The Constitutional Court on Tuesday heard oral arguments in the case of a woman suing the government for discrimination after being disqualified from serving as a firefighter because she was deemed too short.
In 2018, the plaintiff, surnamed Chen (陳), passed the class 4 firefighter and police certification test, but failed the physical examination as, at 158.9cm, she was 1.1cm short of the height requirement.
The Civil Service Protection and Training Commission a year later rejected her application to be a firefighter, citing the height requirement stipulated in the regulations governing qualifications for police officers and firefighters.
Photo: Screen grab from a Constitutional Court’s video
Chen’s lawyer told the court that the height requirement is discriminatory and that barring Chen from becoming a firefighter is an infringement of her right to work in government.
The requirements that non-
indigenous female police and firefighter applicants must be at least 160cm tall has no rational basis, her lawyer said, adding that setting separate certification standards for genders and ethnicities is discriminatory.
The height requirement for men to join the service is less stringent than for women, as more than 90 percent of 18-year-old Taiwanese men meet the 165cm requirement, but only 45 percent of 18-year-old Taiwanese women meet the 160cm requirement, the lawyer said.
Setting height requirements according to gender and ethnicity is a form of discrimination based on intrinsic and unalterable traits, which is not constitutionally justifiable, the lawyer said.
In addition, the regulation states that physical examinations are to be conducted “when necessary,” which is vague legal language that contravenes the doctrine against ambiguity in law, they said.
Lawyers representing the Ministry of Examination and the Ministry of the Interior said that the rules on height requirements are to help ensure that firefighters and police officers are strong enough to perform their functions, which is legally justifiable.
The opportunity to work in public service is rightfully limited to people possessing appropriate competencies and qualifications, they said.
Establishing standards for a type of service is typically the executive branch’s prerogative, which cannot be challenged without cause, the lawyers said.
Height standards differ according to gender due to fieldwork requirements, they said, adding that the height requirement for indigenous people, who are shorter than the average Taiwanese, is lower to ensure equal opportunities.
The recruiting agency’s order for Chen to undergo additional physical examinations to ensure she met the physical standards is a proper exercise of discretion and demonstration of what necessity meant in the rules, they said.
Removing the height requirement would compromise public safety and could place the lives of first responders at a higher risk, National Fire Agency Director-General Hsiao Huan-chang (蕭煥章) told the court.
Judicial Yuan President Hsu Tzong-li (宗力諭) said the court would deliver its judgement no later than five months after the hearing in accordance with the law.
The inspection equipment and data transmission system for new robotic dogs that Taipei is planning to use for sidewalk patrols were developed by a Taiwanese company, the city’s New Construction Office said today, dismissing concerns that the China-made robots could pose a security risk. The city is bringing in smart robotic dogs to help with sidewalk inspections, Taipei Deputy Mayor Lee Ssu-chuan (李四川) said on Facebook. Equipped with a panoramic surveillance system, the robots would be able to automatically flag problems and easily navigate narrow sidewalks, making inspections faster and more accurate, Lee said. By collecting more accurate data, they would help Taipei
TAKING STOCK: The USMC is rebuilding a once-abandoned airfield in Palau to support large-scale ground operations as China’s missile range grows, Naval News reported The US Marine Corps (USMC) is considering new sites for stockpiling equipment in the West Pacific to harden military supply chains and enhance mobility across the Indo-Pacific region, US-based Naval News reported on Saturday. The proposed sites in Palau — one of Taiwan’s diplomatic allies — and Australia would enable a “rapid standup of stored equipment within a year” of the program’s approval, the report said, citing documents published by the USMC last month. In Palau, the service is rebuilding a formerly abandoned World War II-era airfield and establishing ancillary structures to support large-scale ground operations “as China’s missile range and magazine
STATS: Taiwan’s average life expectancy of 80.77 years was lower than that of Japan, Singapore and South Korea, but higher than in China, Malaysia and Indonesia Taiwan’s average life expectancy last year increased to 80.77 years, but was still not back to its pre-COVID-19 pandemic peak of 81.32 years in 2020, the Ministry of the Interior said yesterday. The average life expectancy last year increased the 0.54 years from 2023, the ministry said in a statement. For men and women, the average life expectancy last year was 77.42 years and 84.30 years respectively, up 0.48 years and 0.56 years from the previous year. Taiwan’s average life expectancy peaked at 81.32 years in 2020, as the nation was relatively unaffected by the pandemic that year. The metric
A 72-year-old man in Kaohsiung was sentenced to 40 days in jail after he was found having sex with a 67-year-old woman under a slide in a public park on Sunday afternoon. At 3pm on Sunday, a mother surnamed Liang (梁) was with her child at a neighborhood park when they found the man, surnamed Tsai (蔡), and woman, surnamed Huang (黃), underneath the slide. Liang took her child away from the scene, took photographs of the two and called the police, who arrived and arrested the couple. During questioning, Tsai told police that he had met Huang that day and offered to
RSS