A group of 30 foreign academics yesterday released a statement condemning legislative reforms proposed by opposition lawmakers, saying they are unconstitutional and undermine the objective of good governance.
The statement publicized at a news conference in Taipei is cosigned by international academics, journalists and politicians, including former American Institute in Taiwan directors William Stanton and Stephen Young, and Formosan Association for Public Relations president Bob Yang (楊英育).
The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) have put forward a set of legislative reforms that would introduce “contempt of legislature” charges, require the president to answer lawmakers’ questions and expand the legislature’s investigative powers.
Photo: Hsieh Chun-lin, Taipei Times
The “contempt of legislature” proposals have been especially controversial, as they would allow government officials to be jailed for making remarks deemed to be untrue by lawmakers or for asking questions.
Brawls erupted in the legislature on Friday last week as the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) protested the opposition’s attempt to pass the bills.
“I was appalled by and disappointed with the altercations that took place recently in the chambers of Taiwan’s Legislative Yuan,” Yang told the news conference, calling the proposals “extreme.”
“The violence the world witnessed certainly will make it more difficult for us to advocate for Taiwan in the US,” he said, appealing to the KMT and TPP to exercise restraint and engage in substantive debate.
In the statement, the academics expressed “strong concern and disappointment” about the proposed reforms.
“Whilst reforms are a natural process arising from the parliamentary process, including in Taiwan, the set proposed by the two parties exceed the bounds of those found in constitutional democracies around the world, subvert the rule of law and parliamentary procedures, and should be taken in the context of the KMT’s stated objective of undermining good governance,” they said.
They fail to take into consideration Taiwan’s constitutional framework and go beyond the scope of legislative powers exercised in other countries, the signatories said.
“We note that in most constitutional democracies, while contempt of parliament or congress charges exist, they have generally applied to the defiance of lawfully ordered subpoenas or lying in the course of judicial investigations,” the statement said. “No democracy has applied contempt charges to officials discharging duties during the course of regular hearings or for merely ‘talking back.’”
They expressed concern about the implications of such a rule in a politically polarized climate, noting a comment from KMT Legislator Weng Hsiao-ling (翁曉玲), who said that the legislature and executive have a “top-to-bottom relationship.”
“All of this suggests that the goal of the reform is not to support good governance, but to broaden the authority of the legislative branch in a way that usurps and penalizes the executive. This clearly violates the separation of powers inherent in the Constitution,” the statement said.
In addition, the Constitution only allows for the president to deliver a “state of the nation” address rather than answer questions from lawmakers, it said.
Expansion of the legislature’s investigative powers would also conflict with the role of the Control Yuan, raising “serious questions” about potential overreach, the signatories said.
“All of this is to say that the reform proposals that have been put forward are potentially unconstitutional and a usurpation of political power held by other coequal branches of government,” they said. “They tarnish Taiwan’s image for good governance and further create political rifts at a time it can ill afford to do so, given growing challenges and complexities from Beijing.”
They also expressed concern that the opposition has not posted the bills for public review, blocked the DPP from debate and were to vote by a show of hands rather than a recorded vote for the first time in 35 years.
“With a new administration being sworn in on May 20 and hundreds of international dignitaries flying in for the occasion, they should be witness to Taiwan’s robust democracy, not the depth of its divisions,” the signatories said. “More importantly, the citizens of Taiwan deserve a government that is responsible, accountable and transparent, all of which this reform bill undermines.”
PATROL PARTNERS: The ‘Chiayi’ and the ‘Penghu’ departed for a two-day joint patrol of Palau’s exclusive economic zone, the CGA’s second diplomatic visit to the country The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) set a record for its southernmost deployment of a coast guard vessel as the vessels Chiayi and the Penghu reached Palau’s Pulo Anna Island on Saturday in a cooperative exercise between the two countries. The island, about 217 nautical miles (401km) southwest of Koror in the Palauan state of Sonsorol and 1,220 nautical miles from Taiwan’s southernmost point, Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻), is the furthest south a CGA vessel has sailed. The two vessels are in Palau for the coast guard’s second diplomatic visit to the country. They docked at Malakal Harbor on Tuesday last week. The coast guard
BATCH 1: The military has plans to assign the weapons to the army to defend Taiwan proper, as well as outlying islands and the navy for the Marine Corps, the official said Taiwan is to receive 500 Stinger missiles and 178 launchers from the US by the end of the year, the first batch under a planned two-stage acquisition totaling 2,621 missiles and 763 launchers, a defense official said yesterday on condition of anonymity. The portable missiles would play a vital role in the nation’s air defense capabilities, the source said. The army plans to deploy 2,235 missiles and 657 launchers to defend Taiwan proper and outlying islands, they said, citing military documents. The navy is allotted 295 missiles and 85 launchers to arm the Marine Corps and some surface vessels that lack air defense
The European Parliament on Wednesday adopted a recommendation on EU-China political relations that rejected China’s efforts to restrict Taiwan’s participation in international organizations and exchanges. The recommendation, addressed to the European Council, the European Commission and EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Kaja Kallas, includes several references to EU-Taiwan relations and expresses support for closer ties, saying they would bring positive benefits and have strategic importance. Describing Taiwan as a valuable partner in trade and technology, the European Parliament said it “rejects China’s attempts to coerce international organizations, third countries and other actors into restricting Taiwan’s international participation and
Former president Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) on Monday arrived in San Francisco, receiving a warm welcome from hundreds of overseas Taiwanese as she launched a week-long visit. Accompanied by Representative to the US Alexander Yui (俞大?), and head of Taiwan’s San Francisco office Wu Chih-hsiang (伍志翔), Tsai arrived at her hotel, waving, smiling and giving high-fives to Taiwanese compatriots amid cheers of “Taiwan’s democracy involves you and me” to welcome her to the San Francisco Bay Area. It is Tsai’s first visit to the US since she left office in May 2024 after serving two four-year terms as president. Tsai is today to deliver
RSS