Soong Mayling (
One clue to this could be gleaned simply by looking at the guest list.
The Minister of National Defense, the heads of the China Youth Corps and the National Women's League and KMT heavyweights all attended the historical conference on Madame Chiang Kai-shek's life and times. And her grandson, KMT secretary-general John Chang (
The fact that politicians, historians and the general public disagree on what her contribution actually was, only serves to show that Madame Chiang Kai-shek and the circles she moved in continue to fascinate people.
"People love her, people hate her, they think she's a goddess, a dragon lady ... In the States you have the Kennedys, and England has a royal family ... [the Soongs] are very similar," said Laura Tyson, a journalist researching a biography of Madame Chiang.
Born into history
A member of one of China's most powerful and wealthy families, foreign educated, sister to a former premier and finance minister, sister-in-law to Sun Yat-sen (孫???s) and another former premier, Soong -- who may soon see her third century -- has spent much of her life chained to China's, and Taiwan's, history.
What her role actually was, however, is perhaps more difficult to pin down.
"She's a very complicated, multidimensional woman," said Lin Po-wen (
Born in Guangdong province in 1897 to former Methodist missionary Charles Jones Soong (宋?l?? and his wife, Soong Mei-ling was one of the few women during the era to receive formal education. She spent 10 years in the US, and graduated from Wellesley College in 1917.
Ten years later, her marriage to Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek (
During World War II, she played an active role in drawing foreign attention to the Chinese war of resistance against the Japanese, acting as a spokesperson for the KMT regime and forming an important part of its image abroad.
She befriended Time and Life magazine publisher Henry Luce, who became the core of the US "China lobby," and was a frequent guest of Eleanor and Franklin Roosevelt at the White House.
Many of the presenters at the conference were old friends, such as Yan Cho-yun (
"I think she's a great woman," said Alex Wen-yi Cho (
"When you look at her in the context of her era she was quite revolutionary. An educated woman," said Diana Lary, a military and social historian at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver who spoke at the conference.
"The attention she drew to the war in China had an amazing impact abroad," she said.
Other historians have perhaps been less kind to Madame Chiang than those speaking at the conference this week.
Sterling Seagrave, whose 1985 book The Soong Dynasty chronicles the history of her family, describes her as a silently complicit partner in her husband's regime who was "politically at home on the far right."
"She was full of ideas and energy, but there was a limit to what she could achieve by herself. Chiang proffered power," Seagraves wrote, citing the Chinese adage about the three Soong sisters that "one loved money, one loved power and one loved China."
Tyson said controversy persists over Soong's political views during the Chiang era.
"She talked about how wonderful democracy was, but tolerated a regime that was anything but democratic," she said.
But the image of Soong Mei-ling as an ambitious political player is perhaps an oversimplified one, Tyson said.
"I don't think she was personally or politically ambitious ... she had charisma, she had charm, she was a marvellous talker ... I think she knew that and she used that," Tyson said.
Soong's recent reclusivity doesn't make it easy to clarify these and other questions about her role in many historical developments.
Since Soong moved to New York in 1975, after her husband's death, she and her family have closely guarded her privacy and limited her contact with the media.
Her rare public appearances are for her pet causes, such as the National Palace Museum's travelling exhibition at the Metropolitan Museum in New York in 1996.
`The Eternal Madame'
Although she has been largely out of sight for the last 25 years, she is not out of mind for the people at this week's conference.
"Mainlanders, even Taiwanese have a nostalgic feeling toward Soong Mei-ling, but it's not worship," Lin said.
It's impossible to tell whether Chiang Kai-shek's former secretary Chin Hsiao-yi (
But nostalgia was certainly thick in the air, where recordings of her speeches in English played beside cases full of her military decorations.
Older mainlanders at the conference wandered past photographs from the KMT's archives bearing the heading "The Eternal Madame," occasionally pointing out old friends and elaborating on connections between political players.
Speeches and comments at the conference were peppered with personal anecdotes and thick with emotion. One conference guest suggested compiling a book or album of her quotations as had been done for her sister Soong Ching-ling (
Despite the reverence shown at the conference, Soong's influence is now, observers said, largely historical.
"Her age, her dynasty is gone," said Lin.
BUSY DAY: The same day the USS ‘Barry’ passed through the Strait, Taiwan was ending its Han Kuang military exercises, while China said it conducted an exercise near Taiwan A US Navy ship on Friday sailed through the Taiwan Strait, marking the ninth time a US military vessel has transited the Strait since US President Joe Biden took office in January. The USS Barry, an Arleigh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer, conducted a “routine” transit through the Strait, the US Navy said in a statement, adding that the journey through international waters was conducted “in accordance with international law.” “The ship’s transit through the Taiwan Strait demonstrates the US’ commitment to a free and open Indo-Pacific,” the US Navy said. “The United States military flies, sails and operates anywhere international law allows.” The Ministry
PINGTUNG EXERCISE: The pilots tested their ability to land on the 24m-wide provincial highway, preparing for a scenario in which dedicated airstrips are damaged Emergency landing and takeoff drills for military aircraft were held on a provincial highway for the first time early yesterday as part of Taiwan’s Han Kuang military exercises, testing the ability of pilots and aircraft to land on narrow roads were airstrips to be damaged. The drill began at 6:30am on a 2.26km section of Provincial Highway No. 1 linking Pingtung County’s Jiadong (佳冬) and Fangliao (枋寮) townships. An Indigenous Defense Fighter, an F-16V, a Mirage 2000-5 and an E-2K early warning aircraft participated. The planes landed on the highway in that order at 6:30am, 6:32am, 6:34am and 6:36am before taking off at
FRUIT SPAT: The COA said China had not given evidence for halting wax and custard apple imports, adding that it would spend NT$1bn on promoting sales of the fruit Taipei threatened to take China to the WTO yesterday after Beijing said it would suspend wax apple and custard apple imports from Taiwan due to pest concerns. China’s customs administration earlier yesterday said it had repeatedly found pests called Planococcus minor, a type of mealybug, on wax and custard apples from Taiwan. It asked its Guangdong branch and all affiliated offices to stop clearing the products from today. China had acted unilaterally, without providing scientific evidence, Council of Agriculture (COA) Minister Chen Chi-chung (陳吉仲) told a news conference, criticizing the announcement’s timing, as it came during the Mid-Autumn Festival, celebrated in Taiwan
‘ONE-OFF’ DEAL: Australia would become the only state, after Britain, that the US has helped to build a nuclear fleet, which a White House official called ‘unique’ The US on Wednesday announced a new alliance with Australia and Britain to strengthen military capabilities in the face of a rising China, with Canberra to receive a nuclear submarine fleet and US cruise missiles. US President Joe Biden, Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison and British Prime Minister Boris Johnson did not mention China in unveiling their alliance, dubbed AUKUS — but their intent was clear, and their announcement prompted fury in Beijing. China yesterday condemned the deal as an “extremely irresponsible” threat to stability in the region. The agreement also left Paris furious, as Australia scrapped a US$40 billion 2016 deal to