When vegans and vegetarians say that people who are concerned about climate change and the future of the planet should reduce meat consumption and move toward a plant-based diet, they’re absolutely right. But where does fish fit into the picture?
Fishing boats burn fossil fuels and litter the sea with broken nets and other debris. Unlike land-based meat production, however, the fishing industry doesn’t rely on massive inputs of feed, water and veterinary drugs.
The carbon footprint of a kilogram of herrings, sardines, or anchovies — after processing but before shipping to a point of sale — is just 1.87kg CO2e, according to CarbonCloud. That carbon accounting platform calculates that a similar quantity of British beef adds 32.2kg CO2e to the atmosphere.
Photo: Steven Crook
Taking more fish from the sea so we can scale back livestock operations isn’t a practical option, however. Decades of overfishing means that there aren’t as many fish in the sea as there used to be. And the state of wild fish stocks may be even more parlous than specialists thought a few years ago.
Summarizing a research paper he coauthored for Science (Aug. 23, 2024), Tasmania-based academic Graham Edgar, wrote for The Conversation Web site that “populations of many overfished species are in far worse condition than has been reported, and the sustainability of fisheries was overstated.”
OVERFISHING
Photo: Steven Crook
Edgar and his coauthors examined data from 230 major fisheries that comprise a total of 128 piscine species. The scientists paid particular attention to the biomass (total body weight) of fish stocks, as when the biomass of a particular stock goes below 10 percent of its pre-exploitation size, it’s considered to have collapsed.
In two thirds of those fisheries, they concluded, the extent of depletion has been significantly underestimated. Efforts to sustainably manage fish stocks have been undermined by inaccurate and overoptimistic data.
It’s possible for fish stocks to come back from collapse, but it requires effective enforcement, stakeholder collaboration and a great deal of time. In the early 1990s, the Northern cod, a mainstay of Eastern Canada’s fishing industry, collapsed to just 1 percent of historic levels. Years of moratoriums, research and disputes followed, but last year the Canadian authorities felt sufficiently confident to increase the annual quota to 18,000 tonnes — double that of 2018, but less than a fortieth of the peak catch in 1968.
Photo: Steven Crook
A 2023-2024 survey by Greenpeace suggests that those parts of the ocean that supply Taiwan’s seafood markets are being overfished. Greenpeace volunteers measured 8,038 fish at six markets around the country, comparing the length of each one with the 50-percent reference value for sexual maturity (Lm50, the size at which half of that species’ population is considered sexually mature).
Catching wild creatures before they’re able to reproduce is obviously bad for the population’s long-term viability. For 24 of the 40 species covered by Greenpeace’s survey, over half of the fish hadn’t reached Lm50. And for seven of those species, including the often-eaten white/silver pomfret (Pampus argenteus, 白鯧/銀鯧), more than 90 percent fell short.
Some Taiwanese may be complacent when it comes to the issue of overfishing, reasoning that the country’s sizable aquaculture industry will provide fish even if the oceans don’t. But eating fish raised in ponds doesn’t necessarily mean fewer fish are taken from the ocean, says Liao Yun-chih (廖運志), an associate professor at the University of Taipei’s Department of Earth and Life Sciences.
While aquaculture has the potential to relieve pressure on wild stocks, “it still relies heavily on wild-caught forage fish such as anchovies, sardines and mackerel to feed carnivorous species like salmon and groupers,” he says.
In that sense, he adds, “aquaculture is not entirely sustainable because it doesn’t fully eliminate fishing pressure on wild populations.”
FOOD FOR FISH
By weight, at least 20 percent of the wild fish caught each year aren’t eaten by humans but instead converted into fish meal and fish oil which is then used to nourish farmed fish, poultry and pigs. One irony is that around 90 percent of the fish rendered into feed — among them the forage species mentioned by Liao — are fit for direct human consumption.
Scientists have developed alternative feeds based on microalgae, and companies like Amsterdam-based Corbion promote them, claiming the omega-3 they contain results in healthier fish. Because their microalgae are grown in closed fermentation tanks, they “do not contain the persistent organic pollutants that naturally accumulate in fish oil,” and the process has “low carbon, water and land use impact,” according to Corbion’s Web site.
Making aquaculture more sustainable requires action on several fronts, says Liao. In addition to exploring alternative sources of protein, the industry should favor herbivorous species over carnivorous species. Other goals should be “improving waste and nutrient management to avoid coastal pollution, promoting native or non-invasive cultured species, and ensuring traceability and transparency in the production chain,” he says.
In Liao’s opinion, certification systems like those offered by the Europe-based Aquaculture Stewardship Council can help, but “locally adapted guidelines and incentives are also needed.”
