A former US official yesterday strongly endorsed the so-called “1992 consensus” advocated by President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九), while saying Democratic Progressive Party presidential candidate Tsai Ing-wen’s (蔡英文) proposed “Taiwan consensus” was vague.
Douglas Paal, vice president for studies at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace who served as director of the American Institute in Taiwan from 2002 to 2006, weighed in on one of the main issues in the election when he talked about cross-strait relations during an interview with CtiTV.
Tsai has proposed a “Taiwan consensus” that highlights the democratic process of decision-making on cross-strait policies and rejects the “1992 consensus,” which she says exists only between the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) to impose a “one China” framework.
Photo: CNA
When Ma took office in 2008, he quickly acknowledged the “1992 consensus,” calling it a formula that allows Taiwan and China to interpret “one China” in their respective way and serving as a basis for developing cross-strait ties.
Sixteen cross-strait agreements were signed during his term.
In the interview, Paal described the “Taiwan consensus” as “a way of saying [that Tsai has] no desire to reach cross-strait agreements.”
“The US looks at the ‘Taiwan consensus’ and we know that it is not possible, because we know Taiwan was deeply divided about its future relations with China,” he said, adding the concept conflicts with Tsai’s comments during her campaign that she would continue the current cross-strait process if elected.
China also opposes the “Taiwan consensus” and calls it a “game” not only because it is impossible in the medium term, but also because it allows for independence, he said.
“I, too, don’t see a basis for a ‘Taiwan consensus,’” Paal said.
In Washington, “everybody hopes Taiwan can have a consensus. Everyone would like Taiwan to be of one mind about its future, but it’s still a remote possibility. Maybe decades will be required before something like a consensus can be formed,” he said.
Paal said he thinks highly of the “1992 consensus,” adding that it has been an “effective means” for two sides that are at odds on ways to cooperate while holding on to their own principles.
This is what the US and China have done on several occasions, Paal said, citing as an example the way the two countries have found a way to cooperate even when they have big disagreements, such as over US arms sales to Taiwan.
Paal said Chinese officials had signaled several times last year that they would like to open the door for discussions with the DPP on different formulas “because they were aware that Dr Tsai has criticized [the] 1992 consensus,” but the formula was not forthcoming at the end of the campaign and then Chinese officials became more vocal and insisted that the “1992 consensus” must be respected.
He did not elaborate.
If Tsai wins the election, Paal said he believed the US government “will be massively and quickly engaged to try to help her come to a formula that would preserve [cross-strait] peace and stability.”
Asked about the impact of a DPP victory on cross-strait relations and US-Taiwan ties, Paal said he would like to broaden the issue to a regional level.
“The US and China are both sitting on the edge of their chairs, nervous about the outcome of this upcoming election in Taiwan,” Paal said.
At a time when the US and China are cooperating on issues such as North Korea, Iran and the South China Sea and many others, “the absence of tension [in the] Taiwan Strait has been a big lubricant to better US-China relations and [has] improved international atmosphere in this part of the world,” he said.
The “secret leak” to the Financial Times, in which a senior US official said in September that Washington mistrusts Tsai in her handling of cross-strait relations was “the private feeling of the senior administration officials generally,” Paal said.
He said the assurances Tsai gave to Washington about cross-strait management “were too vague to make Washington comfortable.”
“The US, I am sure, is trying to send a very strong signal that she has to, from the very beginning after the day of the election, not do anything to make any situation worse and try to find means to persuade China that she is not a threat to their perception of what’s required for peace and stability in the cross-strait area,” Paal said.
Paal led a group joined by James Keith, a former US envoy to Malaysia and a former deputy assistant secretary of state, and Steven Goldstein, director of the Taiwan Studies Workshop at Harvard University’s Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, to observe the elections.
At the invitation of the Prospect Foundation, a government-affiliated institute, they will also attend a closed-door forum on the situation in North East Asia on Sunday.
Paal visited the People First Party campaign office yesterday and will visit Tsai’s headquarters today and Ma’s in the morning on Election Day.
Asked about Paal’s visit, AIT spokesperson Christopher Kavanagh said Paal was a private citizen and that his remarks were his “personal views.”
“The AIT did not arrange his trip to Taiwan. We are happy to work with whoever the people of Taiwan elect. We don’t take sides in the election,” Kavanagh said.
Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) is aware that Beijing’s treatment of Hong Kong has weakened any possible sentiment for a “one country, two systems” arrangement for Taiwan, and has instructed Chinese Communist Party (CCP) politburo member Wang Huning (王滬寧) to develop new ways of defining cross-strait relations, Japanese news magazine Nikkei Asia reported on Thursday. A former professor of international politics at Fu Dan University, Wang is expected to develop a dialogue that could serve as the foundation for cross-strait unification, and Xi plans to use the framework to support a fourth term as president, Nikkei Asia quoted an anonymous source
LUCKY DATE: The man picked the 10th ‘Super Red Envelope’ in a lottery store in Taoyuan’s Jhongli because he broke up with his girlfriend on Jan. 10 A man who recently broke up with his girlfriend won a NT$1 million (US$32,929) prize in the “NT$20 million Super Red Envelope” lottery after picking a card based on the date of their breakup, Taiwan Lottery Co said yesterday. The man, in his 20s, bought the 10th ticket at a lottery store in Taoyuan’s Jhongli District (中壢), because he broke up with his girlfriend on Jan. 10, the store owner told the lottery company. The “Super Red Envelope” lottery was a limited offering by the company during the Lunar New Year holiday, which ended yesterday. The cards, which cost NT$2,000 each, came with
TOURISM BOOST: The transportation system could help attract more visitors to the area, as the line is to connect multiple cultural sites, a city councilor said Residents in New Taipei City’s Ankeng District (安坑) said the local light rail system might have a positive influence, but raised questions about its practicality. The Ankeng light rail system, which is to commence operations after the Lunar New Year holiday, would cut travel time for commuters from Ankeng to downtown Taipei or New Taipei City by 15 to 20 minutes, the city government said. According to the initial plan, there would be one train every 15 minutes during peak time and additional interval trains would run between the densely populated Ankang Station (安康) and Shisizhang Station (十 四張). To encourage people to
CHAMPION TREES: The team used light detection and ranging imaging to locate the tree, and found that it measured a height of 84.1m and had a girth of 8.5m A team committed to finding the tallest trees in the nation yesterday said that an 84.1m tall Taiwania cryptomerioides tree had been named the tallest tree in Taiwan and East Asia. The Taiwan Champion Trees, a team consisting of researchers from the Council of Agriculture’s Taiwan Forestry Research Institute and National Cheng Kung University (NCKU), in June last year used light detection and ranging (LiDAR) imaging to find the giant tree, numbered 55214, upstream of the Daan River (大安溪). A 20-member expedition team led by Rebecca Hsu (徐嘉君), an assistant researcher at the Taiwan Forestry Research Institute, set out to find the
RSS