As the government confiscated the printing plates of Scoop Weekly on Wednesday, commentators remained divided about how to strike the proper balance between press freedom and individual privacy.
On Tuesday, the government seized unsold copies of the latest edition of Scoop Weekly after the first batch hit bookstores. The magazine included a sensational free VCD and sold out within hours the day before.
The VCD at the center of the furor purports to show Chu Mei-feng (
The Constitution grants both freedom of "speech, teaching, writing and publication," and "freedom of privacy and correspondence." The current controversy strikes at the core of the often conflicting relationship between the two.
In justifying their conduct, however, the government and prosecutors have cited, on the one hand, laws qualifying the constitutional right to freedom of expression, and, on the other, laws upholding the constitutional right to privacy.
The Government Information Office (GIO) defended its seizure of the magazine Tuesday on the grounds that the Broadcasting and Television Law stipulates that any VCD, DVD or videotape must be viewed by the GIO before it can be released for the purposes of "management and consultation over broadcasting."
The law empowers the government to ban the broadcasting of materials "inimical to the well-being of children and to good conduct."
Taipei prosecutors also say that distribution of the VCD violates Articles 235 and 315 of the Criminal Code, which respectively outlaw the distribution of "indecent" materials and the infringement of personal privacy.
The distribution of indecent materials is punishable by a two-year prison term and authorities are entitled to confiscate the materials.
The taping of private dialogue and conduct without the consent of the individual concerned amounts to commissioning an Article 315 offense. Circulating such material is punishable by a five-year prison term or a NT$50,000 fine.
Lin Feng-jeng (林峰正), lawyer and head of the Taiwan Association for Human Rights, said that based on his experience with cases involving pornographic VCDs or tapes, Scoop Weekly would lose any case in which it was accused of distributing indecent materials.
He added, "Whether the government can use its executive power to interfere with the freedom of the press is questionable."
One commentator said the government did not have grounds to seize copies of the magazine.
"The government doesn't have the power to ban the VCD under the Broadcasting and Television Law, since that law applies only to VCDs, DVDs, and CDs that are publicly broadcast," said Shih Shih-hao (
"I don't think the GIO should get involved, especially since police and prosecutors are looking into the matter," he said.
Scoop Weekly's publisher and owner have asserted that the public's right to know justifies the release of the VCD. Chu is a public figure and the man with whom she is alleged to have had sex is married. Adultery is a criminal offense in Taiwan, punishable by up to one year in prison for both the adulterer and his or her unmarried partner.
AIR DEFENSE: The Norwegian missile system has proved highly effective in Ukraine in its war against Russia, and the US has recommended it for Taiwan, an expert said The Norwegian Advanced Surface-to-Air Missile Systems (NASAMS) Taiwan ordered from the US would be installed in strategically important positions in Taipei and New Taipei City to guard the region, the Ministry of National Defense said in statement yesterday. The air defense system would be deployed in Taipei’s Songshan District (松山) and New Taipei City’s Tamsui District (淡水), the ministry said, adding that the systems could be delivered as soon as the end of this year. The US Defense Security Cooperation Agency has previously said that three NASAMS would be sold to Taiwan. The weapons are part of the 17th US arms sale to
SERIOUS ALLEGATIONS: The suspects formed spy networks and paramilitary groups to kill government officials during a possible Chinese invasion, prosecutors said Prosecutors have indicted seven retired military officers, members of the Rehabilitation Alliance Party, for allegedly obtaining funds from China, and forming paramilitary groups and assassination squads in Taiwan to collaborate with Chinese troops in a possible war. The suspects contravened the National Security Act (國家安全法) by taking photos and drawing maps of key radar stations, missile installations and the American Institute in Taiwan’s headquarters in Taipei, prosecutors said. They allegedly prepared to collaborate with China during a possible invasion of Taiwan, prosecutors said. Retired military officer Chu Hung-i (屈宏義), 62, a Republic of China Army Academy graduate, went to China
REGIONAL PEACE: The US is supporting Taiwan’s self-defense capabilities by providing the nation with defensive arms and services, as it aims to maintain cross-strait stability The US on Friday reiterated its support for Taiwan’s self-defense capabilities in a statement affirming its commitment to the Indo-Pacific region. The White House said that Washington has supported Taiwan’s self-defense capabilities through a range of security assistance authorities and resources, including the first-ever use of Foreign Military Financing (FMF) and Presidential Drawdown Authority (PDA) for Taiwan, as well as International Military Education and Training (IMET). US President Joe Biden had identified the Indo-Pacific as the critical region for the future of the US and the world, it said. “In pursuit of regional peace, security and stability, we have reinvested in our defense
CONFLICT RISK: China’s hostile actions toward Taiwan could ‘precipitate a severe cross-strait crisis involving the United States,’ the report said There is a “moderate” likelihood of a cross-strait war this year that could have a “high” impact on US interests, a survey by the New York-based Council on Foreign Relations said on Tuesday. “Intensified military and economic pressure by China toward Taiwan” is listed among other “top conflicts to watch in 2025” as a “Tier I (High Priority)” potential war, the think tank’s Center for Preventative Action (CPA) said in a report. China’s hostile actions toward Taiwan could “precipitate a severe cross-strait crisis involving the United States and other countries in the region,” the report said, adding that such a scenario could
RSS