The Constitutional Court on Friday ruled that corroborated statements given to prosecutors or judicial police by absent witnesses are admissible as evidence.
The court issued the ruling in response to a request for an interpretation filed by death row inmates Wang Hsin-fu (王信福) and Shen Hung-lin (沈鴻霖), along with three other people in April last year.
That filing said that Article 159-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (刑事訴訟法) contradicted Article 8 of the Constitution, which deals with basic rules for arrests, detention and trials, and also contradicts Article 16 of the Constitution, which protects people’s litigation rights, on the grounds that the article deprives defendants of their right of confrontation, and that it allows “uncorroborated” police statements to serve as evidence.
Photo: Wu Cheng-feng, Taipei Times
The petitioners questioned the constitutionality of clauses allowing prosecutors or judicial police officers to use corroborated statements already given by the litigants as evidence, if such statements are necessary for proving guilt or innocence when witnesses cannot attend a trial.
While acknowledging that Article 159-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure would curtail defendants’ right to cross-examine witnesses, the Constitutional Court in its ruling pointed to the provision that requires a court to scrutinize statements given by absent witnesses in addition to ensuring that the defendant’s right of confrontation is duly compensated for and thus adequately protected.
Additionally, statements provided to prosecutors or judicial police officers by absent witnesses prior to a trial may not serve as the sole piece of evidence based on which a court passes down a guilty verdict, the ruling said.
As such, Article 159-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure does not contradict articles 8 and 16 of the Constitution, the ruling said.
The Supreme Court in 2011 sentenced Wang to death for ordering Chen Jung-chieh (陳榮傑) to fatally shoot two police officers in 1990. Chen was sentenced to death in 1992 and executed that same year. Wang fled and was not apprehended until 2006.
Shen is on death row for raping and killing two female workers in their dormitory with two other perpetrators, Huang Hsi-jen (黃錫任) and Huang Chi-hsiung (黃啟雄), who were arrested and executed in 1990 and 1991 respectively.
Shen was not captured until 2003. The Supreme Court in 2009 sentenced him to death.
Greenpeace yesterday said that it is to appeal a decision last month by the Taipei High Administrative Court to dismiss its 2021 lawsuit against the Ministry of Economic Affairs over “loose” regulations governing major corporate electricity consumers. The climate-related lawsuit — the first of its kind in Taiwan — sought to require the government to enforce higher green energy thresholds on major corporations to reduce emissions in light of climate change and an uptick in extreme weather. The suit, filed by Greenpeace East Asia, the Environmental Jurists Association and four individual plaintiffs, was dismissed on May 8 following four years of litigation. The
STAY AWAY: An official said people should avoid disturbing snakes, as most do not actively attack humans, but would react defensively if threatened Taitung County authorities yesterday urged the public to stay vigilant and avoid disturbing snakes in the wild, following five reported snakebite cases in the county so far this year. Taitung County Fire Department secretary Lin Chien-cheng (林建誠) said two of the cases were in Donghe Township (東河) and involved the Taiwan habus, one person was bit by a Chinese pit viper near the South Link Railway and the remaining two were caused by unidentified snakes. He advised residents near fields to be cautious of snakes hiding in shady indoor areas, especially when entering or leaving their homes at night. In case of a
A tropical disturbance off the southeastern coast of the Philippines might become the first typhoon of the western Pacific typhoon season, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. The system lacks a visible center and how it would develop is only likely to become clear on Sunday or Monday, the CWA said, adding that it was not yet possible to forecast the potential typhoon's effect on Taiwan. The American Meteorological Society defines a tropical disturbance as a system made up of showers and thunderstorms that lasts for at least 24 hours and does not have closed wind circulation.
DIPLOMACY: It is Guatemalan President Bernardo Arevalo’s first visit to Taiwan since he took office last year, while Eswatini’s foreign minister is also paying a visit A delegation led by Guatemalan President Bernardo Arevalo arrived in Taiwan yesterday afternoon and is to visit President William Lai (賴清德) today. The delegation arrived at Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport at 4:55pm, and was greeted by Minister of Foreign Affairs Lin Chia-lung (林佳龍). It is Arevalo’s first trip to Taiwan since he took office last year, and following the visit, he is to travel to Japan to celebrate the 90th anniversary of diplomatic relations between the two countries. Arevalo said at the airport that he is very glad to make the visit to Taiwan, adding that he brings an important message of responsibility
RSS