May 21 to May 27
Cars were overturned, furniture was destroyed and an American flag was ripped and thrown off the second floor balcony of the then-US embassy in Taipei. The angry crowd wreaked havoc on the building for nearly 10 hours before the authorities dispersed the protesters — leading the Americans to wonder if the May 24, 1957 attack was orchestrated by the government.
“In a city notorious for its elaborate secret services and policing agencies ... why was a riot such as this permitted to go unchecked for hours?” writes George Kerr in Formosa Betrayed, noting that certain people were warned of possible trouble days in advance and that the incident happened while president Chiang Kai-shek (蔣介石) was on a mountain retreat, US Ambassador Karl Rankin was in Hong Kong and the army’s chief officers were visiting the offshore islands.
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
The incident was in response to the killing of government employee Liu Tzu-jan (劉自然) by US soldier Robert Reynolds, who allegedly discovered Lee in his garden peeping at his wife, who was taking a shower. Reynolds claims that Lee attacked first with a stick, and he fired two fatal shots in response. There were no witnesses with little evidence, and Reynolds was acquitted by an American military court to the applause of Americans in the courtroom and flown out of the country on May 23.
The United Daily News (聯合報) reported that the nation was in shock over the ruling, and that “resentment and agitation has permeated every corner of society.”
The paper further stated in an editorial, “Protesting the US Army’s Disdain for Human Rights” (抗議美軍蔑視人權): “We can’t help but question US law and the Americans’ lofty ideals of protecting human rights. Otherwise, it simply means that the life of an American has far more value than one of [ours]. Liu is dead, and Reynolds runs free. Isn’t that the bloody truth?”
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
Dressed in black, Liu’s widow stood in front of the embassy the next morning to protest the ruling. This attracted a crowd as things quickly escalated and went out of control.
Both Chiang and Rankin later reflected on the incident. Chiang’s public speech made that July regarding the riots can be found in the National Central Library, while Rankin provides an account in his memoir, China Assignment.
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons :
Rankin had returned to Taiwan during a lull in the riots. The embassy was empty then, but the crowd was still there, throwing stones at his car.
“The buildings were gutted. Everything inside that could be lifted had been thrown out the doors and windows … my personal car was on its side, with a safe dropped on it from the floor above,” he writes. “The police begged us to leave. There were very few of them, and they feared that a new incursion might start at any moment.”
Rankin notes that he was able to account for all his staff by 7pm that night — they had avoided harm by hiding in an air raid shelter and were later escorted out by the police. Only one was hospitalized.
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
Rankin later told US news station CBS that Taiwanese officials were too slow in providing adequate protection, and asked for “full compensation and an adequate apology.”
In the following weeks, 111 people were arrested, with about 40 receiving sentences of six months to one year. Rankin does not speak of any conspiracy or premeditation in his account.
“My eventual conclusions were quite simple,” he writes. “There had been no serious public disorder in Taiwan for 10 years, and internal security had become lax. The city authorities were not prepared to deal with a large mob, either in terms of equipment or numbers of police.”
He also notes that the only people who could have given orders for the army to act — namely Chiang and the Minister of Defense — were not available at that time.
“We were satisfied that while some of Liu’s friends and his widow had planned a small demonstration in the hope of a cash settlement from the US, the outbreak of violence had been spontaneous,” he concludes.
THE GENERALISSIMO SPEAKS
Of course, Chiang’s speech begins with a bunch of anti-Communist rhetoric, but he quickly cut to the chase: “In the past six months, not only have we not been able to achieve any concrete achievements, we have exposed the weaknesses in all levels of our government and brought the greatest shame to our country in 60 years — the ignorant, useless, shameless and pathetic riots that took place in Taipei on May 24.”
He chastises the people and his staff in a long tirade, saying that it has greatly affected the goal of retaking China by attacking their American allies.
