A US judge has ordered a new trial to determine how much Samsung Electronics Co should pay Apple Inc for copying the look of the iPhone.
US District Judge Lucy Koh in San Jose, California, issued her order on Sunday, 10 months after the US Supreme Court set aside a US$399 million award against Samsung.
The three Apple patents covered design elements of the iPhone such as its black rectangular front face, rounded corners and colorful grid of icons for programs and apps.
Photo: Reuters
Koh’s order is a setback for Apple, which called a retrial unnecessary and said the award should be confirmed.
Silicon Valley has closely followed the case that is six-and-a-half years old.
Companies such as Facebook Inc and Alphabet Inc’s Google have said that an Apple win would encourage owners of design patents to sue for huge, unfair awards on products containing hundreds of features that are costly to develop.
The US$399 million represented profit from Samsung’s sales of infringing smartphones, although the South Korean company has said it deserved reimbursement if it prevailed in the litigation.
It was part of a US$548 million payment that Samsung made to Apple in December 2015.
The legal dispute concerned whether the “article of manufacture” for which Samsung owed damages included the entire phone, or only parts that infringed on Apple patents.
Without deciding that question, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote for the Supreme Court on Dec. 6 last year that “the term ‘article of manufacture’ is broad enough to embrace both a product sold to a consumer and a component of that product.”
In Sunday’s order, Koh said that the jury instructions at the original 2012 trial inaccurately stated the law on that issue.
She said Samsung might have been prejudiced if jurors were prevented from considering whether any infringement covered “something other than the entire phone.”
Apple contended that the jury instructions were “not erroneous” and said it had proved that Samsung applied its patented designs to its “entire phones.”
Jurors initially awarded US$1.05 billion to Apple, which was later reduced.
Samsung in a statement welcomed a new trial, calling it “a historic opportunity to determine how the US Supreme Court’s guidance on design patent damages will be implemented.”
ISSUES: Gogoro has been struggling with ballooning losses and was recently embroiled in alleged subsidy fraud, using Chinese-made components instead of locally made parts Gogoro Inc (睿能創意), the nation’s biggest electric scooter maker, yesterday said that its chairman and CEO Horace Luke (陸學森) has resigned amid chronic losses and probes into the company’s alleged involvement in subsidy fraud. The board of directors nominated Reuntex Group (潤泰集團) general counsel Tamon Tseng (曾夢達) as the company’s new chairman, Gogoro said in a statement. Ruentex is Gogoro’s biggest stakeholder. Gogoro Taiwan general manager Henry Chiang (姜家煒) is to serve as acting CEO during the interim period, the statement said. Luke’s departure came as a bombshell yesterday. As a company founder, he has played a key role in pushing for the
China has claimed a breakthrough in developing homegrown chipmaking equipment, an important step in overcoming US sanctions designed to thwart Beijing’s semiconductor goals. State-linked organizations are advised to use a new laser-based immersion lithography machine with a resolution of 65 nanometers or better, the Chinese Ministry of Industry and Information Technology (MIIT) said in an announcement this month. Although the note does not specify the supplier, the spec marks a significant step up from the previous most advanced indigenous equipment — developed by Shanghai Micro Electronics Equipment Group Co (SMEE, 上海微電子) — which stood at about 90 nanometers. MIIT’s claimed advances last
CROSS-STRAIT TENSIONS: The US company could switch orders from TSMC to alternative suppliers, but that would lower chip quality, CEO Jensen Huang said Nvidia Corp CEO Jensen Huang (黃仁勳), whose products have become the hottest commodity in the technology world, on Wednesday said that the scramble for a limited amount of supply has frustrated some customers and raised tensions. “The demand on it is so great, and everyone wants to be first and everyone wants to be most,” he told the audience at a Goldman Sachs Group Inc technology conference in San Francisco. “We probably have more emotional customers today. Deservedly so. It’s tense. We’re trying to do the best we can.” Huang’s company is experiencing strong demand for its latest generation of chips, called
GLOBAL ECONOMY: Policymakers have a choice of a small 25 basis-point cut or a bold cut of 50 basis points, which would help the labor market, but might reignite inflation The US Federal Reserve is gearing up to announce its first interest rate cut in more than four years on Wednesday, with policymakers expected to debate how big a move to make less than two months before the US presidential election. Senior officials at the US central bank including Fed Chairman Jerome Powell have in recent weeks indicated that a rate cut is coming this month, as inflation eases toward the bank’s long-term target of two percent, and the labor market continues to cool. The Fed, which has a dual mandate from the US Congress to act independently to ensure