The Aviation Safety Counsel (ASC) yesterday published its findings in a report on the China Airlines plane that broke into pieces over the sea between Taiwan and Hong Kong in May 2002. The report blamed cracks in the plane's fuselage, as well as poor maintenance as the cause of the crash that killed all 225 passengers on board.
On May 25, 2002, the CAL flight CI-611, a Boeing 747-200 jumbo jet, broke apart and plunged into the Taiwan Strait 23 nautical miles northeast of Penghu County shortly after takeoff from CKS International Airport.
PHOTO: CNA
After more than two years of analyzing information gathered from the plane's flight data recorder, air traffic control, wreckage distribution and a reconstructed section of the fuselage, the ASC concluded that a 180.34cm crack on the fuselage resulted in the in-flight breakup at the altitude of 10,668m, killing 206 passengers and 19 crew members.
According to the ASC, the fatigue crack in the aircraft could be dated back to an accident that took place 25 years ago. On Feb. 7, 1980, the aircraft suffered damage when its tail touched the ground while landing in Hong Kong. Although the damaged plane was shipped back to Taiwan and underwent temporary repairs the day after the incident, permanent repairs conducted by the nation's largest carrier, China Airlines, were flawed.
"China Airlines did not repair the [damage] in accordance with Boeing's [structural repair manual]. The damaged skin should have been either trimmed or removed as the standard procedure required. But the repairs did not extend sufficiently beyond the damaged area and thus, did not restore structural strength," said ASC Chairman Kay Yong (
The ASC believes that the pre-existing fissures on scratched surface, and after not having been properly fixed, deepened and grew to a 180.34cm crack as a result of pressurization and de-pressurization during flights.
"A crack measuring 180.34cm in length is long enough to cause structural separation in the fuselage. It is the root cause of the in-flight breakup of the aircraft," said Thomas Wang (王興中) head of the ASC's investigation team.
Although the ASC could not confirm exactly when the fuselage came apart, the Cabinet-level aviation authority criticized the air carrier for not finding the damage to the aging aircraft in regular checkups over the past 25 years.
CAL officials, however, rebuked the ASC's report and questioned its findings.
"Since the section of the aircraft that is suspected of causing the crash was not found, the information is not conclusive enough to determine the exact cause of the accident," CAL said in a statement.
"The ASC said that they have found 75 percent of the aircraft, but they actually collected only 50 percent of the damaged section 46, the key part needed to determine the cause of the crash," said CAL spokesman Roger Hen (
While openly disputing the ASC's findings, the air carrier objected to the claim that maintenance oversight was also to blame.
"Our checkups are conducted in compliance with the SRM [structural repair manual]. Boeing stated clearly that if repairs are done in accordance with the SRM, there is no need to report it to the aircraft manufacturer," Hen said.
According to the regulations of Boeing's Repair Assessment Program, aircraft should have undergone inspections upon reaching of 22,000 flights. Yet the accident occurred when the jet completed its 21,398th flight, a few times of landing and take-off away from the maintenance program's maximum threshold.
Civil Aeronautics Administration (CAA) slammed that the ASC's report, accusing the agency of failing to find the actual cause of the crash.
"How could the ASC jump hastily its conclusions when half of the [section in question] has yet to be found?" said CAA director-general Billy Chang (張國政).
Taiwan would benefit from more integrated military strategies and deployments if the US and its allies treat the East China Sea, the Taiwan Strait and the South China Sea as a “single theater of operations,” a Taiwanese military expert said yesterday. Shen Ming-shih (沈明室), a researcher at the Institute for National Defense and Security Research, said he made the assessment after two Japanese military experts warned of emerging threats from China based on a drill conducted this month by the Chinese People’s Liberation Army’s (PLA) Eastern Theater Command. Japan Institute for National Fundamentals researcher Maki Nakagawa said the drill differed from the
‘WORSE THAN COMMUNISTS’: President William Lai has cracked down on his political enemies and has attempted to exterminate all opposition forces, the chairman said The legislature would motion for a presidential recall after May 20, Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairman Eric Chu (朱立倫) said yesterday at a protest themed “against green communists and dictatorship” in Taipei. Taiwan is supposed to be a peaceful homeland where people are united, but President William Lai (賴清德) has been polarizing and tearing apart society since his inauguration, Chu said. Lai must show his commitment to his job, otherwise a referendum could be initiated to recall him, he said. Democracy means the rule of the people, not the rule of the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), but Lai has failed to fulfill his
A fugitive in a suspected cosmetic surgery fraud case today returned to Taiwan from Canada, after being wanted for six years. Internet celebrity Su Chen-tuan (蘇陳端), known as Lady Nai Nai (貴婦奈奈), and her former boyfriend, plastic surgeon Paul Huang (黃博健), allegedly defrauded clients and friends of about NT$1 billion (US$30.66 million). Su was put on a wanted list in 2019 when she lived in Toronto, Canada, after failing to respond to subpoenas and arrest warrants from the Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office. Su arrived at Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport at 5am today on an EVA Air flight accompanied by a
A rally held by opposition parties yesterday demonstrates that Taiwan is a democratic country, President William Lai (賴清德) said yesterday, adding that if opposition parties really want to fight dictatorship, they should fight it on Tiananmen Square in Beijing. The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) held a protest with the theme “against green communists and dictatorship,” and was joined by the Taiwan People’s Party. Lai said the opposition parties are against what they called the “green communists,” but do not fight against the “Chinese communists,” adding that if they really want to fight dictatorship, they should go to the right place and face
RSS