The saga of a US aircraft carrier being denied entry to Hong Kong at Thanksgiving took a bizarre turn yesterday when China denied saying the whole affair had been a misunderstanding.
The White House said Chinese Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi (楊潔箎) had told US President George W. Bush as much on Wednesday.
The US Department of Defense said it had issued a formal complaint to China and that Beijing still had not provided sufficient explanation for blocking the USS Kitty Hawk, and eight ships traveling with it, entry to Hong Kong for a long-planned Thanksgiving visit.
China later changed its mind, but by then the carrier group was steaming back to Japan.
"Reports that Foreign Minister Yang said in the United States that it was a misunderstanding do not accord with the facts," Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Liu Jianchao (劉建超) told a news conference in Beijing. "China approved the visit of the Kitty Hawk group to Hong Kong based on humanitarian reasons. The decision made by the US later was up to them."
He did not elaborate. Liu also denied receiving a complaint from the US.
"The Chinese side has not received any protest from the US side. I don't think there should be a protest on this issue," he said, suggesting reporters ask the US why its officials decided not to send the ship to Hong Kong after China approved the visit.
There has been speculation China's move to block the ships was related to irritation over US plans to help Taiwan upgrade its missile system and a meeting between Bush and exiled Tibetan spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama.
Liu said he thought generally that Sino-US ties were developing well but expressed dissatisfaction with some recent US actions.
"We think that generally communication, talks and exchanges are progressing smoothly. Both sides have smooth communication on bilateral and international issues," he said.
"But it should be pointed out that recently, bilateral relations have been interfered with and damaged by mistaken actions by the US. For examples, US leaders have met the Dalai Lama," Liu said.
"Also on the Taiwan question, China approves of the US opposing Taiwan's UN entry referendum," he added. "At the same time, we have grave concern with US arms sales to Taiwan."
Liu's comments came after US Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense David Sedney met for 30 minutes with Chinese Major General Zhao Ning (趙寧) at the Pentagon on Wednesday, conveying "deep regret and concern" over the Chinese actions, Morrell said.
He said Sedney told the general they "run counter to our joint interest in positively developing our military-to-military relations."
"The general said nothing substantive in response, but promised to relay the message back to Beijing," the Pentagon spokesman said in a written statement.
Analysts said the Pentagon's reaction to the Chinese rebuff has been unusually pointed.
"I have never seen the Pentagon get so angry at the Chinese in my 30 years of dealing with the China issue," said John Tkacik, a former State Department official now at the Heritage Foundation think tank.
The first sign of trouble came on Nov. 20 when China refused to allow two US minesweepers -- the USS Patriot and the USS Guardian -- to enter Hong Kong for refuge from a storm and to refuel. They refueled at sea and made it back to their home port in Sasebo, Japan, without incident. Then came the denial for the Kitty Hawk, a port call that had been scheduled at least a month in advance.
Hundreds of family members had flown to Hong Kong to spend time with relatives from the ship for the Thanksgiving holiday.
Morrell said an explanation was "due to the families of those sailors who at great personal costs had made arrangements to visit their loved ones in Hong Kong expecting the Kitty Hawk to port there as planned."
The chief of the US Navy and the head of the US Pacific Command on Tuesday said they were especially bothered that the two minesweepers were denied a safe harbor.
"It is not, in our view, conduct that is indicative of a country who understands its obligations as a responsible nation," Admiral Tim Keating, the Pacific commander, told reporters during a video conference.
The spat occurred just weeks after a visit to China by US Secretary of Defense Robert Gates that was described by US officials as positive.
China-US relations have improved since 2001, when their militaries broke contact following a collision between a Chinese fighter jet and US spy plane. But many differences remain over issues such as China's military build-up and US weapon sales to Taiwan.
On Wednesday, the Pentagon had tried to play down speculation that China's refusal to allow the Kitty Hawk to visit Hong Kong was in retaliation for Washington's decision to sell nearly US$1 billion in Patriot 2 anti-missile upgrades to Taiwan.
