Mon, Oct 19, 2015 - Page 15 News List

US court rules in favor of Google’s online library


Google Inc is not violating copyright laws by digitizing millions of books so it can provide small portions of them to the public, a US federal appeals court on Friday ruled in a decade-long dispute by authors worried that the project would spoil the market for their work.

The 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan agreed with a judge who concluded that the snippets Google showed customers from its database was a transformative use of the information and thus did not violate copyright laws.

Judge Denny Chin ruled in November 2013 that Google’s digitization of more than 20 million books, mostly out-of-print titles, did not violate copyrights because the Mountain View, California-based company only showed short sections of the books in its database.

Chin had said it would be difficult for anyone to read any of the works in their entirety by repeatedly entering different search requests.

In an opinion written by Judge Pierre Leval, the appeals court agreed, saying the snippet feature “substantially protects against its serving as an effectively competing substitute for plaintiffs’ books.”

“Snippet view, at best and after a large commitment of manpower, produces discontinuous, tiny fragments, amounting in the aggregate to no more than 16 precent of a book. This does not threaten the rights holders with any significant harm to the value of their copyrights or diminish their harvest of copyright revenue,” it added.

The three-judge appeals panel did acknowledge that some book sales would likely be lost if someone were merely searching for a portion of text to ascertain a fact.

This story has been viewed 1616 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top