Lauding the Council of Grand Justices' recent constitutional interpretation on the legislature's refusal to review the Control Yuan member nominees list submitted by the president, academics said yesterday that the ruling has asserted the constitutional powers of the Control Yuan and made clear to lawmakers who boycot the review that they have crossed the line.
The Control Yuan, the nation's top watchdog empowered by the Constitution to investigate irregularities involving government employees under the nation's five-branch governmental framework, has been idle since January 2005, when the terms of its previous members expired.
Although a list of 27 candidates nominated by President Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁) was delivered to the legislature on December 20, 2004, the pan-blue-dominated legislature has prevented the Control Yuan nominees review from being put onto the legislative agenda in the Procedure Committee
The Council of Grand Justices last Wednesday issued Interpretation No. 632, in response to a request filed by pan-green lawmakers in 2005 asking it to rule on the constitutionality of the pan-blues' boycott in screening the nomination list.
The interpretation said that the purpose of organs of the state created by the Constitution is to fulfill their constitutional function and that they cannot be interrupted because of a personnel reshuffle.
If the president does not make nominations or the legislature refuses to exercise its power of approval, the Control Yuan becomes effectively dysfunctional and unable to perform its function, undermining the integration of the nation's constitutional system, which is not permitted by the Constitution, the interpretation said.
Chang Wen-chen (
"It [the interpretation] sets up a clear baseline that the constitutional organs -- the supervisory system, the judicial branch and the independent prosecutorial system -- cannot be used as bargaining chips for political purposes," Chang said.
Chang said the grand justices had made it clear in the interpretation that pan-blue lawmakers had transgressed the principles of checks and balances and that of the separation of power by boycotting the list in the Procedure Committee.
Vested by the Constitution and its additional articles, the Control Yuan has the power to impeach or censure public functionaries working at the central and local levels. It may also propose corrective measures to government organs for improvement.
The Control Yuan can also exercise its auditing powers to supervise the budget expenditures of branches of the government and handle assets disclosures by public functionaries.
It's members can perform circuit supervisions and conduct investigations into cases referred to them from other branches of the government or ones they receive from the public. They can also take the initiative to investigate alleged illegalities within their terms of reference.
Over the past two-and-a-half years the number of cases pending at the Control Yuan has grown to 47,191, 16,323 of which were submitted by the public and the rest referred by other branches of government, officials said.
Some of the cases have been addressed by civil servants in accordance with measures implemented by former Control Yuan president Fredrick Chien (錢復), but a backlog of more than 24,000 cases remains because they can only be investigated by Control Yuan members, it said.
Those cases include sales of pork products from sick and dead hogs, illegal money lending, leaks of confidential data from the military, a prosecutorial cover-up of drug trafficking and a spate of ethical problems involving judicial personnel, among others.
Chen Chi-hua (陳志華), a professor of politics at National Taipei University, called the situation a "constitutional crisis" as neither state organs nor officials have had to take responsibility for their alleged administrative flaws since the previous Control Yuan members had stepped down.
Officials accused of misconduct should be investigated by Control Yuan members and, if found guilty, punished by the "Commission on Disciplinary Sanctions of Public Functionaries," Chen Chi-hua said.
It had been proved in the past that this model is effective in overseeing the performance of government agencies and public officials, he said.
"Now, in the absence of Control Yuan members, who is taking care of the public's complaints?" he said.
Chen In-chin (陳英鈐), an associate professor of law at National Central University, said Interpretation No. 632 "was based on a very fundamental spirit of the Constitution -- the legislature is obliged to exercise its power of consent on the president's nominations."
Responding to the disapproval of some pan-blue lawmakers who argued that Interpretation No. 632 had encroached on "the autonomous operation of the legislature," Chen In-chin said the legislature's autonomy is not something that is immune to the Constitution.
At the end of next month more than half of the grand justices' terms expire, and the president is expected to submit eight nominations to the legislature for these positions.
Chen In-chin said that there have been concerns voiced by a civil watchdog that the list of nominees for grand justices might encounter the same difficulty as the list of Control Yuan nominees.
Article 14 of the Law of Interpretation Procedures For Grand Justices (司法院大法官審理案件法) states that two-thirds of grand justices constitute a quorum and that two-thirds of those present must favor an interpretation before it can be adopted.
Given the law, the council of grand justices will be paralyzed if pan-blue lawmakers play the same trick and boycott a review of the nominees, Chen In-chen said.
"The interpretation will raise public awareness of the seriousness caused by the deadlock over confirming the Control Yuan nominees and thus might prevent a similar constitutional crisis from happening in the case of the grand justices," he said.
UNILATERAL MOVES: Officials have raised concerns that Beijing could try to exert economic control over Kinmen in a key development plan next year The Civil Aviation Administration (CAA) yesterday said that China has so far failed to provide any information about a new airport expected to open next year that is less than 10km from a Taiwanese airport, raising flight safety concerns. Xiamen Xiangan International Airport is only about 3km at its closest point from the islands in Kinmen County — the scene of on-off fighting during the Cold War — and construction work can be seen and heard clearly from the Taiwan side. In a written statement sent to Reuters, the CAA said that airports close to each other need detailed advanced
Tropical Storm Fung-Wong would likely strengthen into a typhoon later today as it continues moving westward across the Pacific before heading in Taiwan’s direction next week, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. As of 8am, Fung-Wong was about 2,190km east-southeast of Cape Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻), Taiwan’s southernmost point, moving westward at 25kph and possibly accelerating to 31kph, CWA data showed. The tropical storm is currently over waters east of the Philippines and still far from Taiwan, CWA forecaster Tseng Chao-cheng (曾昭誠) said, adding that it could likely strengthen into a typhoon later in the day. It is forecast to reach the South China Sea
Almost a quarter of volunteer soldiers who signed up from 2021 to last year have sought early discharge, the Legislative Yuan’s Budget Center said in a report. The report said that 12,884 of 52,674 people who volunteered in the period had sought an early exit from the military, returning NT$895.96 million (US$28.86 million) to the government. In 2021, there was a 105.34 percent rise in the volunteer recruitment rate, but the number has steadily declined since then, missing recruitment targets, the Chinese-language United Daily News said, citing the report. In 2021, only 521 volunteers dropped out of the military, the report said, citing
WEATHER Typhoon forming: CWA A tropical depression is expected to form into a typhoon as early as today, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said yesterday, adding that the storm’s path remains uncertain. Before the weekend, it would move toward the Philippines, the agency said. Some time around Monday next week, it might reach a turning point, either veering north toward waters east of Taiwan or continuing westward across the Philippines, the CWA said. Meanwhile, the eye of Typhoon Kalmaegi was 1,310km south-southeast of Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻), Taiwan’s southernmost point, as of 2am yesterday, it said. The storm is forecast to move through central
RSS