They didn’t pop open boxes of sweets or send out excited phone messages when their first child was born at public hospital on a rainy Mumbai night in July.
The couple had known from the 24th week of the pregnancy that their child would be born with Arnold Chiari Type II syndrome — a structural defect in the brain.
Since abortions in India are allowed only up to 20 weeks of pregnancy, the couple petitioned India’s Supreme Court to allow them a to terminate the pregnancy, which was by then 27 weeks. The court rejected their plea.
Photo: Reuters
The couple, who chose to remain anonymous in the much-publicized case, said in media interviews that they did not have the wherewithal — emotional and financial — to take care of the child, while doctors could not indicate the infant’s expected life span.
The baby died a fortnight ago.
“There was no treatment available for the baby. Pus was flowing from the brain. The mother was home and cared for the baby for a month and a half,” said Nikhil Datar, a Mumbai-based gynecologist whom the couple consulted.
Photo: Reuters
Datar guided the couple to file the abortion petition in the Supreme Court citing the fetus’s abnormality.
“She [the mother] has now slipped into depression. We don’t disturb her any more,” Datar said.
When India introduced the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act in 1971, it set a 20-week deadline for abortions, which campaigners say was an arbitrary decision then, and now ignores the medical advances India has made.
The Indian government remains reluctant to change the law fearing its misuse for sex-selective abortions.
But the 20-week deadline has hit victims of sexual assault, especially the very young whose pregnancies are detected late, campaigners say.
In July, the Supreme Court rejected an abortion plea made by the parent of a 10-year-old rape victim who delivered a child last month.
The court last week appointed a medical board to study the abortion plea of the 13-year-old rape survivor who is now 31 weeks’ pregnant, and will hear her plea this week.
“It is unethical to put a victim of rape through the trauma of a full term pregnancy and then abandon the child,” said Sangeeta Rege of the Centre for Enquiry into Health and Allied Themes, a health charity supporting the 13-year-old.
These cases were among a string of petitions, backed by the some of the country’s best known doctors, health charities and lawyers, seeking abortions at India’s top court.
The court has approved more pleas than it has declined, but activists say suggested amendments to the 1971 act to extend the abortion deadline to 24 weeks and to train more doctors to carry out abortions should be passed in parliament to unburden the court and save women from unnecessary stress.
“In 45 years, technological interventions have improved. Terminations are becoming safer and safer,” said Datar, who is guiding at least six patients currently on their abortion pleas.
A FAMILY AFFAIR
Abortions in India are a “conditional right,” offered only if there is a substantial risk of the child being born with a physical or mental handicap or in the case of contraceptive failure.
But the termination must be carried out within 20 weeks — unless the mother’s life is in danger — and the final decision rests with the doctor, who will often consult the woman’s wider family.
“Abortion is not being understood as a woman’s right. Women are asked to bring their spouse or in-laws if they are seeking an abortion particularly in the second trimester,” said Rege.
“So abortion is not a woman’s choice, but that of the family.”
And doctors fear flouting another law — the Pre Conception and Pre-Natal Diagnostic Techniques Act — that aims to stop the widespread practice of female feticide and sex-selective abortions in India, where boys are preferred over girls.
So abortion requests in the second trimester of a pregnancy — which is when fetal anomalies are detected — are often denied, despite studies showing that only a small proportion of these abortions are sex-selective.
As a result many women visit small backstreet clinics to terminate their pregnancies, where the cost of the procedure is high but care is poor.
“It is estimated that about 10 percent of the nearly 45,000 maternal deaths in the country annually are due to unsafe abortions,” said Subha Sri, chairperson of CommonHealth, a national coalition of health charities.
“Studies have shown that the more desperate the woman for an abortion, the higher its cost.”
Proposed changes to the MTP Act have raised concerns in the Indian government that the amendment may increase sex-selective abortions, a concern campaigners say is not based on evidence.
But the proposal is backed by the health ministry and is currently with the Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s office for consideration, said a health ministry official.
OVERLOADED HOSPITALS
Sandeep Jadhav, 29, was over the moon when his wife Sonali told him she was pregnant with their first child.
Their local municipal hospital that had long waiting times and the first ultrasound scan came when Sonali was already 20 weeks pregnant.
“The doctor said there was a problem, but asked me to return after a month,” Jadhav said.
Jadhav, a driver, told his employer who took him to a gynecologist in a private hospital where he was told his child will be born with a neurological condition.
“I wanted a healthy child. But my wife was already 21 weeks pregnant by the time the diagnosis was made.”
Backed by Datar, Jadhav made an abortion plea to the Supreme Court, which was approved. Sonali had a termination at 24 weeks.
Doctors say that while fetal abnormalities can be detected after 18 weeks, the wait can be longer in India where public healthcare facilities are overloaded.
Renowned pediatric cardiologist Devi Shetty has argued that “screening 26 million pregnant women a year with less than 15,000 experienced radiologists within the deadline of 20 weeks is a tall order in India.”
This paradox, campaigners say, makes the case for the deadline to be extended to at least 26 weeks and lifted completely for rape-induced pregnancies.
“The deadline revolves around the unborn child. But what about the person who is alive?” asks Rege.
Sept.16 to Sept. 22 The “anti-communist train” with then-president Chiang Kai-shek’s (蔣介石) face plastered on the engine puffed along the “sugar railway” (糖業鐵路) in May 1955, drawing enthusiastic crowds at 103 stops covering nearly 1,200km. An estimated 1.58 million spectators were treated to propaganda films, plays and received free sugar products. By this time, the state-run Taiwan Sugar Corporation (台糖, Taisugar) had managed to connect the previously separate east-west lines established by Japanese-era sugar factories, allowing the anti-communist train to travel easily from Taichung to Pingtung’s Donggang Township (東港). Last Sunday’s feature (Taiwan in Time: The sugar express) covered the inauguration of the
The corruption cases surrounding former Taipei Mayor and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) head Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) are just one item in the endless cycle of noise and fuss obscuring Taiwan’s deep and urgent structural and social problems. Even the case itself, as James Baron observed in an excellent piece at the Diplomat last week, is only one manifestation of the greater problem of deep-rooted corruption in land development. Last week the government announced a program to permit 25,000 foreign university students, primarily from the Philippines, Indonesia and Malaysia, to work in Taiwan after graduation for 2-4 years. That number is a
In a stark demonstration of how award-winning breakthroughs can come from the most unlikely directions, researchers have won an Ig Nobel prize for discovering that mammals can breathe through their anuses. After a series of tests on mice, rats and pigs, Japanese scientists found the animals absorb oxygen delivered through the rectum, work that underpins a clinical trial to see whether the procedure can treat respiratory failure. The team is among 10 recognized in this year’s Ig Nobel awards (see below for more), the irreverent accolades given for achievements that “first make people laugh, and then make them think.” They are not
This Qing Dynasty trail takes hikers from renowned hot springs in the East Rift Valley, up to the top of the Coastal Mountain Range, and down to the Pacific Short vacations to eastern Taiwan often require choosing between the Rift Valley with its pineapple fields, rice paddies and broader range of amenities, or the less populated coastal route for its ocean scenery. For those who can’t decide, why not try both? The Antong Traversing Trail (安通越嶺道) provides just such an opportunity. Built 149 years ago, the trail linked up these two formerly isolated parts of the island by crossing over the Coastal Mountain Range. After decades of serving as a convenient path for local Amis, Han settlers, missionaries and smugglers, the trail fell into disuse once modern roadways were built