Eight months after implementing a ban on under-16s accessing social media services like TikTok, Australia finds its younger users are returning in droves, new data from Qustodio showed.
As of last month, 26 percent of children aged 13 to 15 were on TikTo, just 1 percentage point below the rate prior to Australia’s groundbreaking rules coming into effect, the parental control software maker said.
The rate for children aged 10 to 12 is higher now than before the ban, the data showed.
Photo: AFP
The Australian government has been at the forefront of legislating to prevent underage users from accessing services such as Instagram and Facebook from Meta Platforms Inc and TikTok, owned by China’s ByteDance Ltd. Many argue the services are harmful to young users’ mental health and other countries are following Australia’s example, including New Zealand announcing plans this week.
“What we’ve seen is an immediate drop to a degree, but slowly but surely the numbers have started to increase again to almost equivalent levels” for some services, said Yasmin London, a global online safety expert at Qustodio.
Usage rates for Instagram and Snap Inc’s Snapchat are lower than TikTok, but have also begun to creep up after falling initially when the ban came into effect in December last year, the data showed.
Children could be obfuscating their ages, using virtual private networks that disguise their locations, or simply not encountering effective age checks on platforms, London said.
“In the end, kids want access because they want to be connected just like the rest of us,” she said.
The new data underscore concerns about the effectiveness of Australia’s age controls and Big Tech’s compliance with them. Regulators, tech firms and parents around the world are studying Australia’s experience as more than two dozen governments have implemented or are seeking to implement similar measures.
Australia is being “closely watched,” and has come to symbolize the issue of social media restrictions, said Minda Smiley, a senior analyst at Emarketer focused on social media.
“Even as other countries follow suit, I think a lot of people are paying particular attention to Australia and hoping it can provide some sort of blueprint,” she said.
The new data, which Qustodio said may understate the issue as it is collected only from devices that have its parental oversight software installed, also emerges as social media giants face numerous lawsuits in the US alleging they are harming their young users by making their platforms hard to resist.
Barcelona-based Qustodio’s research was based on anonymized information from 19,000 Australian families. It measured the percentage of children who had unblocked access to the apps and used them at least once per month for more than five consecutive minutes.
One service seeing an increase in usage is Meta’s WhatsApp, which is not subject to the government’s restrictions. About 27 percent of children aged 13 to 15 were on the messaging platform prior to the ban compared with 36 percent now.
TikTok, Snap and Meta did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The Australian government in June said the social media companies were not doing enough to comply with the age restriction, which mandates that the firms take reasonable steps to keep under-16s off or face fines. It pledged to double the maximum penalty for violations to A$99 million (US$71 million) and to give the country’s online safety watchdog extra enforcement powers. No social media platform has been fined for breaching the ban.
Australia’s online safety regulator, known as eSafety, did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the new data.
Governments looking for clues as to whether or not Australia’s rules are working will likely take the long view, Smiley said.
“It’s still early enough in the game that I think Australia will keep pressing,” she said. “The ban has come at a time when social media is under more scrutiny than ever, so I’d say they have public sentiment on their side.”
HELD ACCOUNTABLE: A total of 56 people were handed prison sentences, with terms for senior executives ranging from six to 18 years in jail, Xinhua reported China yesterday sentenced the founder of embattled property giant Evergrande to life in prison and fined the group more than US$2 billion for offenses including fraud, five years after a high-profile default. Evergrande Group was once the face of Chinese real estate, surfing a decades-long property boom as it peddled home-ownership dreams. However, its access to credit dramatically narrowed when the government introduced curbs on excessive borrowing and speculation. The company defaulted in 2021 after struggling to repay creditors. A court in southern China fined the firm and its real-estate arm a total of 15.82 billion yuan (US$2.35 billion). It issued a life sentence
MAN VS MACHINE: The games could help improve hardware, but longer-term value depends on real-world problem-solving, an executive at a tech firm said China’s humanoid robots have shown they can run quicker than the fastest humans. Now comes the real test: Can they also handle packaging and warehouse operations while reliably performing precision tasks like connecting cables designed to evaluate their ability to work like humans in less flashy jobs? The five-day World Humanoid Robot Games, which began in Beijing on Saturday, combines events modeled on human sports with those designed to test the robots in simulated factories, restaurants, offices and in emergency situations. Heavily promoted in Chinese state media, the games, held at Beijing’s National Speed Skating Oval and which run through Wednesday, feature 51
A cross-party group of Japanese lawmakers, including one from Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi’s governing party, yesterday headed to Beijing to meet with Chinese officials for the first time since ties between the two Asian rivals deteriorated after Takaichi’s comment on Taiwan angered China. The group, which includes Gaku Hashimoto, a lawmaker of Takaichi’s governing Liberal Democratic Party and a former health and welfare vice minister, and a lawmaker each from two opposition parties Komeito and the Centrist Reform Alliance (CRA), is to meet with Chinese Communist Party officials during their visit through Thursday. “Communication has been severed in all areas and we
A former adviser at the US National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) on Tuesday pleaded guilty to conspiring to evade public records laws and conceal government documents related to grant research funding and the COVID-19 pandemic. David Morens, who had worked as a senior official at the institute during the COVID-19 pandemic, entered his plea to a conspiracy charge during a hearing in federal court in Greenbelt, Maryland. The 78-year-old had been indicted in April on charges related to what prosecutors said was a scheme to thwart public records requests received by the agency beginning in April 2020 related to
RSS