Kim Sbarcea knew exactly what she wanted. She typed “Tiffany Elsa Peretti mesh earrings” into Google and chanced upon a pair of the US$450 earrings for — deal of deals — US$32.
The Web site, called tiffany-outletsale.com, looked legit. She hit the buy button.
In that instant, Sbarcea’s money was sucked from her house in Christchurch, New Zealand, into the global counterfeiting market, where Chinese banks have emerged as key conduits in an illegal industry estimated to be worth US$1.8 trillion this year.
At least three prominent Chinese banks serve as safe havens for counterfeiters, who use them to process credit card payments or move their money around the globe, The Associated Press has found.
A review of hundreds of pages of court documents — along with interviews with lawyers, investigators, government officials and industry groups — shows that a lack of legal cooperation between the West and China is allowing counterfeiters to use Chinese banks as financial shelters.
Five lawsuits filed in the US against counterfeiters reveal a pattern: Counterfeiters sold fakes online in the US, using credit cards or PayPal. Then, records show, they transferred millions to accounts at two of China’s largest, state-owned banks — the Bank of China (中國銀行) and the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC, 中國工商銀行) — as well as China Merchants Bank (招商銀行).
The banks do not dispute that the accused counterfeiters held accounts, but refuse to comply with US court orders to freeze funds or disclose information about accounts in China, saying that would violate bank secrecy laws. The banks said they are committed to fighting counterfeiting, have broken no laws, and are caught in a jurisdictional dispute between China and the US.
In a 2013 letter, the Chinese embassy in Washington complained to the US Department of State about subpoenas served “time and again” on Chinese banks.
The embassy wrote that demands to freeze assets and disclose information about accounts in China amounted to “wrongful acts that disrespect China’s sovereignty and laws.”
Chinese regulators later warned that the issue could “undermine” Chinese-US relations.
In one of two lawsuits, Tiffany & Co seeks US$58.5 million in damages in a New York federal court from an online counterfeiting ring that spans three continents.
Tiffany said it traced PayPal transfers to Bank of China (BOC), ICBC and China Merchants Bank accounts, and also found that the Bank of China was processing credit card payments for one defendant.
A Latvian bank handed over details about the illicit money flows, but the Bank of China refused to cooperate, US court documents show.
Gucci Group NV is seeking US$12 million in damages in a New York federal court from a counterfeiting ring it said sold millions worth of fake handbags and wallets to US consumers. Using records provided by JPMorgan & Chase Co, Gucci traced US$530,000 in transfers from counterfeiters in the US to Bank of China accounts.
However, the Bank of China refused to freeze those funds for Gucci. Instead, it secretly froze more than US$890,000 of the accused counterfeiters’ money to cover its own legal costs, Chinese court documents show.
The other two lawsuits were filed by the US Department of Justice, which traced millions in online sales of counterfeit sports jerseys to Bank of China and ICBC.
More than 90 percent of the banks used by online counterfeiters to process credit card payments are Chinese, according to the International Anti-Counterfeiting Coalition, a non-profit industry group whose members include Apple Inc, Procter & Gamble Co and Tiffany & Co.
The coalition said it has helped shut down more than 4,900 accounts used to process payments for 200,000 Web sites selling counterfeit goods since 2012.
Its records of account closures show the Bank of China and two other state-controlled banking giants — the Bank of Communications (交通銀行) and the Agricultural Bank of China (中國農業銀行) — processing payments for counterfeiters.
“We have to find better ways of gathering evidence,’’ said Mark Cohen, a former intellectual property attache at the US embassy in Beijing.
In the past, Chinese banks have sometimes disclosed information in response to US lawsuits. The value of that information is clear: Lawyers, using transaction information from a Shanghai account obtained on the order of a New York court, cracked a network that shipped dangerous counterfeit blood glucose test kits for diabetics to 600 US pharmacies.
Now, however, banks are tightening enforcement of secrecy rules, in part because China’s consumer protection law was broadened in 2010, China University of Political Science and Law associate professor Zheng Junguo (鄭俊果) said.
The US also restricts access to financial information, but allows judges to order disclosure for lawsuits anywhere in the world. The UK, Hong Kong and Singapore have similar provisions that can be used to fight transnational crime.
The only legal ways to get information about Chinese bank accounts are to file a lawsuit in China or make a request through the Hague Convention. Critics dismiss both as too cumbersome.
The Bank of China said the US lawsuits had put it in an “impossible position,” caught between “US court orders that compel BOC to freeze, turn over or disclose information about bank accounts in China, and Chinese law, which requires the bank not to freeze or turn over accounts in China.”
Gucci and Tiffany declined to comment on the ongoing litigation.
In a statement released on Friday, Tiffany spokesman Carson Glover said the company is committed to combating counterfeiters and has shut down 5,000 infringing Web sites in the past three years.
BUSINESS UPDATE: The iPhone assembler said operations outlook is expected to show quarter-on-quarter and year-on-year growth for the second quarter Hon Hai Precision Industry Co (鴻海精密) yesterday reported strong growth in sales last month, potentially raising expectations for iPhone sales while artificial intelligence (AI)-related business booms. The company, which assembles the majority of Apple Inc’s smartphones, reported a 19.03 percent rise in monthly sales to NT$510.9 billion (US$15.78 billion), from NT$429.22 billion in the same period last year. On a monthly basis, sales rose 14.16 percent, it said. The company in a statement said that last month’s revenue was a record-breaking April performance. Hon Hai, known also as Foxconn Technology Group (富士康科技集團), assembles most iPhones, but the company is diversifying its business to
Apple Inc has been developing a homegrown chip to run artificial intelligence (AI) tools in data centers, although it is unclear if the semiconductor would ever be deployed, the Wall Street Journal reported on Monday. The effort would build on Apple’s previous efforts to make in-house chips, which run in its iPhones, Macs and other devices, according to the Journal, which cited unidentified people familiar with the matter. The server project is code-named ACDC (Apple Chips in Data Center) within the company, aiming to utilize Apple’s expertise in chip design for the company’s server infrastructure, the newspaper said. While this initiative has been
GlobalWafers Co (環球晶圓), the world’s No. 3 silicon wafer supplier, yesterday said that revenue would rise moderately in the second half of this year, driven primarily by robust demand for advanced wafers used in high-bandwidth memory (HBM) chips, a key component of artificial intelligence (AI) technology. “The first quarter is the lowest point of this cycle. The second half will be better than the first for the whole semiconductor industry and for GlobalWafers,” chairwoman Doris Hsu (徐秀蘭) said during an online investors’ conference. “HBM would definitely be the key growth driver in the second half,” Hsu said. “That is our big hope
The consumer price index (CPI) last month eased to 1.95 percent, below the central bank’s 2 percent target, as food and entertainment cost increases decelerated, helped by stable egg prices, the Directorate-General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) said yesterday. The slowdown bucked predictions by policymakers and academics that inflationary pressures would build up following double-digit electricity rate hikes on April 1. “The latest CPI data came after the cost of eating out and rent grew moderately amid mixed international raw material prices,” DGBAS official Tsao Chih-hung (曹志弘) told a news conference in Taipei. The central bank in March raised interest rates by