Sun, Apr 11, 2010 - Page 3 News List

Public pension draws criticism

PROPPING UPAlthough the fund had been bleeding money for a decade, the fund’s manager said the global financial crisis was the main reason it had lost money


The management of the Public Service Pension Fund is not transparent and its risk control is lax, according to an investigation by the Control Yuan, which is in charge of monitoring the behavior of government officials.

In a report on the investigation presented on Friday, the Control Yuan said the fund, which manages the pensions of nearly 700,000 military personnel, civil servants and teachers, lost more than NT$86 billion (US$2.73 billion) because of the global financial crisis in 2008.

The Control Yuan launched an investigation after public misgivings over the viability of the fund’s investments.

Control Yuan member Chao Chang-ping (趙昌平) said that between 1999 and 2008, the fund’s portfolio had an average rate of return of minus 4.58 percent and lost more than NT$48.7 billion (US$1.54 billion).

The rate was lower than that of Taiwan’s weighted stock index average return of negative 0.92 percent and also lower than the average rate of return of 2.5 percent had the money been kept in a time deposit over the same period, Chao said.

He said the fund management board was trying to rationalize its long-term poor performance by citing the global financial crisis, which Chao instead described as a “failure to fulfill its duty of professional investment and management.”

The public also often wonders whether the government is “propping up stock prices or dumping stocks” on the stock market when the fund buys or sells stocks.

Chao said that “propping up sagging stocks” was not the mission of the pension fund.

If the fund can formulate a “take-profit point” or “stop-loss point” quantitative assessment, where specific targets for cutting losses or locking in profits are set, it would help dispel speculation about improper intervention by the fund management board, Chao said.

Meanwhile, Tsai Feng-ching (蔡豐清), deputy chairman of the fund management board, said regulations of the fund have followed set procedures and that the rate of return of 19.5 percent last year was the highest ever.

He also dismissed allegations that the fund was operated privately without supervision in a “secret room,” saying it was just an ordinary room set up to trade stocks located on the third floor of the Examination Yuan building.

The Control Yuan has questioned two former chairmen of the fund management board — Chu Wu-shien (朱武獻) and Chang Che-shen (張哲琛).

The report said Chu had intervened too much in the fund’s investments and set up certain professional equipment on his office desk, which the report described as improper.

Chu, a former head of the Ministry of Civil Service, said he set up the equipment because he was in charge of management of the fund and that he needed to pay attention to it from time to time.

This story has been viewed 3235 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top