Two nuclear specialists from Europe yesterday recommended terminating the Fourth Nuclear Power Plant project, saying it presents many risks and would not have obtained construction and operating permits if it had been evaluated according to the EU’s nuclear safety standards.
The two experts were invited by Greenpeace Taiwan and co-authored a critical review of the stress-test reports on the power plant in Gongliao District (貢寮), New Taipei City (新北市), conducted by Taiwan Power Co (Taipower) and an independent peer review team from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development’s (OECD) Nuclear Energy Agency in March, as well as the national action plans by the Atomic Energy Council.
“We recommend terminating the Fourth Nuclear Power Plant project,” Oda Becker, one of the authors of the review, said at the the press conference in Taipei.
Photo: Wang Yi-sung, Taipei Times
Becker is a physicist from Germany who has been working in the field of nuclear safety for many years as an independent scientific consultant for clients including the Austrian government and several non-governmental organizations.
Given existing natural hazards, the design weaknesses and the deficiencies of the structure, system and components of the plant, as well as its short distance to New Taipei City, a severe accident would have disastrous consequences for millions of people, Becker said.
“It is impossible to reduce the risks to an acceptable safety level,” she said.
Becker said that Taipower’s assessment of the plant’s safety risks in the event of a disaster caused by earthquakes, floods or tsunamis were all underestimated, because the operator had either used insufficient or outdated for reference and therefore cannot accurately estimate the possible severe damage to the plant. Neither did it provide sufficient preventive measures to protect the plant against the most severe natural disasters.
Although Taipower and the government have often said they would immediately take “ultimate emergency measures” to abandon the plant to prevent a meltdown of the nuclear core, Becker questioned whether that would be effective in a worst-case scenario.
Since the proposed measures are activated by manpower and fuel damage can occur as fast as 1.6 hours after it is exposed above cooling-water level, it is questionable whether Taipower can activate the measures within such a short period of time, considering that it will be very difficult and dangerous to perform these measures after a big earthquake or tsunami.
Jan Haverkamp, a consultant on nuclear energy and energy policy for Greenpeace for many years, said that compared with the newer Advanced Boiling Water Reactors (ABWR) used in the EU, the outdated ABWR design of the Fourth Nuclear Power Plant has unaddressed issues, including whether it has protection against the impact of a large aircraft, a passive isolation condenser system, a core catcher, a passive containment cooling system and a dedicated power supply for severe accident management.
Commenting on the Atomic Energy Council’s plan to have the European Nuclear Safety Regulators Group (ENSREG) perform a stress-test on the Fourth Nuclear Power Plant in November, Haverkamp said that the ENSREG stress-test has a limited scope and can only assess some aspects of the plant’s safety problems, so the government and the public should not think that the plant would be completely safe if it passes the stress-test.
The chief mechanic in an air force unit from which an F-16 and its pilot went missing last week died on Sunday evening in what might have been a suicide, the Ministry of National Defense said yesterday. The ministry in a statement confirmed media reports that the mechanic, surnamed Huang (黃), “hurt himself” at a military barracks. Huang was taken to Hualien Armed Forces General Hospital after he was found unresponsive in the barracks, but doctors could not revive him, the ministry said. Huang served in the 26th Tactical Fighter Group of the 5th Tactical Fighter Wing, the same unit as the missing
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) last night said that it had no comment about reports that a senior US Navy officer had arrived in Taipei for a visit. Several media outlets reported that Rear Admiral Michael Studeman, director of intelligence of the US Indo-Pacific Command, arrived at Taipei International Airport (Songshan airport) on a special charter flight at about 7pm. The schedule of a “senior US official” in Taiwan would not be made public, the ministry said in a news release, without confirming the visit or the official’s identity. Interactions and exchanges between Taiwan and the US are common, and visits
‘VIRUS DIPLOMACY’: The nation’s expertise in handling COVID-19 was among the reasons that it should not be excluded from the WHO, the European Parliament said The European Parliament this week passed resolutions that support Taiwan’s bid to participate in the WHO and its intention to negotiate a trade pact with Taiwan. During its plenary session from Monday to Thursday, the parliament approved resolutions on the foreign policy consequences of the COVID-19 outbreak and the EU’s trade policy, parts of which were viewed as friendly toward Taiwan by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. In a statement yesterday, the ministry welcomed the passage of the resolutions and thanked the parliament for its support for Taiwan. In the first resolution, the parliament cited Beijing’s increasing threats to Taiwan, the crackdown on
NON-TYPICAL: Apart from Atsani, storms in autumn missed Taiwan, rainfall has been lower and average temperatures have been higher, a CWB forecaster said The current water shortage is expected to worsen in the next few months, with the Central Weather Bureau (CWB) yesterday forecasting a colder, dryer winter than normal. With winter starting next week, the bureau at a media briefing outlined the expected conditions through February and reviewed autumn’s significant weather events. Weather Forecast Center director Lu Kuo-cheng (呂國臣) said that autumn this year had three major characteristics: First, 13 tropical storms and typhoons formed from September to this month, up from 11 in the same period last year, Lu said. Apart from Atsani, for which sea and land alerts were issued in Taiwan, the tropical