Buying the dip or buying the dead? Enron Corp shares have almost quadrupled since the company filed the biggest US bankruptcy in history Sunday. The rise confounds lawyers and money managers who say the stock probably will be wiped out in a reorganization or liquidation of the Houston-based energy trader.
"That it's going up boggles my mind," said Peter Antoszyk, a partner at law firm Brown, Rudnick, Freed & Gesmer in Boston, who specializes in bankruptcy law. Enron has about US$19 billion in debt and preferred stock to repay before holders of common shares have any claim to its assets.
PHOTO: REUTERS
Buyers of Enron shares may include those who had bet on a decline and now need to replace borrowed shares to cover short sales, said traders and fund managers. Still, 700 million shares traded so far this week, more than 20 times the number that had been sold short as of last month, suggesting more buyers have been drawn into the rally.
Worthless shares have risen before during bankruptcies. In 1993, the Securities and Exchange Commission investigated trading in shares of LTV Corp and Wang Laboratories after reorganization plans left shareholders with little or nothing. On May 27, 1993, LTV shares were the most-active US stock, trading at US$0.25 a share, even though the steelmaker's bankruptcy called for the shares to be exchanged for warrants worth just US$0.03.
Enron's shares rose US$0.14 to US$1.01 on Wednesday, giving the stock a market value of more than US$750 million. Five blocks of more than 1 million shares moved after the opening, including a block of 2 million shares at US$1.03 just before the close of New York Stock Exchange trading. Last Wednesday the shares plunged 85 percent on trading of a record 346 million shares after Dynegy Inc canceled a takeover, and the shares ended the week at US$0.26.
"The stock won't be worth the paper it's printed on," said Art Hogan, chief market analyst at Jefferies & Co. He reckons Enron, which had a peak market value of more than US$70 billion last year, will be delisted from the New York Stock Exchange.
The NYSE has said it is reviewing Enron's listing on the exchange because of its Chapter 11 filing.
"The exchange monitors compliance with listing standards and it may appraise and determine on an individual basis the suitability for continued listing of an issue in light of all pertinent facts whenever it deems such action appropriate," said NYSE spokesman Ray Pellecchia.
NYSE member brokers "have a `know your customer' obligation under our rules," he said, "to know the essential facts of each customer as the basis for recommending suitable investments." Companies' annual listing fees to the Big Board are due on Jan. 1. Companies pay fees of as much as US$500,000 based on their shares outstanding. The exchange doesn't disclose how much individual members paid, Pellechia said.
With just US$500 million left to fund operations, Enron got permission from US Bankruptcy Judge Arthur Gonzalez this week to draw US$250 million of as much as US$1.5 billion in bankruptcy financing from a bank group led by JP Morgan Chase & Co and Citigroup Inc.
Former customers are shunning the company's trading operation that had generated most of its profits and helped it record US$100 billion of revenue last year. Enron fired half the 8,000 employees at its Houston headquarters and is selling units to raise cash.
Enron's debt sells for US$0.14 to US$0.28 on the dollar, indicating there won't be enough of the company left to cover creditors first in line for repayment, much less common shareholders, fund managers say.
"It looks extraordinarily doubtful there could be any value for the common shares in either a liquidation or a reorganization," said Martin Whitman, who helps manage US$4 billion at Third Avenue Funds in New York and specializes in analyzing distressed securities.
"Shareholders of the new Enron will be almost wholly the unsecured creditors. You can take that to the bank." Whitman said he may buy some of Enron's debt, but wouldn't consider the common shares.
With a minimum of a year and more likely two or more years before a reorganization plan can be worked out, buyers of Enron shares may be looking to sell within days or hoping to influence the bankruptcy talks, Antoszyk said.
Even though holders of common stock are last in line to get repaid, they must as a class approve a reorganization or liquidation plan or a judge must overturn their objection before the plan can go forward.
"The last thing you want is to go to a contested settlement plan," Antoszyk said. "You can create a mess of litigation that can be very costly and slow things up." At current prices, a controlling interest in Enron would cost about US$400 million.
Internet message boards were filled with postings by people arguing whether the rise in Enron is a "sucker's rally" or a buying opportunity.
"It could just be a lot of retail investors who think Enron at US$0.26 a share looked pretty good," said Bruce Simon, chief investment officer at Glenmede Trust, which manages US$17 billion in Baltimore. "They think they can double their money overnight, which you can." Just don't plan on holding the shares long, he said.
WAITING GAME: The US has so far only offered a ‘best rate tariff,’ which officials assume is about 15 percent, the same as Japan, a person familiar with the matter said Taiwan and the US have completed “technical consultations” regarding tariffs and a finalized rate is expected to be released soon, Executive Yuan spokeswoman Michelle Lee (李慧芝) told a news conference yesterday, as a 90-day pause on US President Donald Trump’s “reciprocal” tariffs is set to expire today. The two countries have reached a “certain degree of consensus” on issues such as tariffs, nontariff trade barriers, trade facilitation, supply chain resilience and economic security, Lee said. They also discussed opportunities for cooperation, investment and procurement, she said. A joint statement is still being negotiated and would be released once the US government has made
Authorities have detained three former Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TMSC, 台積電) employees on suspicion of compromising classified technology used in making 2-nanometer chips, the Taiwan High Prosecutors’ Office said yesterday. Prosecutors are holding a former TSMC engineer surnamed Chen (陳) and two recently sacked TSMC engineers, including one person surnamed Wu (吳) in detention with restricted communication, following an investigation launched on July 25, a statement said. The announcement came a day after Nikkei Asia reported on the technology theft in an exclusive story, saying TSMC had fired two workers for contravening data rules on advanced chipmaking technology. Two-nanometer wafers are the most
NEW GEAR: On top of the new Tien Kung IV air defense missiles, the military is expected to place orders for a new combat vehicle next year for delivery in 2028 Mass production of Tien Kung IV (Sky Bow IV) missiles is expected to start next year, with plans to order 122 pods, the Ministry of National Defense’s (MND) latest list of regulated military material showed. The document said that the armed forces would obtain 46 pods of the air defense missiles next year and 76 pods the year after that. The Tien Kung IV is designed to intercept cruise missiles and ballistic missiles to an altitude of 70km, compared with the 60km maximum altitude achieved by the Missile Segment Enhancement variant of PAC-3 systems. A defense source said yesterday that the number of
Taiwanese exports to the US are to be subject to a 20 percent tariff starting on Thursday next week, according to an executive order signed by US President Donald Trump yesterday. The 20 percent levy was the same as the tariffs imposed on Vietnam, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh by Trump. It was higher than the tariffs imposed on Japan, South Korea and the EU (15 percent), as well as those on the Philippines (19 percent). A Taiwan official with knowledge of the matter said it is a "phased" tariff rate, and negotiations would continue. "Once negotiations conclude, Taiwan will obtain a better
RSS