A critical State Department report on the operations of the American Institute in Taiwan's (AIT) Taipei office has found serious shortcomings in the management style of Director Douglas Paal, calling staff morale low and citing an inability to accurately explain the situation in Taiwan to the US government.
Minister of Foreign Affairs Mark Chen (
The evaluation report, by the department's inspector-general (IG), was kept secret, although a publicly-available summary was made available by the department, which virtually ignores the negative comments of the full report. But people who have read the full report say it is scathing in its evaluation of several aspects of Paal's management.
MEDIA LEAK
The evaluation report was first disclosed by the Chinese-language daily China Times. Chen yesterday said that he learned of the information from the media.
"I have played [golf] with him several times. I know he is quite a straightforward man. As for the others, it is inappropriate for me to make any comment," Chen said.
Paal has made specific contributions to US-Taiwan relations, Chen added.
Of the 48 points used to evaluate Paal and the office, the de facto US ambassador scored worst in the area of morale, which was considered the most serious problem facing the office.
The investigation found that Paal was unduly "strong handed" and refused to listen to dissenting views among his aides.
"He would not allow dissenting views. He would even suppress dissenting views. So the US government may not have had a comprehensive, well-rounded view of the situation in Taiwan. It would make it difficult to have a balanced view of Taiwan," said one person who had access to the report.
The investigators found Paal to be ineffective in dealing with the Chen Shui-bian (
Even before Paal took over the post in 2002, he was faced with problems with the Chen government, the report said. It cited problems he had with Taiwan officials in the past, and said he "was not welcomed" when he arrived in Taipei.
Because of this, he did not really become a successful and effective representative of the US government, which made it difficult for him to influence the actions of Chen or the DPP government, the IG investigators found.
In one of its only positive comments on Paal, the report found him able to accurately relay US government policy to Chen and his government, which resulted in a moderation of the more extreme aspects of Chen's policies and positions in recent years. The investigators concluded that as a result, Taiwan was able to rely on his version of US policy.
Paal was to have retired from his AIT position in July with the expectation that he would be assigned to another diplomatic post by the Bush administration. He had been hoping to be named the new ambassador to Singapore, or perhaps South Korea. However, according to Washington sources, Paal was rejected for all the diplomatic posts available.
As a result, he reportedly was allowed to stay on until December, when he would be eligible for a full State Department pension upon retirement.
The department IG investigation covered all three AIT offices, in Taipei, Kaohsiung and Washington. The fieldwork was conducted from Feb. 28 through March 21 this year, and the summary of the report was issued on the department's Web site on July 12. It was described as a routine investigation that was conducted annually to assess AIT's performance and efficiency.
The findings reported in the secret full report, however, became known only this week. A spokeswoman for the department's IG office had no comment on the contents of the report, which was labeled "unclassified" but "sensitive" and allowed only limited internal distribution.
METHODOLOGY
The investigators used three methods to come to their conclusions: a questionnaire among AIT staffers, face-to-face interviews and direct observation of the operation of the offices.
The investigation was conducted during a critical period in US-Taiwan-China triangular relations, when good two-way communications was especially important.
It wasn't long after the investigators finished their work that the back-to-back trips to Beijing by opposition politicians former Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) chairman Lien Chan (
In the public summary of the IG report, the office said that it "determined the director's leadership had some shortcomings," but went no further in its criticism of Paal. It also found shortcomings in the office's physical facilities.
additional reporting by Shih Hsiu-chuan
POLAM KOPITIAM CASE: Of the two people still in hospital, one has undergone a liver transplant and is improving, while the other is being evaluated for a liver transplant A fourth person has died from bongkrek acid poisoning linked to the Polam Kopitiam (寶林茶室) restaurant in Taipei’s Far Eastern Sogo Xinyi A13 Department Store, the Ministry of Health and Welfare said yesterday, as two other people remain seriously ill in hospital. The first death was reported on March 24. The man had been 39 years old and had eaten at the restaurant on March 22. As more cases of suspected food poisoning involving people who had eaten at the restaurant were reported by hospitals on March 26, the ministry and the Taipei Department of Health launched an investigation. The Food and
The long-awaited Taichung aquarium is expected to open next year after more than a decade of development. The building in Cingshui District (清水) is to feature a large ocean aquarium on the first floor, coral display area on the second floor, a jellyfish tank and Dajia River (大甲溪) basin display on the third, a river estuary display and restaurant on the fourth, and a cafe and garden on the fifth. As it is near Wuci Fishing Port (梧棲漁港), many are expecting the opening of the aquarium to bring more tourism to the harbor. Speaking at the city council on Monday, Taichung City Councilor
A fourth person has died in a food poisoning outbreak linked to the Xinyi (信義) branch of Malaysian restaurant chain Polam Kopitiam (寶林茶室) in Taipei, Deputy Minister of Health and Welfare Victor Wang (王必勝) said on Monday. It was the second fatality in three days, after another was announced on Saturday. The 40-year-old woman experienced multiple organ failure in the early hours on Monday, and the family decided not to undergo emergency resuscitation, Wang said. She initially showed signs of improvement after seeking medical treatment for nausea, vomiting and diarrhea, but her condition worsened due to an infection, he said. Two others who
Taiwanese should be mindful when visiting China, as Beijing in July is likely to tighten the implementation of policies on national security following the introduction of two regulations, a researcher said on Saturday. China on Friday unveiled the regulations governing the law enforcement and judicial activities of national security agencies. They would help crack down on “illegal” and “criminal” activities that Beijing considers to be endangering national security, according to reports by China’s state media. The definition of what constitutes a national security threat in China is vague, Taiwan Thinktank researcher Wu Se-chih (吳瑟致) said. The two procedural regulations are to provide Chinese