The High Court’s acquittal of the New Party’s Wang Ping-chung (王炳忠) on spying charges showed that judges do not understand how severely Chinese espionage undermines Taiwan’s democracy, two legal experts said yesterday.
The High Court on Friday acquitted Wang; fellow New Party members Ho Han-ting (侯漢廷) and Lin Ming-cheng (林明正); Wang’s father, Wang Chin-pu (王進步); and Chinese student Zhou Hongxu (周泓旭) of espionage charges in a ruling that upheld a Taipei District Court acquittal in April last year.
They were indicted in June 2018 over alleged breaches of the National Security Act (國家安全法), after they were accused of receiving funding from entities controlled by the Chinese People’s Liberation Army, which prosecutors said they used to set up propaganda Web sites.
Photo: CNA
Zhou was in 2017 convicted in a separate case of spying for China and sentenced to 14 months in prison.
Taipei prosecutor Lin Da (林達) said that as China updates and increases its online disinformation campaigns and cyberattacks on Taiwan, “judiciary officials and existing laws have not kept up,” and have proven to be an “insufficient defense mechanism” against espionage.
Taiwanese have long felt that judges lack an understanding of the serious harm Chinese spying has on society, Lin Da said.
Earlier this month, the Hualien District Court sentenced Yin Yuan-cheng (尹垣程), the administrator of two Facebook groups, to three months in prison for spreading misinformation about COVID-19, after he was arrested in December 2020 for allegedly spreading disinformation as an agent of the Chinese government.
“China and its cyberarmy take advantage of Taiwan’s freedom and democracy to engage in cognitive warfare to subvert Taiwan’s democracy,” Lin Da said. “When judges give lenient sentences or acquittals in these cases, they harm national security, as China will be even more brazen in conducting espionage with more sophisticated methods.”
Lin Da said that Beijing believes it can influence Taiwan slowly, and that Taiwanese would have trouble perceiving the gradual abuse of free speech and manipulation of public opinion.
“It looks to many people like the judges are encouraging China to conduct more covert activities,” said attorney Huang Di-ying (黃帝穎), who is chairman of the Taiwan Forever Society.
Huang said that the defendants acquitted in Friday’s cases were accused of developing a spy network for China by setting up youth and student organizations, and online chat groups, but the court ruled that prosecutors lacked clear evidence that they were operating as spies and that their actions did not present a “clear and immediate danger” to national security.
The ruling was contrary to most people’s expectations and counter to prevailing interpretations of laws, he said.
“This and other recent cases show that the courts are letting Chinese proxies off the hook on very shaky reasoning,” he said. “Judges are giving Chinese operatives the green light to come to Taiwan to infiltrate our society.”
Taiwan should learn from Australia and the US how to get tough on espionage cases, as they have amended national security laws and enacted statutes on foreign proxies, he said.
STRONG RELATIONSHIPS: China would not blockade Taiwan, because President Xi respects him, and Russia would not have invaded if he were president, he said Former US president and the Republican candidate in next month’s presidential election Donald Trump said he would impose additional tariffs on China if China were to “go into Taiwan,” the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reported. “I would say: If you go into Taiwan, I’m sorry to do this, I’m going to tax you, at 150 percent to 200 percent,” Trump was quoted as saying in an interview with the WSJ published on Friday. Asked if he would use military force against a blockade on Taiwan by China, Trump said it would not come to that because Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) respected
The Taipei Department of Transportation discouraged YouBike 2.0E users from taking them on long-distance trips after a Taipei city councilor said that riders often use the new electric bike, YouBike 2.0E, to climb Yangmingshan (陽明山). Taipei earlier this year began offering the first 30 minutes of YouBike 2.0 rentals for free, with Taipei and New Taipei offering the YouBike 2.0E on Aug. 30 to encourage rider usage. For YouBike 2.0, the rate is NT$10 per 30 minutes within the first four hours, NT$20 per 30 minutes for five to eight hours and NT$40 per 30 minutes after eight hours. Meanwhile, for e-bikes,
RESOURCE RICH: Taiwan is located in the Pacific Ring of Fire and has up to 30 gigawatts of the potential energy, of which 10 gigawatts could be economically viable Academia Sinica and CPC Corp yesterday began drilling the nation’s first deep geothermal well in Yilan County’s Yuanshan Township (員山). The 4km-deep well is expected to take 18 months to complete and has an estimated investment of NT$337 million (US$10.54 million), Academia Sinica President James Liao (廖俊智) said. “While Taiwan has up to 30 gigawatts of potential deep geothermal energy, with an estimated 10 gigawatts being economically viable, only by digging wells can we determine the actual amount of commercially viable geothermal energy,” Liao said at the project’s opening ceremony. Data collected during and after the excavation process would be used for future
HACKERS’ MARKET: Chat logs about Taiwan and documents outlining ways to take over online accounts were leaked from a company that sells data from hacks Taiwanese cybersecurity specialists found 577 leaked documents which show that the Chinese Communist Party is engaging in “cognitive warfare” against Taiwan through cyberattacks and disinformation campaigns, a documentary released last month by Japanese public broadcaster NHK showed. The filmmakers behind Tracking China’s Leaked Documents said they spent six months visiting seven countries, including Taiwan, where they interviewed members of TeamT5, a malware research and cybersecurity firm, which found the leaked documents. TeamT5 said they discovered a string of mysterious URLs on the social media platform X, which they suspected could be accounts created by hackers or people who leaked data, which led