For 40 years, the annual Han Kuang exercises have tested the military’s combat readiness in the face of a possible Chinese invasion.
The military drills usually feature large-scale live-fire demonstrations, with the president and top generals watching over the highly-publicized missile launches and anti-amphibious landing exercises.
Extensive media coverage of the drills is ostensibly to keep the public informed about the latest developments in the armed forces and to reassure them that the troops are capable of defending the nation.
Photo courtesy of Military News Agency
The Han Kuang drills have long been criticized for being little more than a photo-op that has limited practical impact on defense preparedness, but this year major changes are expected — prompted by President William Lai’s (賴清德) appointment of a new minister of defense who has a bold new vision for the Han Kuang exercises.
Wellington Koo (顧立雄), the first defense minister since 2013 who is neither an active nor retired general, announced last month that he would cancel most live-fire exercises that are “done for show or demonstration purposes.”
Other aspects of the drills this year also face an overhaul, the Ministry of National Defense said.
First, this year’s live-fire exercises would be held at night for the first time to test the armed forces’ 24-hour defense capabilities.
Second, the military’s decentralized command structure would also be put to the test for the first time, with exercises monitoring units’ decision-making capabilities in scenarios simulating loss of contact with the central command during wartime.
Third, each soldier would be expected to follow updated Rules of Engagement (ROE) instructions that explain under what kinds of circumstances they are authorized to use certain weapons or launch counterattacks, for instance.
Although the live-fire aspect would be reduced in this year’s drills, participating troops would be more rigorously tested in a variety of scenarios that could occur without prior warning in a cross-strait war, the ministry said.
Some military experts have praised the proposed changes.
Tamkang University Graduate Institute of International Affairs and Strategic Studies assistant professor Lin Ying-yu (林穎佑) said the live-fire drills of previous Han Kuang exercises were impressive to watch, but had little value in preparing for real battlefield scenarios.
Lin also praised Koo’s decision to test units’ familiarity with the updated ROE, which was revised last year, following repeated incursions into Taiwan’s air defense identification zone by Chinese warplanes, drones and balloons.
“In the event of a [Chinese] People’s Liberation Army full-scale invasion, it is highly likely that soldiers on the frontline could lose contact with the central command, because the enemy would prioritize destroying communication systems,” he said.
It is extremely important that soldiers knows their ROE, informing them where their defensive posts are, and when and how to counterattack, he added.
Lin also said that most of the exercises in previous drills were scripted and planned so that participating troops knew exactly when and where the simulated “invading force” would show up.
This year, the simulated “enemy attack” could happen anytime and anywhere with any available weapon systems, which would better simulate real battlefield conditions
However, some experts were critical of the move.
Retired air force lieutenant general Chang Yen-ting (張延廷) criticized the decision to cancel the practical war game segment during a political talk show on June 24.
“How can soldiers fight if they cannot see their enemies? What will they be shooting at without simulated targets?” he said.
Chang was referring to simulated “invasions” at critical defensive positions across Taiwan where some military units were designated to play the role of “red” invading forces while other units posed as “blue” defense troops.
These red-blue team exercises have been canceled in this year’s exercises, the ministry said.
Chang said that without a simulated enemy, the military exercises would be unrealistic and lack practical value.
“We might as well call off the Han Kuang drills,” he added.
Chief of the General Staff Admiral Mei Chia-shu (梅家樹) said at a June 26 legislative session that the main focus of this year’s drills is to allow combined-arms brigades to focus on “familiarizing themselves with the environment they will be defending should a war break out and practice their defensive plans.”
Given the unrehearsed nature of the new drills format, the ministry canceled most of this year’s live-fire exercises to reduce the chance of unforeseen incidents, Mei said.
However, this does not mean that the armed forces have abandoned live-fire training and landing defense exercises, Mei said.
Live-fire drills would also be staged at two other routine exercises scheduled for this year.
Although live-fire drills have been canceled on Taiwan proper, troops stationed on the nation’s outlying islands would conduct live-fire drills from July 22 to 26, he added.
Su Tzu-yun (蘇紫雲), a research fellow at Taiwan’s military-funded Institute for National Defense and Security Research, said he understands the rationale behind the changes.
Su said the simulated “situations” would not be announced in advance to put participating military personnel under greater pressure. This would simulate situations that more closely resemble actual combat scenarios.
Chieh Chung (揭仲), a researcher at the Taipei-based think tank Association of Strategic Foresight, does not believe the changes proposed by the new defense minister are a good idea.
Chieh said the military could have made the combat training more “realistic and unscripted” rather than “canceling them altogether.”
He also said it is illogical that the ministry canceled live-fire exercises for troops on Taiwan proper during Han Kuang while continuing live-round shootings on the nation’s outlying islands.
The live-fire component of the annual Han Kuang exercises is scheduled to run from July 22 to 26 this year.
STAY AWAY: An official said people should avoid disturbing snakes, as most do not actively attack humans, but would react defensively if threatened Taitung County authorities yesterday urged the public to stay vigilant and avoid disturbing snakes in the wild, following five reported snakebite cases in the county so far this year. Taitung County Fire Department secretary Lin Chien-cheng (林建誠) said two of the cases were in Donghe Township (東河) and involved the Taiwan habus, one person was bit by a Chinese pit viper near the South Link Railway and the remaining two were caused by unidentified snakes. He advised residents near fields to be cautious of snakes hiding in shady indoor areas, especially when entering or leaving their homes at night. In case of a
A tropical disturbance off the southeastern coast of the Philippines might become the first typhoon of the western Pacific typhoon season, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. The system lacks a visible center and how it would develop is only likely to become clear on Sunday or Monday, the CWA said, adding that it was not yet possible to forecast the potential typhoon's effect on Taiwan. The American Meteorological Society defines a tropical disturbance as a system made up of showers and thunderstorms that lasts for at least 24 hours and does not have closed wind circulation.
ENERGY RESILIENCE: Although Alaska is open for investments, Taiwan is sourcing its gas from the Middle East, and the sea routes carry risks, Ho Cheng-hui said US government officials’ high-profile reception of a Taiwanese representative at the Alaska Sustainable Energy Conference indicated the emergence of an Indo-Pacific energy resilience alliance, an academic said. Presidential Office Secretary-General Pan Men-an (潘孟安) attended the conference in Alaska on Thursday last week at the invitation of the US government. Pan visited oil and gas facilities with senior US officials, including US Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum, US Secretary of Energy Chris Wright, Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy and US Senator Daniel Sullivan. Pan attending the conference on behalf of President William Lai (賴清德) shows a significant elevation in diplomatic representation,
Credit departments of farmers’ and fishers’ associations blocked a total of more than NT$180 million (US$6.01 million) from being lost to scams last year, National Police Agency (NPA) data showed. The Agricultural Finance Agency (AFA) said last week that staff of farmers’ and fishers’ associations’ credit departments are required to implement fraud prevention measures when they serve clients at the counter. They would ask clients about personal financial management activities whenever they suspect there might be a fraud situation, and would immediately report the incident to local authorities, which would send police officers to the site to help, it said. NPA data showed
RSS