As the latest in a long line of Wall Street morality plays, the one involving Sanford I. Weill, the chairman of Citigroup, and Jack B. Grubman, his firm's former star telecommunications analyst, is unfolding in depressingly familiar fashion. But it differs too from some other dramas involving brokerage firm titans: Thousands of individual investors lost millions of dollars because of what appear to have been self-interested actions by Grubman and Weill.
The story so far: In early 1999 Weill asked Grubman, a man whose job it is to monitor by the minute what is happening at telecom companies, to "take a fresh look" at AT&T. Grubman, who had been negative on the stock, coincidentally upgraded it to a buy in November 1999. A few months later, Weill's firm helped AT&T sell shares in its wireless division to investors, reaping bountiful fees. And Grubman got help from Weill securing spots in a prestigious Manhattan nursery school for his twins. In October 2000, Grubman downgraded the shares again after the stock had lost 50 percent of its value.
Recall past Wall Street shows. The infractions and hubris of Michael Milken at Drexel Burnham Lambert in the 1980s did not wipe out armies of small investors. And individual investors were largely unaffected by the attempt of a Salomon Brothers trader to corner the market in US Treasury securities, a power play that cost John H. Gutfreund, the firm's chairman, his job in 1991.
Weill said last week that he did not mean to pressure Grubman into changing his view on AT&T, and that he assumed Grubman would rate the stock on its merits. But his argument is unpersuasive.
The fact is, Weill's request of Grubman draws him into the circle of people that investors can consider at least partly responsible for losses they incurred by following the analyst's advice. Between his upgrade of AT&T when the stock was at US$57.43, and his downgrade, at US$28.88, some US$80 billion in market value vanished.
Grubman was not the only analyst who was bullish on AT&T in 1999. This column quoted one in May 1999 who incorrectly projected a positive future for the company and its shareholders. What a bad call of mine that was.
It may not come as a surprise to people on Wall Street or those accustomed to its ways, that Weill inserted himself into the research process relating to AT&T. But that doesn't mean it looks good. In fact, it looks awful. Sufficiently so that some large investors have dumped Citigroup shares as a result.
Bill Dierker, vice president of equity securities at Nationwide Insurance in Columbus, Ohio, said he had sold the last of his company's roughly 1.5 million Citigroup shares last Wednesday. That was two days after Weill owned up to contacting Grubman about his AT&T rating.
Dierker's reason? "The quality of management is a big variable in my decision-making process and Citigroup went from having a reasonable score to having a low score," he said. "For investors, it used to be we didn't know what we didn't know. Now, I think there's a sense that there's a lot we don't know."
Weill's position at the top of Citigroup may yet be secure. But his legacy as a share manager has been severely damaged.
Bill Fleckenstein, president of Fleckenstein Capital in Seattle, said the incident showed "that it wasn't just the analysts and the corporate finance guys on Wall Street who would do whatever it took to make a buck. The CEOs did, too."
SECURITY: As China is ‘reshaping’ Hong Kong’s population, Taiwan must raise the eligibility threshold for applications from Hong Kongers, Chiu Chui-cheng said When Hong Kong and Macau citizens apply for residency in Taiwan, it would be under a new category that includes a “national security observation period,” Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) Minister Chiu Chui-cheng (邱垂正) said yesterday. President William Lai (賴清德) on March 13 announced 17 strategies to counter China’s aggression toward Taiwan, including incorporating national security considerations into the review process for residency applications from Hong Kong and Macau citizens. The situation in Hong Kong is constantly changing, Chiu said to media yesterday on the sidelines of the Taipei Technology Run hosted by the Taipei Neihu Technology Park Development Association. With
CARROT AND STICK: While unrelenting in its military threats, China attracted nearly 40,000 Taiwanese to over 400 business events last year Nearly 40,000 Taiwanese last year joined industry events in China, such as conferences and trade fairs, supported by the Chinese government, a study showed yesterday, as Beijing ramps up a charm offensive toward Taipei alongside military pressure. China has long taken a carrot-and-stick approach to Taiwan, threatening it with the prospect of military action while reaching out to those it believes are amenable to Beijing’s point of view. Taiwanese security officials are wary of what they see as Beijing’s influence campaigns to sway public opinion after Taipei and Beijing gradually resumed travel links halted by the COVID-19 pandemic, but the scale of
A US Marine Corps regiment equipped with Naval Strike Missiles (NSM) is set to participate in the upcoming Balikatan 25 exercise in the Luzon Strait, marking the system’s first-ever deployment in the Philippines. US and Philippine officials have separately confirmed that the Navy Marine Expeditionary Ship Interdiction System (NMESIS) — the mobile launch platform for the Naval Strike Missile — would take part in the joint exercise. The missiles are being deployed to “a strategic first island chain chokepoint” in the waters between Taiwan proper and the Philippines, US-based Naval News reported. “The Luzon Strait and Bashi Channel represent a critical access
Pope Francis is be laid to rest on Saturday after lying in state for three days in St Peter’s Basilica, where the faithful are expected to flock to pay their respects to history’s first Latin American pontiff. The cardinals met yesterday in the Vatican’s synod hall to chart the next steps before a conclave begins to choose Francis’ successor, as condolences poured in from around the world. According to current norms, the conclave must begin between May 5 and 10. The cardinals set the funeral for Saturday at 10am in St Peter’s Square, to be celebrated by the dean of the College