A decade-long spat over a high-end bakery’s use of artificial ingredients in “all-natural” bread has ended with the Supreme Court awarding NT$3.42 million (US$111,473) in compensation to dissatisified customers.
The Consumers’ Foundation in a statement on Thursday said that Top Pot Bakery lost its appeal against a lower court ruling ordering it to pay 864 customers purchase-based compensation plus damages of NT$1,000 each.
The case began in August 2013 when a baker at Top Pot Bakery — which claimed its products were free of artificial ingredients — confessed to a Hong Kong blogger that the chain did indeed use such additives.
Photo: Chang Chuan-chia, Taipei Times
The bakery chain, which was established in late 2010, offered refunds or replacements following the revelation, but many customers were unwilling to accept the offer.
The Consumers’ Foundation in April 2014 filed a lawsuit with the Taipei District Court against former Top Pot Bakery chairman Chuang Hung-ming (莊鴻銘), then-chairman Hsu Hsun-ping (徐洵平) and entertainer Little S (小S, also known as Dee Hsu, 徐熙娣), asking for NT$25.6 million in compensation on behalf of 1,060 customers.
The consumer watchdog initially asked for the repayment of the original funds spent, plus three times that amount in punitive penalties and an additional NT$20,000 per person in psychological damage.
The Consumers’ Foundation said it listed Little S as a defendant because she had used her celebrity status to promote Top Pot’s products and should be held responsible for misleading the public.
The Taipei District Court in 2020 ruled that the firm, Chuang and Hsu Hsun-ping should jointly compensate 897 customers a total of NT$5.382 million.
However, the district court ruled that Little S was not liable for Top Pot’s false claims, as she had only said that the bakery’s products were “delicious” at a promotional event.
After an appeal, the High Court modified the lower court’s decision last year and ordered the company, Chuang and Hsu Hsun-ping to pay NT$3.42 million in compensation to 864 customers.
The High Court said the ruling, upheld by the Supreme Court, was made with consideration that Top Pot had already paid more than NT$100 million in out-of-court settlements.
SHIPS, TRAINS AND AUTOMOBILES: The ministry has announced changes to varied transportation industries taking effect soon, with a number of effects for passengers Beginning next month, the post office is canceling signature upon delivery and written inquiry services for international registered small packets in accordance with the new policy of the Universal Postal Union, the Ministry of Transportation and Communications said yesterday. The new policy does not apply to packets that are to be delivered to China, the ministry said. Senders of international registered small packets would receive a NT$10 rebate on postage if the packets are sent from Jan. 1 to March 31, it added. The ministry said that three other policies are also scheduled to take effect next month. International cruise ship operators
NUMBERS IMBALANCE: More than 4 million Taiwanese have visited China this year, while only about half a million Chinese have visited here Beijing has yet to respond to Taiwan’s requests for negotiation over matters related to the recovery of cross-strait tourism, the Tourism Administration said yesterday. Taiwan’s tourism authority issued the statement after Chinese-language daily the China Times reported yesterday that the government’s policy of banning group tours to China does not stop Taiwanese from visiting the country. As of October, more than 4.2 million had traveled to China this year, exceeding last year. Beijing estimated the number of Taiwanese tourists in China could reach 4.5 million this year. By contrast, only 500,000 Chinese tourists are expected in Taiwan, the report said. The report
HORROR STORIES: One victim recounted not realizing they had been stabbed and seeing people bleeding, while another recalled breaking down in tears after fleeing A man on Friday died after he tried to fight the knife-wielding suspect who went on a stabbing spree near two of Taipei’s busiest metro stations, Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an (蔣萬安) said. The 57-year-old man, identified by his family name, Yu (余), encountered the suspect at Exit M7 of Taipei Main Station and immediately tried to stop him, but was fatally wounded and later died, Chiang said, calling the incident “heartbreaking.” Yu’s family would receive at least NT$5 million (US$158,584) in compensation through the Taipei Rapid Transit Corp’s (TRTC) insurance coverage, he said after convening an emergency security response meeting yesterday morning. National
The Forestry and Nature Conservation Agency yesterday launched a gift box to market honey “certified by a Formosan black bear” in appreciation of a beekeeper’s amicable interaction with a honey-thieving bear. Beekeeper Chih Ming-chen (池明鎮) in January inspected his bee farm in Hualien County’s Jhuosi Township (卓溪) and found that more than 20 beehives had been destroyed and many hives were eaten, with bear droppings and paw prints near the destroyed hives, the agency said. Chih returned to the farm to move the remaining beehives away that evening when he encountered a Formosan black bear only 20m away, the agency said. The bear
RSS