Mon, Dec 13, 2004 page1

• US scholars cite need to fight foreign media's `spin'

  OUTSIDE VIEW Noting the foreign media's coverage of the weekend's legislative poll, visiting academics said it is in Taiwan's interests to challenge their interpretations

  • By Huang Tai-lin / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Stating that many foreign media reports had incorrectly interpreted Saturday's election as a referendum on independence, US academics yesterday said the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) government must fight the foreign media's spin on events.

  The US scholars made the remark yesterday while visiting with Wu A-ming (吳阿明), Board Chairman of the Liberty Times, a sister newspaper of the Taipei Times.

  "One thing which I found the western media got wrong, particularly CNN, was that they viewed this election as referendum on independence," said June Dreyer, chair of the Department of Political Science of the University of Miami. "But to us, it does not seem that way."

  The pan-blue camp, consisting of the pro-unification Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and the People First Party (PFP), retained its legislative majority in Saturday's election, winning a total of 114 seats. The DPP and its small political ally, the Taiwan Solidarity Union (TSU), fell short of their goal to gain a majority in the new legislature.

  Several foreign media outlets, such as CNN, reported Saturday's electoral result as the people of Taiwan saying no to a new mandate to accelerate President Chen Shui-bian's (陳水扁) pro-independence policies.

  "It is very much not in Taiwan's interest to allow the foreign spin to prevail. And the foreign spin is -- Chen loses, China won," said Edward Friedman, a political science professor at the University of Wisconsin.

  Battling `spin'

  "I think the most important thing, in terms of Taiwan's standing in the world and its relationship to the world, is to fight this battle of `spin.'"

  Friedman said the most frightening thing he found about this the international media's spin on the events was that "it is not just CNN, the Asian Wall Street Journal but everyone."

  "Even an Arab newspaper wrote it the same way," Friedman said, adding that although many foreign press outlets had sent reporters to Taiwan to cover the weekend's election, "their heads never, somehow, get involved with Taiwan's reality."

  Friedman attributed it to "China's power and China's ability to define reality."

  Another observation the US scholars noted was incorrectly reported in the foreign media's coverage of the election was the mood of the population in the lead-up to the election.

  "I listen to CNN and I read the western newspapers and I was amazed at how wrong they were, because they were saying in the days before the election, Taiwan was very tense. And we didn't find it tense at all," she said.

  Commenting on the electoral result, Dreyer noted some positive elements of the result.

  "If [US President] George Bush and the American State Department think this is a referendum on independence and it failed ... they will be less nervous and they will not give warnings to Taiwan, will not have [Secretary of State] Colin Powell saying that we are for unification and things like that," Dreyer said.

  Breathing space

  "So this will give Taiwan some breathing space and meanwhile, of course, we all understand that pro-localization continues to take place and the longer it can take place without George Bush or the State Department noticing, the better," she said.

  Regarding to issues Chen promoted during the campaign such as rectifying the names of government agencies and state-own enterprises to "Taiwan," Dreyer said the administration should "do it and do it slowly." "It would probably be less upsetting to the American government," she said.

  Friedman said the name-change issue was not a new issue.

  When Chiang Kai-shek's (蔣介石) army came to Taiwan, he felt, after crushing the people, the number one problem was inflation. So they put out money to control it, called what -- the New Taiwan Dollar," Friedman said.

  "So, in terms of the use of the word Taiwan to establish sovereignty, the truth is it goes back to Chiang Kai-shek."

  The process of Taiwanization had been expanding in the 1970s under Chiang, when he allowed more seats for Taiwan in the legislature, and in the 1980s under his son, Chiang Ching-kuo (蔣經國), Friedman said.

  Conspiracy

  "It was an ordinary piece of KMT politics of being on Taiwan, and the name change issue is not a recent conspiracy, it is a piece of the reality of being on Taiwan," he said.

  "After all, the American office here is the American Institution in Taiwan and the American act is called the Taiwan Relations Act," he said.

  Questioned on the US' sensitivity over the name-change issue, Friedman attributed it to "the rise of Chinese power."

  "China not wanting to see it happen, and China worrying about Taiwan identification (台灣認同) and Taiwan ethnic identification (台灣民族認同) and essentially trying to get the United States to act for China to stop Taiwan ethnic identification," Friedman said.

  Friedman thinks the reason the US does this for China relates to the international situation following 911 and the Iraq invasion.

  Proliferation

  "With China's rise as an economic power and the feeling that you need China for many many things, not just North Korea, proliferation, and Pakistan, but lots of things, China each time would say to the US `but this costs us [domestically] to do this, and what are you going to do for us?" he said.

  "So when I go back home I'll say to my people that we gained something too, and the US has been accepting that line and acting for Beijing in terms of its feeling of its general international situation," Friedman said.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Typhoon could trigger sea warning, hit central Taiwan

  • 2

    Cancelations announced as sea warning issued for Typhoon Fung-wong

  • 3

    Exports soar 49.7% to all-time high

  • 4

    Fung-wong approaches Taiwan, batters Philippines

  • 5

    Tropical storm expected to strengthen into typhoon later today