The Taipei district court found two gay men not guilty on charges of indecency yesterday, calling it a case of justice delayed.
"When things such as this happen, the only thing that the court can do is render a not-guilty verdict. This is a decision of law, but it can do little to correct the wrongs that have been done to the defendants," said Wu Chiu-hung (
A-hau (
PHOTO: CHEN CHENG-CHANG, TAIPEI TIMES
A-cheng (阿誠), 34, a body-building trainer working at the health club, was also arrested by police on the same night when he tried to stop the arrest. The police charged him with providing sex services to gay customers at the club.
A third man was also taken into custody at the time but returned to Hong Kong were he lives and did not return to answer the charges.
Gay rights groups have claimed the three defendants were discriminated against during the process of arrest and police interrogation. The defendants also claim they were forced by police at the time of detention to strip so that photos could be taken and used as evidence against them.
According to court records, the police denied all accusations of discrimination and changed their testimony regarding the photos during the trial.
"At first a policeman admitted the photos were taken but that they did not force the men to do anything. But after further questioning, the officer contradicted his earlier statement about the photos," Wu said.
Media publicity surrounding the arrest of the men has cost A-cheng his job at the club and forced A-hau to change his name and residence.
The defendants do not plan to take any legal action against the police involved.
"It's better for ordinary citizens not to fight with [police] officials because chances are they will lose at the end of the day," said Kenneth H.C. Chiu (
Two pieces of major evidence used in the case by police and the prosecution were over 300 new and used condoms and the confession of A-hau during his interrogation. However, Wu said the fact that there were numerous weak points in the nature of the confession, made him question whether the admission was indeed obtained of the defendant's own free will.
He also challenged the charge of public indecency, saying it goes against common sense to think that consenting homosexuals would display acts of intimacy in public.
"Our society still regards homosexuals as strange. Few would admit they are homosexuals under such social pressure, let alone display their acts of intimacy to others," Wu said.
In acquitting the defendants, Wu expressed sympathy for the men, specially for A-cheng, saying he was only arrested because of "bad luck."
"He did nothing wrong, but only tried to stop the police from arresting his customers. His charge, as far as I'm concerned, was groundless," Wu said.
The prosecution has 10 days after receiving the written judgment to file an appeal.
Taiwanese actress Barbie Hsu (徐熙媛) has died of pneumonia at the age of 48 while on a trip to Japan, where she contracted influenza during the Lunar New Year holiday, her sister confirmed today through an agent. "Our whole family came to Japan for a trip, and my dearest and most kindhearted sister Barbie Hsu died of influenza-induced pneumonia and unfortunately left us," Hsu's sister and talk show hostess Dee Hsu (徐熙娣) said. "I was grateful to be her sister in this life and that we got to care for and spend time with each other. I will always be grateful to
REMINDER: Of the 6.78 million doses of flu vaccine Taiwan purchased for this flu season, about 200,000 are still available, an official said, following Big S’ death As news broke of the death of Taiwanese actress and singer Barbie Hsu (徐熙媛), also known as Big S (大S), from severe flu complications, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) and doctors yesterday urged people at high risk to get vaccinated and be alert to signs of severe illness. Hsu’s family yesterday confirmed that the actress died on a family holiday in Japan due to pneumonia during the Lunar New Year holiday. CDC Deputy Director-General Tseng Shu-hui (曾淑慧) told an impromptu news conference that hospital visits for flu-like illnesses from Jan. 19 to Jan. 25 reached 162,352 — the highest
TAIWAN DEFENSE: The initiative would involve integrating various systems in a fast-paced manner through the use of common software to obstruct a Chinese invasion The first tranche of the US Navy’s “Replicator” initiative aimed at obstructing a Chinese invasion of Taiwan would be ready by August, a US Naval Institute (USNI) News report on Tuesday said. The initiative is part of a larger defense strategy for Taiwan, and would involve launching thousands of uncrewed submarines, surface vessels and aerial vehicles around Taiwan to buy the nation and its partners time to assemble a response. The plan was first made public by the Washington Post in June last year, when it cited comments by US Indo-Pacific Commander Admiral Samuel Paparo on the sidelines of the Shangri-La Dialogue
COMBINING FORCES: The 66th Marine Brigade would support the 202nd Military Police Command in its defense of Taipei against ‘decapitation strikes,’ a source said The Marine Corps has deployed more than 100 soldiers and officers of the 66th Marine Brigade to Taipei International Airport (Songshan airport) as part of an effort to bolster defenses around the capital, a source with knowledge of the matter said yesterday. Two weeks ago, a military source said that the Ministry of National Defense ordered the Marine Corps to increase soldier deployments in the Taipei area. The 66th Marine Brigade has been tasked with protecting key areas in Taipei, with the 202nd Military Police Command also continuing to defend the capital. That came after a 2017 decision by the ministry to station