Hong Kong’s appeal court yesterday banned Glory to Hong Kong, a protest song that emerged during the territory’s massive democracy demonstrations in 2019.
Penned anonymously, its lyrics include the words “Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our times,” and it has been all but illegal to sing or play it since authorities crushed the protests and Beijing imposed a national security law quelling dissent in 2020.
Yesterday’s decision by the Court of Appeal would make Glory to Hong Kong the first song to be banned in the former British colony since it was handed over to China in 1997.
Photo: AP
We “are satisfied that an injunction should be granted,” appeal judge Jeremy Poon wrote in the decision, granting an order that would stop a range of acts, including broadcasting and performing the song.
Officials in June last year had requested an injunction to ban Glory to Hong Kong, but were refused by the High Court in a surprise ruling, which said a ban could have a “chilling effect” on innocent third parties.
The court also said then that the injunction did not have “any real utility,” which judges in the Court of Appeal disagreed with.
“The composer of the song has intended it to be a ‘weapon’ and so it had become,” Poon wrote.
Civil injunction is needed, as “criminal law alone would not achieve the public interest purpose of safeguarding national security,” Poon wrote.
The injunction contained exceptions for “academic activity and news activity,” a tweak the government made after earlier questioning by judges.
Representing the government during an appeal hearing in December last year, lawyer Benjamin Yu (余若海) had said the song was akin to “misinformation and propaganda.”
He said the song was still “prevalent” and “remains highly effective in arousing emotions of the public.”
A key issue raised by judges during the December hearing was how the government’s proposed order would affect Internet service providers.
Officials had demanded Internet giants such as Google remove the protest song from their search results and video platforms, but were largely rebuffed.
SHAKE-UP: Lam, who would be the third president in less than two years, emerged as one of the country’s most important officials after leading an anti-corruption effort Vietnam has nominated the enforcer of the Communist Party’s anti-corruption drive as the next president and proposed a new head of the National Assembly, in appointments that could ease months of political turmoil and allow policymakers to refocus on a struggling economy. Unprecedentedly for a one-party nation once known for its stable politics, two state presidents and a National Assembly speaker have stepped down in less than 18 months, all for unspecified “wrongdoing” amid a major anti-graft campaign which is unnerving foreign investors because of its chilling effect on bureaucracy. After approval from the National Assembly, which could come this week, Vietnamese
MOSTLY SYMBOLIC: The ruling party has a large enough majority to override the veto of the legislation, which the president said contradicts the constitution Georgia’s president on Saturday vetoed a so-called “Russian law” targeting media that has sparked weeks of mass protests. The legislation would require media and non-governmental organizations to register as “pursuing the interests of a foreign power” if they receive more than 20 percent of their funding from abroad. Critics of the bill say it closely resembles legislation used by the Kremlin to silence opponents, and that it would obstruct Georgia’s bid to join the EU. Georgian President Salome Zourabichvili, who is increasingly at odds with the ruling Georgian Dream party, said that the legislation contradicts the country’s constitution and “all European standards,” adding
Australian Minister for Defence Richard Marles yesterday said that newly elected Solomon Islands Prime Minister Jeremiah Manele had told him the Pacific Island nation is undertaking a security review that would determine the future of policing cooperation. A security pact struck with China in 2022 by then-Solomon Islands prime minister Manasseh Sogavare, who was pro-Beijing and encouraged Chinese infrastructure projects, alarmed Canberra and Washington amid concerns over China’s naval ambitions in the region. The Solomon Islands’ biggest aid donor, Australia provided policing support for national elections last month. China also has a policing presence on the archipelago, strategically located 1,600km northeast of
A powerful armed ethnic group in Myanmar yesterday said it had won control over a town in the western state of Rakhine after weeks of fighting, denying accusations it had targeted members of the Muslim-minority Rohingya during the offensive. Khine Thu Kha, a spokesman for the Arakan Army (AA), said its soldiers had taken Buthidaung near Myanmar’s border with Bangladesh, marking another battlefield defeat for the ruling junta that is fighting opposition groups on multiple fronts. “We have conquered all the bases in Buthidaung and also took over the town yesterday,” Khine Thu Kha said by telephone. Some Rohingya activists accuse the AA