Sat, Jan 05, 2008 - Page 11 News List

Intel calls off deal with One Laptop per Child

'PHILOSOPHICAL IMPASSE' The chipmaking giant says that commitments to manufacturers and suppliers prevent it from exclusively supporting the XO laptop

BLOOMBERG

Intel Corp, the world's largest chipmaker, split from a foundation working to provide US$100 laptops to the developing world, ending a six-month truce with the founder of the nonprofit group, Nicholas Negroponte.

The company reached a "philosophical impasse" with the One Laptop per Child foundation and Negroponte, who'd asked the company to exclusively support the group's XO laptop, Intel spokesman Chuck Mulloy said on Thursday in an interview.

Intel joined the board of One Laptop per Child (OLPC) in July, teaming up with a former critic. Negroponte had accused the company of trying to put his project out of business by developing a similar laptop called the Classmate PC. With Intel on its board, the foundation expected the firm to abandon support for the Classmate and other rival products, Mulloy said.

"It's unusual anyone does an alliance with a company the size of Intel and then gives that company an offer they can't accept," said Rob Enderle, president of the San Jose, California-based research firm Enderle Group. "The OLPC folks should know Intel couldn't accept the deal."

A call on Thursday to One Laptop per Child in Cambridge, Massachusetts, wasn't returned.

"After more than six months of discussion on this key point -- which is, `Do we provide exclusive support to XO?' -- we mutually agreed to go our separate ways," Mulloy said. "If Intel were to exclusively support the XO over other platforms, it would force us to abandon our relationships and commitments with local manufacturers and suppliers."

Negroponte called Intel "shameless" on the 60 Minutes TV news program last May, saying the chipmaker was selling its Classmate PCs below cost in order to undercut the XO device.

The XO is built with chips from Intel rival Advanced Micro Devices Inc. Drew Prairie, a spokesman for that company, didn't return messages seeking comment.

Intel, based in Santa Clara, California, had developed a working prototype for an XO laptop based on its own chips, Mulloy said. That project is now discontinued. Intel plans to keep supporting the Classmate PC and other low-cost computers, including Asustek Computer Inc's Eee PC.

The Classmate, depending on the included software, is "slightly more pricey" than the XO, which costs about US$188, Mulloy said. The group plans to bring the XO's price down to US$100.

Intel fell US$0.68 to US$24.67 on Thursday in NASDAQ Stock Market trading. The shares rose 32 percent last year.

This story has been viewed 1701 times.
TOP top