When Next Media launched its “News-in-Motion” feature on the Chinese-language Apple Daily Web site last week, it was considered by some a novelty, a harbinger of animated news in Taiwan.
Within a week, however, it had managed to upset children’s and women’s rights groups, while others deemed it a challenge to the limits of freedom of expression.
The sensational content and graphic animation compelled representatives from 15 advocacy groups to stage a protest outside Next Media’s headquarters on Thursday to express their disapproval. On the same day, Taipei Mayor Hau Lung-bin (郝龍斌) fined the company NT$500,000 for the second consecutive day, accusing it of violating the Children and Juvenile Welfare Act (兒童及青少年福利法).
As the Apple Daily provides a barcode allowing access to “News-in-Motion,” schools in Taipei City have been ordered to cancel their subscriptions, while students and teachers have been asked not to bring the paper to schools. Computers on school campuses also blocked the IP addresses of “News-in-Motion” and residents of the city are now required to present their ID to be allowed to read the paper at city libraries.
The controversy surrounding “News-in-Motion” has placed tremendous pressure on the National Communications Commission (NCC), which is in the process of reviewing the group’s application to establish the Next TV network. The applications include plans for “News-in-Motion” to feature on its news channel.
NCC spokesperson Chen Jeng-chang (陳正倉) said that Next TV’s chances of securing an operating license for its news and information channels are very low, especially in the wake of the “News-in-Motion” scandal.
Chen said that the commission would review the three other channels that the group intends to set up — entertainment, sports and movie channels — this week, adding that commissioners are likely to approve them as they are “less controversial.”
Some view “News-in-Motion,” as well as the warnings issued by civic groups, as part of a plan weaved by Next Media Group chairman Jimmy Lai (黎智英), who has spent more than NT$1 billion (US$30 million) on the project.
Professor Hung Chen-ling (洪貞玲), of the Graduate Institute of Journalism at National Taiwan University, said the Apple Daily is known for complementing its crime stories with cartoons to help readers form a better impression of the scene.
“The response the newspaper has received over the years convinced Next Media that the same thing might also work on TV with animated news,” Hung said. “So ‘News-in-Motion’ was launched to test reactions from the market and the company will simply change direction if that backfires.”
The style of animation, however, received mixed reaction from professional animation producers and media researchers.
“In simulating a homicide, do we really have to tell the audience how the victim was cut to pieces or how blood was spattered at the crime scene?” asked Fong Tsai-shin (方彩欣), assistant professor in the Department of Applied Arts at Fu Jen Catholic University.
Fong also called for caution over the use of animated news.
“Words and images are different,” she said. “People can imagine the scene with the words they read, but when you show them the images, the imagination is gone. They begin to see it as fact.”
“When reporters give instructions to [animation] artists about what they want to show, they might also be adding some personal interpretations,” she said. “The amount of detail shown in animation could be determined by the kind of headlines they want the story to have.”
Fong said that animation can be used to enhance storytelling in certain types of news, such as those introducing a new technology. Even so, she said that reporters are not necessarily technology experts and are likely to provide wrong information. Besides, the quality of animated news may also be questionable given the limited time that animation artists have to reproduce the details and deliver their representations, she said.
Lai recruited King Pu-tsung (金溥聰), former Taipei City Government spokesperson, as CEO of Next TV because of King’s background in journalism. King, however, held the position for just four months and left in June. He said in an interview with the United Daily News that he did not agree with the use of animation to cover crime stories.
Chiang An-kuo (蔣安國), an associate professor at Fo Guang University, said he did not agree with NCC Chairwoman Bonnie Peng (彭芸) when she said that “News-in-Motion” is not news.
“To me, it is news, because it answers all the basic questions of news — who, what, where, when, why and how,” he said.
While he is aware that the NCC will soon address the concerns raised by the use of animated news, Chiang said it was important for the commission to shed its traditional mindset when dealing with emerging media.
“Animated news is a product of the multimedia age and the technology is [nothing more than] a tool,” he said, adding that we must avoid treating it as some “uncontrollable monster.”
Chiang said the problem with “News-In-Motion” is that it focuses on violence and sexual abuse, which is why advocates were offended.
“They [Next Media] simply have to adjust the content to meet public expectations,” he said.
Chiang said the NCC has neither the ability nor the time and resources to regulate the content of news media. The only thing the NCC can do is ask that media adhere to the rules.
Weber Lai (賴祥蔚), director of the Applied Media Arts Graduate Institute at National Taiwan University of Arts, said that in the short term the government could regulate animated news based on laws protecting women and children.
“The law almost always has to follow technology. Today it is animated news. Who knows what will come next? The commission can only stipulate some general guidelines to regulate new media content in the long run.”
As online content can be downloaded on cellphones, said Jason Lin (林一平), professor at National Chiao Tung University’s Department of Computer Science, the NCC must establish a rating system for online content.
The manufacture of the remaining 28 M1A2T Abrams tanks Taiwan purchased from the US has recently been completed, and they are expected to be delivered within the next one to two months, a source said yesterday. The Ministry of National Defense is arranging cargo ships to transport the tanks to Taiwan as soon as possible, said the source, who is familiar with the matter. The estimated arrival time ranges from late this month to early next month, the source said. The 28 Abrams tanks make up the third and final batch of a total of 108 tanks, valued at about NT$40.5 billion
A group from the Taiwanese Designers in Australia association yesterday represented Taiwan at the Midsumma Pride March in Melbourne. The march, held in the St. Kilda suburb, is the city’s largest LGBTQIA+ parade and the flagship event of the annual Midsumma Festival. It attracted more than 45,000 spectators who supported the 400 groups and 10,000 marchers that participated this year, the association said. Taiwanese Designers said they organized a team to march for Taiwan this year, joining politicians, government agencies, professionals and community organizations in showing support for LGBTQIA+ people and diverse communities. As the first country in Asia to legalize same-sex
Travel agencies in Taiwan are working to secure alternative flights for travelers bound for New Zealand for the Lunar New Year holiday, as Air New Zealand workers are set to strike next week. The airline said that it has confirmed that the planned industrial action by its international wide-body cabin crew would go ahead on Thursday and Friday next week. While the Auckland-based carrier pledged to take reasonable measures to mitigate the impact of the workers’ strike, an Air New Zealand flight arriving at Taipei from Auckland on Thursday and another flight departing from Taipei for Auckland on Saturday would have to
MOTIVES QUESTIONED The PLA considers Xi’s policies toward Taiwan to be driven by personal considerations rather than military assessment, the Epoch Times reports Chinese President Xi Jinping’s (習近平) latest purge of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) leadership might have been prompted by the military’s opposition to plans of invading Taiwan, the Epoch Times said. The Chinese military opposes waging war against Taiwan by a large consensus, putting it at odds with Xi’s vision, the Falun Gong-affiliated daily said in a report on Thursday, citing anonymous sources with insight into the PLA’s inner workings. The opposition is not the opinion of a few generals, but a widely shared view among the PLA cadre, the Epoch Times cited them as saying. “Chinese forces know full well that
RSS