The term “flexible employment” has gone viral in China after a prominent economics professor described gig work as a form of “welfare,” drawing widespread public anger and highlighting deep anxieties over job insecurity.
Zhang Dandan (張丹丹), a professor of economics and deputy dean at Peking University’s National School of Development, made the remarks during a discussion on social protection for gig workers, on the popular financial show Let’s Talk (張丹丹) last week.
She said that from the perspective of labor economics, “flexibility itself is a form of welfare.”
Photo: Reuters
While regular employees trade schedule flexibility for pensions and other benefits, flexible workers enjoy greater control over their time at the cost of weaker social protections, Zhang said.
The comments triggered a fierce backlash over the weekend, with social media users accusing Zhang of being oblivious to the harsh realities of the gig economy.
Zhang did not respond to a Reuters request for comment.
The controversy has struck a nerve for many in China, where a cooling economy has made secure, full-time employment harder to find.
The think tank China New Employment Forms Research Center estimates the number of flexible workers — those without permanent full-time contracts — would rise to 320 million this year from 280 million last year.
That represents about 44 percent of China’s urban workforce and is roughly equivalent to the entire population of the US.
The rise of gig jobs in China, where employers are not mandated to make social insurance contributions, heightens long-term risks for the nation’s already strained welfare and pension systems, some industry experts have said.
Prominent nationalist commentator Hu Xijin (胡錫進), a former editor at the state-backed Global Times newspaper, called Zhang’s remarks “shocking” and “unacceptable.”
“She has paid the price for her reputation for speaking this way, and the responsibility lies with her,” Hu wrote on his Weibo account, adding that she should “respond to public opinion, explain where necessary, and apologize where appropriate.”
Despite the backlash, some social media users pointed out that Zhang’s academic career had focused largely on documenting the struggles of gig workers and advocating for their social security.
Zhang last year said that on-demand workers made up about 31 percent of the workforce in China’s manufacturing sector.
During peak seasons, that proportion can rise to as high as 80 percent for large manufacturers with more than 10,000 workers, she said.
Nevertheless, Zhang’s framing of “flexibility” as a benefit was seen as insensitive.
“Such comments from experts are no less than rubbing salt into the wounds of those without job security,” one Weibo user wrote.
Another user pointed out the relentless pressure faced by delivery drivers and couriers: “Every day, they are racing against the platform’s algorithm at all costs, without rest ... [flexible work] is precisely the most unavoidable of choices, not a preference.”
HELD ACCOUNTABLE: A total of 56 people were handed prison sentences, with terms for senior executives ranging from six to 18 years in jail, Xinhua reported China yesterday sentenced the founder of embattled property giant Evergrande to life in prison and fined the group more than US$2 billion for offenses including fraud, five years after a high-profile default. Evergrande Group was once the face of Chinese real estate, surfing a decades-long property boom as it peddled home-ownership dreams. However, its access to credit dramatically narrowed when the government introduced curbs on excessive borrowing and speculation. The company defaulted in 2021 after struggling to repay creditors. A court in southern China fined the firm and its real-estate arm a total of 15.82 billion yuan (US$2.35 billion). It issued a life sentence
MAN VS MACHINE: The games could help improve hardware, but longer-term value depends on real-world problem-solving, an executive at a tech firm said China’s humanoid robots have shown they can run quicker than the fastest humans. Now comes the real test: Can they also handle packaging and warehouse operations while reliably performing precision tasks like connecting cables designed to evaluate their ability to work like humans in less flashy jobs? The five-day World Humanoid Robot Games, which began in Beijing on Saturday, combines events modeled on human sports with those designed to test the robots in simulated factories, restaurants, offices and in emergency situations. Heavily promoted in Chinese state media, the games, held at Beijing’s National Speed Skating Oval and which run through Wednesday, feature 51
A former adviser at the US National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) on Tuesday pleaded guilty to conspiring to evade public records laws and conceal government documents related to grant research funding and the COVID-19 pandemic. David Morens, who had worked as a senior official at the institute during the COVID-19 pandemic, entered his plea to a conspiracy charge during a hearing in federal court in Greenbelt, Maryland. The 78-year-old had been indicted in April on charges related to what prosecutors said was a scheme to thwart public records requests received by the agency beginning in April 2020 related to
The wildfires burning across Europe this summer have exposed a potentially deadly threat lurking beneath the blackened landscape: rusty bombs and mines from World War I and II that threaten crews responding to the flames. Some of the weapons have exploded in the intense heat. Blasts have been reported in France, Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands, where a bomb-disposal team was dispatched to check a forest threatened by flames near a site of fierce fighting in the Limburg Province in 1944. Fueled by climate change, the fires and explosions show that the continent’s “climatic luck” is running out, said Sarah Njeri, a
RSS