Dueling experts on Thursday deployed statistics to make their case in the US District Court in Chicago in a first-of-its-kind hearing to determine if phony drug stash-house stings run by federal agents dating back to the 1990s are racially biased.
More than 40 people convicted in such stings could go free if a special nine-judge panel rules that discrimination underpins the stings.
The operations run by the US Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives typically involve agents posing as cartel couriers who talk suspects into agreeing to rob drugs that do not exist from stash houses that are also fictitious.
While the same question has come up in courts elsewhere, it is the federal trial judges in Chicago who have taken the lead in seeking an answer, and how they decide the sensitive and complex issue could determine if agencies curtail or even abandon their use nationwide.
The answer to whether the stings do or do not discriminate based on race largely hinges on competing interpretations of statistics.
Jeffrey Fagan, a defense expert who took the stand first, testified that data clearly shows blacks, and in some cases Hispanics, are disproportionately singled out for the stings.
US government witness Max Schanzenbach argued later that Fagan’s methodology was flawed.
One panelist, Judge Robert Gettleman, sounded doubtful that competing statistics could decide the question.
Highlighting the unreliability of statistics, he referred to Mark Twain’s quip about three kinds of lies: “Lies, damned lies and statistics.”
The judges on the panel each preside over 12 separate stash-house cases with 43 defendants, a dozen of whom sat in a jury box on Thursday.
Some yawned or sank in their seats as testimony strayed into mathematics and technical explanations about probabilities.
The judges chose to hear evidence simultaneously after lawyers for all 43 defendants moved for the stash-house charges to be tossed on grounds of racial bias.
How they decide — possibly in a single ruling — is expected to influence how courts nationwide deal with similar claims.
Among the panelists who were scheduled to hear a second day of testimony yesterday was Ruben Castillo. His ruling in 2013 that there is a “strong showing of potential bias” in the stings generated years of legal motions and dueling expert reports — culminating in this week’s hearings.
Castillo is the Chicago federal court’s first Hispanic chief judge.
Courts have ruled previously that proving racial bias does not necessarily require proof of explicit racist behavior, such as an official caught using racial slurs. It can sometimes be enough to point to statistical evidence that a racial group is disproportionately hurt by a policy.
Fagan noted that out of 94 stash-house defendants in the Chicago area between 2006 and 2013, 74 were black, 12 were Hispanic and just eight were white.
If the bureau’s criteria for picking targets were truly colorblind, he said, far more whites would have been snared, but government lawyers have argued it is only natural that trafficking-related stings are focused where trafficking activity is highest — in low-income areas in Chicago’s south and west.
The bureau’s expert said Fagan was wrong to assume in his analysis that hundreds of thousands of people in eight counties in and around Chicago would be willing to entertain the idea of arming themselves and storming a stash-house.
He said that assumption skewed Fagan’s findings that the 43 defendants, many of whom had previous convictions for violent crimes, were unfairly singled out.
The stings have been criticized on other grounds, including for agents’ power to arbitrarily increase the severity of charges simply by increasing the amount of non-existent drugs they tell targets are in the non-existent stash houses.
Suspects can also be charged with trying to distribute the phantom drugs, charges that carry stiff mandatory prison terms.
POLITICAL PRISONERS VS DEPORTEES: Venezuela’s prosecutor’s office slammed the call by El Salvador’s leader, accusing him of crimes against humanity Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele on Sunday proposed carrying out a prisoner swap with Venezuela, suggesting he would exchange Venezuelan deportees from the US his government has kept imprisoned for what he called “political prisoners” in Venezuela. In a post on X, directed at Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, Bukele listed off a number of family members of high-level opposition figures in Venezuela, journalists and activists detained during the South American government’s electoral crackdown last year. “The only reason they are imprisoned is for having opposed you and your electoral fraud,” he wrote to Maduro. “However, I want to propose a humanitarian agreement that
ECONOMIC WORRIES: The ruling PAP faces voters amid concerns that the city-state faces the possibility of a recession and job losses amid Washington’s tariffs Singapore yesterday finalized contestants for its general election on Saturday next week, with the ruling People’s Action Party (PAP) fielding 32 new candidates in the biggest refresh of the party that has ruled the city-state since independence in 1965. The move follows a pledge by Singaporean Prime Minister Lawrence Wong (黃循財), who took office last year and assumed the PAP leadership, to “bring in new blood, new ideas and new energy” to steer the country of 6 million people. His latest shake-up beats that of predecessors Lee Hsien Loong (李顯龍) and Goh Chok Tong (吳作棟), who replaced 24 and 11 politicians respectively
Young women standing idly around a park in Tokyo’s west suggest that a giant statue of Godzilla is not the only attraction for a record number of foreign tourists. Their faces lit by the cold glow of their phones, the women lining Okubo Park are evidence that sex tourism has developed as a dark flipside to the bustling Kabukicho nightlife district. Increasing numbers of foreign men are flocking to the area after seeing videos on social media. One of the women said that the area near Kabukicho, where Godzilla rumbles and belches smoke atop a cinema, has become a “real
‘WATER WARFARE’: A Pakistani official called India’s suspension of a 65-year-old treaty on the sharing of waters from the Indus River ‘a cowardly, illegal move’ Pakistan yesterday canceled visas for Indian nationals, closed its airspace for all Indian-owned or operated airlines, and suspended all trade with India, including to and from any third country. The retaliatory measures follow India’s decision to suspend visas for Pakistani nationals in the aftermath of a deadly attack by shooters in Kashmir that killed 26 people, mostly tourists. The rare attack on civilians shocked and outraged India and prompted calls for action against their country’s archenemy, Pakistan. New Delhi did not publicly produce evidence connecting the attack to its neighbor, but said it had “cross-border” links to Pakistan. Pakistan denied any connection to