low and middle-income households, offering them a maximum subsidy of NT$100,000 per year. However, even if some of them are lucky enough to get pregnant, where can they find the money to get proper pregnancy checkups, feed their kids or pay for their tuition fees?” Teng said.

  Teng said the subsidy scheme could also give the parents-in-law and spouses of women who have accepted their infertility an excuse to force or persuade them into receiving IVF treatments to fulfill their “traditional obligation” of carrying on their husbands’ family names.

  Dismissing the criticism, Health Promotion Administration Director Chiu Shu-ti (邱淑媞) said the country has done a lot to help financially disadvantaged parents with the costs of raising their children, but little effort has been made to assist reproductively challenged couples in fulfilling their parenthood dream.

  “While there are many women who do not want to have children, there are also people who have been forced to give up their hopes of being a mother due to financial reasons,” Chiu said.

  Chiu said the funding for the scheme would be sourced solely from the surcharges on cigarette sales, adding: “What is so wrong about wanting to help these women achieve their dream of having babies?”
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Sinner, Sabalenka reach Cincinnati quarter-finals

  • 2

    Lai urges people to vote ‘no’ in nuclear energy referendum

  • 3

    Ma pans Lai’s kowtowing to Japan

  • 4

    Taiwan bars officials from China military parade marking end of war with Japan

  • 5

    Singaporean PM quotes Taiwanese song in national speech