“To be honest, we cannot withstand another blow to our international standing, which has turned us into the laughingstock of the world,” he says. “I personally believe that after this incident, our international friends have less trust in us, and domestically, this will be a great chance for people who oppose our party to denounce us.”
Chiang says that the riots could have been avoided if the military police had taken action once people started gathering outside the embassy and contacted their superiors immediately, adding that nothing was reported until the attacks were already under way. He was especially angry that the Taipei Police Department never made an official report to City Hall, greatly slowing the spread of information to other departments. He blasted the convoluted chain of command within the government structure, and also denounced the government’s incompetence in dealing with the immediate aftermath of Liu’s killing, leading to the Americans taking over the investigation and acquitting Reynolds of wrongdoing.
The rest of the speech is a long and winding lecture on how the government has grown idle since retreating to Taiwan and that it should always stay alert and keep up with modern ideas and technology because they must not forget the ultimate goal of defeating the Communists.
“If all departments can follow even 50 percent of my instructions and teachings over the past seven years, I believe that there will not be another May 24 Incident,” he says.
At the time of the incident, Taiwan and the US were still hammering out the details of the Status of Forces Agreement with the Republic of China, which included whether US staff and soldiers were immune from Taiwanese jurisdiction.
Law professor Chiu Hung-dah (丘宏達) writes in a study on the agreement that the US agreed that Taiwan would have jurisdiction over “members of the US armed forces or civilian component and their dependents.” However, Taiwan waived its primary rights to exercise jurisdiction except for certain cases, including security offenses against the government and offenses against Taiwanese citizens, including murder, robbery and rape.
Check out the following link for a video of the riots by the Associated Press: www.youtube.com/watch?v=VANq_EXvZj4
Taiwan in Time, a column about Taiwan’s history that is published every Sunday, spotlights important or interesting events around the nation that have anniversaries this week.
With listicles of local attractions including Costco and numerous children’s playgrounds, I was not expecting much. Opened on Jan. 31, the Taipei MRT’s Circular Line, or Yellow Line, made life in the nation’s capital even more convenient. But judging from Internet search results, it hasn’t opened up many new tourism opportunities, unsurprising as the route mostly crosses densely populated areas and industrial parks. Places like a sports stadium with rainbow colored bleachers perfect for Instagram selfies wouldn’t do it for me either, and it’s pointless to list attractions at the connecting stops that have existed for years. As a history nerd, there
June 1 to June 7 In February 1988, Robert Wu (吳清友) set aside NT$17.5 million to purchase two Henry Moore sculptures from London’s Marlborough Gallery. He never bought the pieces. Feeling slighted that the gallery manager initially looked down on him as a Taiwanese, he decided that night to use the money to open his own art space back home. “Without selling any art, that money could support the gallery for four years. If I feature one artist per month, that provides a stage for at least 100 artists,” Wu said in the book Eslite Time (誠品時光) by Lin Ching-yi (林靜宜).
Captain Wynn Gale — a fifth-generation Georgia shrimper — is on the side of the road on an April morning, selling shrimp at the same street corner where his dad sold shrimp. “How’s the pandemic treating you?” I ask. “Sales have dropped off by about two-thirds. No out-of-towners coming through on the I-95. No local traffic.” He sighs. “I’m going to tough it out. I can survive with what I’m selling. But that’s all I’m doing. Most shrimpers don’t have 401k retirement plans, you know?” Gale would rather be out on his boat, a 1953 trawler he had for nine years but recently
The Lunar New Year vacation had just ended when Alice Wu began to worry about COVID-19. Not long after, on Feb. 10, Wu — who didn’t give her Chinese name to speak freely for this story — received the first of several coronavirus-related sales messages through her smartphone. The pitch came from an acquaintance who represents Amway, an American multi-level marketing (MLM) company that’s been active in Taiwan since 1982. “I’ve only met her once, and I’ve never bought from her. If her sister wasn’t one of my daughter’s teachers, I’d probably block her,” says Wu, who lives in Taichung. MLM, sometimes