While acknowledging that overfishing of the oceans is an ongoing global problem, Liao sees some positive developments, saying: “Certain fisheries with effective management practices and ecolabel certifications, such as the Marine Stewardship Council, offer promising models.”
Citing the government’s support for the Ocean Heart ecolabel (海洋之心生態標章), he says, “ I believe we are moving toward a more sustainable ocean, step by step.”
In his previous positions at Academia Sinica and the National Museum of Marine Science and Technology, Liao was the primary contributor to the Seafood Guide Taiwan (fishdb.sinica.edu.tw/seafoodguide/), which also involved the Taiwan Ocean Conservation and Fisheries Sustainability Foundation (臺灣海洋保育與漁業永續基金會, TOFF).
The guide urges consumers to “buy the right fish, eat the right fish [and] do your part for marine conservation!”
Liao has also participated in a seafood sustainability assessment for Kenting National Park, evaluating criteria such as: population trends and current stock status; biological characteristics; fishing equipment and methods; environmental impacts; and management measures for wild-caught species.
“For aquaculture species, we examined larvae sources, feed, environmental impacts, and farm management,” he says.
Drawing on their research, Liao and his colleagues issued science-based advice, detailing which species consumers can enjoy with a clear conscience and which they should steer clear of.
MISSED OPPORTUNITIES
However, there have been missed opportunities when it comes to amplifying the impact of these efforts, Liao says. Academia Sinica’s guide attracted some media coverage, and it was integrated into a number of educational events, but Liao thinks that “broader and more sustained public outreach — especially through digital platforms, schools and community events — could have extended its reach significantly.”
The assessment conducted for Kenting National Park “was rigorous, and they printed posters and brochures to promote sustainable seafood at events and restaurants around Kenting, but the results weren’t widely communicated to the general public.”
This is somewhat galling, as Liao describes low public awareness as “one of the biggest challenges.” When consumers choose seafood, he adds, “most are unaware of the species’ stock status, fishing methods or the environmental impacts of their choices. They’re mainly concerned about the price.”
Noting that the Seafood Guide Taiwan emphasizes environmental education and promotes responsible consumption, Liao says: “I’d like to see sustainability content integrated more fully into formal education. Building environmental awareness from a young age is key to long-term change.”
Part Two of this article will look at what Taiwanese consumers can do to help save the oceans’ wild fisheries.
Steven Crook, the author or co-author of four books about Taiwan, has been following environmental issues since he arrived in the country in 1991. He drives a hybrid and carries his own chopsticks. The views expressed here are his own.
Google unveiled an artificial intelligence tool Wednesday that its scientists said would help unravel the mysteries of the human genome — and could one day lead to new treatments for diseases. The deep learning model AlphaGenome was hailed by outside researchers as a “breakthrough” that would let scientists study and even simulate the roots of difficult-to-treat genetic diseases. While the first complete map of the human genome in 2003 “gave us the book of life, reading it remained a challenge,” Pushmeet Kohli, vice president of research at Google DeepMind, told journalists. “We have the text,” he said, which is a sequence of
On a harsh winter afternoon last month, 2,000 protesters marched and chanted slogans such as “CCP out” and “Korea for Koreans” in Seoul’s popular Gangnam District. Participants — mostly students — wore caps printed with the Chinese characters for “exterminate communism” (滅共) and held banners reading “Heaven will destroy the Chinese Communist Party” (天滅中共). During the march, Park Jun-young, the leader of the protest organizer “Free University,” a conservative youth movement, who was on a hunger strike, collapsed after delivering a speech in sub-zero temperatures and was later hospitalized. Several protesters shaved their heads at the end of the demonstration. A
Every now and then, even hardcore hikers like to sleep in, leave the heavy gear at home and just enjoy a relaxed half-day stroll in the mountains: no cold, no steep uphills, no pressure to walk a certain distance in a day. In the winter, the mild climate and lower elevations of the forests in Taiwan’s far south offer a number of easy escapes like this. A prime example is the river above Mudan Reservoir (牡丹水庫): with shallow water, gentle current, abundant wildlife and a complete lack of tourists, this walk is accessible to nearly everyone but still feels quite remote.
In August of 1949 American journalist Darrell Berrigan toured occupied Formosa and on Aug. 13 published “Should We Grab Formosa?” in the Saturday Evening Post. Berrigan, cataloguing the numerous horrors of corruption and looting the occupying Republic of China (ROC) was inflicting on the locals, advocated outright annexation of Taiwan by the US. He contended the islanders would welcome that. Berrigan also observed that the islanders were planning another revolt, and wrote of their “island nationalism.” The US position on Taiwan was well known there, and islanders, he said, had told him of US official statements that Taiwan had not
RSS