Defense Department spokesman Geoff Morrell, during a regular daily briefing, was asked about the possible Taiwanese arms sales connection.
Specifically, he was asked whether the Chinese were upset that Gates had failed to give China an advanced warning of the sale when he was in Beijing
The Pentagon announced the sale on Nov. 9, just five days after Gates arrived in China for talks aimed at improving bilateral military relations.
"I'm not aware of the reason for their decision not to allow us to dock in Hong Kong," Morrell said in answer to a question about the possible link with the arms sales.
"It has not been articulated to us," Morrell said.
Since the Patriot upgrade sales had been in the works for months, Morrell added: "I don't know that there was any news to share on that count. But I don't recall that coming up at any of our meetings with the Chinese during Gates' trip."
Meanwhile, a newspaper owned by the Chinese Communist Party blamed Washington for causing the spat.
The Global Times, a tabloid published by the People's Daily, cited an unidentified People's Liberation Army senior colonel as blaming Washington's decision to sell Taiwan an anti-missile defense system.
That "obviously sent the wrong signals" to Taiwan's president, Chen Shui-bian (
"At a time when the US side is seriously harming China's interests, there is no logic under heaven by which China should then be expected to open its heart and embrace him," the paper said.
Additional reporting by Charles Snyder
BACK IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD: The planned transit by the ‘Baden-Wuerttemberg’ and the ‘Frankfurt am Main’ would be the German Navy’s first passage since 2002 Two German warships are set to pass through the Taiwan Strait in the middle of this month, becoming the first German naval vessels to do so in 22 years, Der Spiegel reported on Saturday. Reuters last month reported that the warships, the frigate Baden-Wuerttemberg and the replenishment ship Frankfurt am Main, were awaiting orders from Berlin to sail the Strait, prompting a rebuke to Germany from Beijing. Der Spiegel cited unspecified sources as saying Beijing would not be formally notified of the German ships’ passage to emphasize that Berlin views the trip as normal. The German Federal Ministry of Defense declined to comment. While
‘REGRETTABLE’: TPP lawmaker Vivian Huang said that ‘we will continue to support Chairman Ko and defend his innocence’ as he was transferred to a detention facility The Taipei District Court yesterday ruled that Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) Chairman Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) be detained and held incommunicado over alleged corruption dating to his time as mayor of Taipei. The ruling reversed a decision by the court on Monday morning that Ko be released without bail. After prosecutors on Wednesday appealed the Monday decision, the High Court said that Ko had potentially been “actively involved” in the alleged corruption and ordered the district court to hold a second detention hearing. Ko did not speak to reporters upon his arrival at the district court at about 9:10am yesterday to attend a procedural
‘UPHOLDING PEACE’: Taiwan’s foreign minister thanked the US Congress for using a ‘creative and effective way’ to deter Chinese military aggression toward the nation The US House of Representatives on Monday passed the Taiwan Conflict Deterrence Act, aimed at deterring Chinese aggression toward Taiwan by threatening to publish information about Chinese Communist Party (CCP) officials’ “illicit” financial assets if Beijing were to attack. The act would also “restrict financial services for certain immediate family of such officials,” the text of the legislation says. The bill was introduced in January last year by US representatives French Hill and Brad Sherman. After remarks from several members, it passed unanimously. “If China chooses to attack the free people of Taiwan, [the bill] requires the Treasury secretary to publish the illicit
The Executive Yuan yesterday warned against traveling to or doing business in China after reports that Beijing is recruiting Taiwanese to help conceal the use of forced Uighur labor. The government is aware that Taiwan-based influencers and businesses are being asked to make pro-Beijing content and offered incentives to invest in the region, Executive Yuan acting spokeswoman Julia Hsieh (謝子涵) told a news conference. Taiwanese are urged to be aware of the potential personal and reputational harm by visiting or operating businesses in China, Hsieh said, adding that agencies are fully apprised of the situation. A national security official said that former Mainland
RSS