The Constitutional Court yesterday heard arguments in a case involving the constitutionality of amendments to government oversight laws, with expert witnesses disagreeing on whether the legislative process was so flawed it should be declared void by the court.
The deliberation that led up to the passage of the amendments, which took effect on June 26, was fundamentally flawed because lawmakers approved the revisions by raising their hands and the names of the voters were not recorded, said expert witness Chang Wen-chen (張文貞), a law professor at National Taiwan University.
Chang cited a constitutional ruling in 2000, which said that such a voting method “contravened the principle of openness and transparency” and constituted “manifest and gross procedural flaws.”
Photo: CNA
In the 2000 ruling (Constitutional Interpretation No. 499), the court deemed the constitutional amendments adopted a year prior by the now-defunct National Assembly unconstitutional due in part to the use of secret ballots during the deliberation.
The oversight laws should be considered “quasi-constitutional statutes” as they “directly affected” the responsibilities of top government bodies stipulated in the Constitution, Chang said.
The case was brought to court by the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) caucus, the Executive Yuan, President William Lai (賴清德) and the Control Yuan in a bid to reject the oversight laws.
The amendments to the Act Governing the Legislative Yuan’s Power (立法院職權行使法) and the Criminal Code were pushed through by Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) lawmakers at the end of May. The Constitutional Court issued an injunction that halted the enforcement of some revisions, including those that would give legislators much broader investigative powers.
Responding to Chang’s arguments, expert witness Ed Huang (黃銘輝), an associate professor at National Taipei University’s Department of Law, said the oversight laws did not apply the “vigorous” views adopted in the 2000 ruling and that the Constitutional Court should instead consider the 1994 ruling (Constitutional Interpretation No. 342) on the Organic Act of the National Security Council (國家安全會議組織法).
That ruling highlighted the court’s adherence to the “principle of legislative autonomy,” according to which the court should respect the legislature as an entity that operates under its own rules and procedures, Huang said.
The ruling also said the court should intervene only in the event of major flaws in the legislative process, defined as those that “can be determined ... without investigation into the facts,” Huang said.
Although the oversight laws were passed by lawmakers raising their hands in approval, they were legitimate according to the legislature’s rules of procedure, TPP caucus whip Huang Kuo-chang (黃國昌) said.
Neither electronic nor recorded voting is a “default rule” in the legislative process, he added.
However, attorney Chen Peng-kwang (陳鵬光), representing the DPP caucus, said that electronic and recorded voting had been adopted in the legislative process “by convention” for the past three decades.
The passage of the oversight amendments was an exception, because Legislative Speaker Han Kuo-yu (韓國瑜) contravened long-standing convention and disregarded the principle of openness and transparency, Chen said.
The oral arguments, which lasted until 5pm, also touched upon updated measures that expand the legislature’s investigative powers and require the president to periodically address the legislature and then take questions.
The case is being presided over by 15 justices, who were all appointed by former president Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) of the DPP.
Under the Constitutional Court Procedure Act (憲法訴訟法), the approval of at least eight justices is required for any of the amendments to be annulled.
The court should rule on te case within three months of the conclusion of oral arguments, but the deadline can be extended by two months if necessary.
UNILATERAL MOVES: Officials have raised concerns that Beijing could try to exert economic control over Kinmen in a key development plan next year The Civil Aviation Administration (CAA) yesterday said that China has so far failed to provide any information about a new airport expected to open next year that is less than 10km from a Taiwanese airport, raising flight safety concerns. Xiamen Xiangan International Airport is only about 3km at its closest point from the islands in Kinmen County — the scene of on-off fighting during the Cold War — and construction work can be seen and heard clearly from the Taiwan side. In a written statement sent to Reuters, the CAA said that airports close to each other need detailed advanced
Tropical Storm Fung-Wong would likely strengthen into a typhoon later today as it continues moving westward across the Pacific before heading in Taiwan’s direction next week, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. As of 8am, Fung-Wong was about 2,190km east-southeast of Cape Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻), Taiwan’s southernmost point, moving westward at 25kph and possibly accelerating to 31kph, CWA data showed. The tropical storm is currently over waters east of the Philippines and still far from Taiwan, CWA forecaster Tseng Chao-cheng (曾昭誠) said, adding that it could likely strengthen into a typhoon later in the day. It is forecast to reach the South China Sea
Almost a quarter of volunteer soldiers who signed up from 2021 to last year have sought early discharge, the Legislative Yuan’s Budget Center said in a report. The report said that 12,884 of 52,674 people who volunteered in the period had sought an early exit from the military, returning NT$895.96 million (US$28.86 million) to the government. In 2021, there was a 105.34 percent rise in the volunteer recruitment rate, but the number has steadily declined since then, missing recruitment targets, the Chinese-language United Daily News said, citing the report. In 2021, only 521 volunteers dropped out of the military, the report said, citing
WEATHER Typhoon forming: CWA A tropical depression is expected to form into a typhoon as early as today, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said yesterday, adding that the storm’s path remains uncertain. Before the weekend, it would move toward the Philippines, the agency said. Some time around Monday next week, it might reach a turning point, either veering north toward waters east of Taiwan or continuing westward across the Philippines, the CWA said. Meanwhile, the eye of Typhoon Kalmaegi was 1,310km south-southeast of Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻), Taiwan’s southernmost point, as of 2am yesterday, it said. The storm is forecast to move through central
RSS