The spectacular popular mobilization seeking an end to conflict in Sudan's Darfur region could damage efforts to stop the bloodshed at a time when real progress might be within reach, experts say.
An interpretation of the conflict as one between Arabs and Africans or even between moderates and Islamist extremists has helped mobilize the worldwide campaign, said Alex de Waal of the Social Science Research Council in New York.
"It's easy to take this simplified construct of Arabs and Africans and turn it into something that's meaningful, even though it may not be ethnographically or historically correct," he said.
France brings the US, China and some 15 other nations together for a major conference today in Paris aimed at launching a new international drive to end the atrocities in Darfur.
The conflict in Darfur has pitted a rebel insurgency against the Arab-dominated government in Khartoum and its proxy militia known as the janjaweed, whose leader stands accused of war crimes.
200,000 killed
At least 200,000 people have been killed and 2 million driven from their homes in Darfur since 2003, the UN said.
Khartoum, however, has always disputed those figures are too high.
The simplification of the conflict in the media and by pressure groups has helped the Darfur issue become so prominent in the US, de Waal said.
Lawrence Rossin of the Save Darfur Coalition, an alliance of groups that has been stridently pressing for international intervention in Sudan, says the US mobilization over Darfur is the biggest such activism there "since the campaign against the Vietnam war, especially among students."
The university activism ranges from appeals to block investment in Sudan to a video game devised by a student which places the player in the position of a refugee from the conflict.
"We have a million militants and 180 member organizations," said Rossin, a former US ambassador, who notes that he has been aided by Hollywood stars such as George Clooney and Mia Farrow.
But de Waal denounced the oversimplification of the conflict that has been made in order to draw in the wider public.
"A lot of the `African' groups have defected to join the government and a lot of the `Arab' groups have defected to join the rebels," he said.
The belligerents on both sides are black and Muslim, with Islamists present in both groups, he said.
Experts say that the government in Khartoum instrumentalized antagonism caused by desertification to pit traditional farmers against nomadic herders, from which came most of the janjaweed militia who are accused of the worst atrocities.
`Changed hugely'
"In the case of Darfur, where the situation is not only complicated but has changed hugely in the last three years, that simplification can be very problematic," de Waal said.
"The statements that genocide and massacres are still continuing is another ... and they're not, the predictions that unless urgent action is taken hundreds of thousands of people will die is another simplification," he said.
French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner, who has said that resolving the Darfur crisis will be one of his priorities, wrote in Le Monde newspaper last December of "Arab militias chasing black populations, fundamentalist Muslims trying to impose Shariah law on moderate Muslims."
"Darfur is still burning," Jacky Mamou, the president of Urgence Darfour, a coalition of rights groups in France, wrote in a recent book that carried Kouchner's Le Monde statement.
"The forced exodus of populations from Darfur is continuing," he said.
"We're no longer in the situation we were in in 2004 when there were 10,000 deaths a month, but we are in a very bad situation which cannot last," he said.
Former president of Doctors Without Borders Rony Brauman said that "giving a misleading vision of the situation will lead to totally inappropriate propositions for a resolution" of the conflict.
"What is at stake today is not to send in an intervention force because there is no space for intervention, it is rather to incite the belligerents to regroup, to reorganize and to begin discussions," he said.
Pressure
Sudan has bowed to months of pressure and agreed to the deployment of peacekeepers in Darfur under the UN and the African Union.
But Khartoum is boycotting today's Paris conference, angry that it was not consulted during preparations for the meeting and arguing that the French initiative will unnecessarily duplicate efforts by the UN and the African Union.
The African Union is also staying away, skeptical about the meeting's purpose and miffed at being kept out of the planning.
Oscar-winning actress Susan Sarandon and Scream star Melissa Barrera were each dropped by Hollywood companies after making comments on the Israel-Hamas war that some deemed anti-Semitic. Spyglass Media Group, the production company behind the upcoming Scream VII, acknowledged Barrera’s exit from the horror franchise. The Mexican-born actress, who starred in In the Heights and the two recent Scream installments, had posted statements on Instagram Stories calling the war “genocide and ethnic cleansing.” “Gaza is currently being treated like a concentration camp,” she wrote. Spyglass said in a statement that its position “is unequivocally clear: We have zero tolerance for antisemitism or the incitement
‘SYMBOLIC ATTACK’: Ukraine said it downed 74 of the Iranian-made drones, but five people were wounded in Kyiv, as people marked Holodomor Remembrance Day Ukraine on Saturday said it had downed 74 out of 75 drones Russia launched at it overnight, in what it said was the biggest such attack since the start of the invasion in February last year. The Ukrainian army said Russia had launched a “record number” of Iranian-made Shahed drones, the majority of which targeted Kyiv, causing power cuts as temperatures dipped below freezing. The drone attack came as Ukraine marked Holodomor Remembrance Day, commemorating the 1930s starvation of millions in Ukraine under Soviet leader Joseph Stalin. “The enemy launched a record number of attack drones at Ukraine. The main direction
Ecologists from the National Autonomous University of Mexico on Friday relaunched a fundraising campaign to bolster conservation efforts for axolotls, an iconic, endangered fish-like type of salamander. The campaign, called “Adoptaxolotl,” asks people for as little as 600 pesos (US$35) to virtually adopt one of the tiny “water monsters.” Virtual adoption comes with live updates on your axolotl’s health. For less, donors can buy one of the creatures a virtual dinner. In their main habitat the population density of Mexican axolotls has plummeted 99.5 percent in under two decades, scientists behind the fundraiser said. Last year’s Adoptaxolotl campaign raised just more than 450,000
CLAIMS: The North Korean leader reportedly inspected images taken by his new spy satellite of Pearl Harbor and a US nuclear-powered aircraft carrier in Busan State media yesterday said that North Korean leader Kim Jong-un reviewed images taken by his country’s new spy satellite of a US naval base at Pearl Harbor in Hawaii and “major target” sites across South Korea. Pyongyang said it put a military spy satellite into orbit this week, but Seoul said it was too early to determine if the satellite was functioning as the North claims. Experts have said putting a working reconnaissance satellite into orbit would improve North Korea’s intelligence-gathering capabilities, particularly over South Korea, and provide crucial data in any military conflict. Pyongyang previously said, within hours of the
RSS