When photos of what was quickly dubbed “a turbine blade graveyard” in the US state of Wyoming appeared in BBC and Bloomberg news reports in early 2020, the reaction of some wind-energy skeptics verged on the gleeful.
They argued that — in addition to onshore wind turbines being noisy eyesores, and offshore turbines threatening marine ecosystems and migrating birds — the wind-energy industry was creating a mountain of waste.
The images from Wyoming appeared to be evidence that, when turbine blades reach the end of their lives, after 20 or 25 years’ of use, the only course of action is to cut them up and bury them.
Photo: Steven Crook
‘UNRESOLVED PROBLEM’
Because they need to be strong yet light, turbine blades are made of composites that incorporate fiber-reinforced polymers and filling materials like balsa wood or PVC foam. The Web site of Germany’s Fraunhofer Research Institution for Materials Recycling and Resource Strategies sums up one consequence: “The recycling of these composite materials, and in particular the separation of the components without forfeiting the desirable properties, is still an unresolved problem.”
Even though most of its windfarms are just a few years old, Taiwan is already having to dispose of worn-out or failed blades. On Mar. 15 last year, ETtoday reported that, so far, crushing and then burying has been the main method of disposal.
Photo courtesy of Taiwan Marine Heavy Industry
Over the coming decade, ETtoday pointed out, Taiwan alone will have to do something with approximately 900 decommissioned blades, and renewable energy entrepreneur Manuel Zehr doubts the country will find a good solution that satisfies the government’s local-content requirements.
While several European nations, within and outside the EU, have established a legal basis for decommissioning early-generation turbines, the blades remain a challenge due to their different material layers, which only can be separated manually, Zehr says.
“Taiwan already has a labor shortage, and limited space in which 60m to 100m-long turbine towers and blades can be dismantled,” says Zehr, the general manager of Formosan Business Support Co Ltd.
Photo: Steven Crook
According to Zehr, decommissioning and the circular economy has become a profitable business in Europe, which is working in cooperation with energy partners in Africa. In Taiwan, he laments, “policy simply doesn’t share this vision. The three leading parties have absorbed candidates, issues and votes from environmentalist parties, without legislating their agendas.”
Zehr urges the authorities to change their emphasis on local content to an approach based on regional shared goals.
“Turbines from the 1990s are full of profitable, in-demand materials, but Taiwan has to find partners willing to share their labor and their space. We shouldn’t be physically limited to the island of Taiwan,” he says.
Photo courtesy of Tien Li Offshore Wind Technology & Vestas
In April last year, Vestas — a Danish multinational that describes itself as “the energy industry’s global partner on sustainable energy solutions” — announced that its local partner, Tien Li Offshore Wind Technology, had completed its first 85m-long turbine blade. The former company’s press release touted this a localization triumph. There was no mention of either recycling or disposal.
On Jul. 8 last year, Swancor, a Taiwanese maker of specialist chemicals, revealed that it’s working with Spain-based Siemens Gamesa Renewable Energy to create turbine blades which, after decommissioning, can be broken down into reusable resins and glass fibers.
Swancor’s Web site says that “the recycling process does not produce waste solvents and waste gas, and has a low carbon footprint,” but doesn’t predict when this technology might ripen. And, of course, the world will still be left with the problem of already-installed blades.
Experience outside Taiwan shows that, if retired blades are mechanically shredded, the resulting granules can be used as a combustible or sand substitute by cement companies, or incinerated in a waste-to-energy (WtE) plant. (Air pollution from state-of-the-art WtE plants has “minimal public health impacts,” according to the UN Environment Program.)
NORTHERN EUROPE LEADS THE WAY
In Northern Europe, small-scale projects are exploring the possibility of turning old blades into skis, snowboards, bicycle sheds and fencing material — and it’s to Northern Europe that Taiwan should look when searching for progressive practices, says Kim Asher, a Taichung-based wind-energy veteran.
“In most situations, if you want the gold standards for environmental regulations policies and activities, look to the Baltic, Northern Europe, and Scandinavia. The Baltic benefits from some of the most environmentally conscious stewardship on the planet,” says the Briton, who’s been in the industry for more than 15 years.
Some of the practices implemented in that part of the world, such as legislating for much cleaner fuel on the ships that build and maintain offshore wind farms, “ultimately also have great economic benefits, and Taiwan can learn a lot from looking in that direction,” she says.
“Taiwan is not excelling in environmental terms… yet,” Asher says. “However, I strongly believe it has all of the ingredients to excel.”
Asher says that she is currently working on a concept that could tie all the loose ends together and help Taiwan become a world leader in green energy.
“Over the last few years I’ve been here, I’ve seen things improving. Some of the weaker players with less suitable management styles have moved out of the sector, and those remaining are starting to get some good traction,” she says.
It’s often pointed out that, while wind turbines don’t produce carbon dioxide when they’re operating, the manufacture and installation of turbines has a significant carbon footprint. Such emissions are always a concern for the wind-energy industry, Asher says, because a larger footprint means higher energy costs.
“The process of making production less energy-intensive aligns with environmental concerns, especially as more green energy becomes available to fuel the expansion of green energy production. It becomes a virtuous circle. The impact of the expansion of green energy production should be understood to be a paradigm shift that works over decades, not overnight,” she says.
Asked how offshore wind farms affect marine life and birds, Asher replies: “I don’t specialize in environmental impact assessments, but as someone with thousands of days working on ships in offshore construction, and being a specialist in subsea operations, I can tell you that almost every subsea structure I’ve seen, from the Norwegian Sea to the South China Sea, becomes an artificial reef that expands habitats for marine life.”
The wind industry, she says, “goes to great lengths to assess, monitor and adapt in response to environmental impacts.”
Without offshore construction, there’d be much less funding for ocean ecology research, she says.
“It’s a certainty that we cannot continue to throw billions of tonnes of fossil fuels through the fires of industry,” says Asher. “Climate change is already biting, and we need to understand that change is inevitable. As a species, we need enormous amounts of energy to sustain our standards of living, and we need to adapt the mix of technologies that can deliver this. Wind is definitely a part of that.”
She challenges those who say otherwise to consider how much energy they use, and to come up with strategies to mitigate their own impacts.
“If they can do better, I’m sure industry will listen, as we’re living through a time where energy is all about innovation,” she says.
Steven Crook, the author or co-author of four books about Taiwan, has been following environmental issues since he arrived in the country in 1991. He drives a hybrid and carries his own chopsticks. The views expressed here are his own.
In late October of 1873 the government of Japan decided against sending a military expedition to Korea to force that nation to open trade relations. Across the government supporters of the expedition resigned immediately. The spectacle of revolt by disaffected samurai began to loom over Japanese politics. In January of 1874 disaffected samurai attacked a senior minister in Tokyo. A month later, a group of pro-Korea expedition and anti-foreign elements from Saga prefecture in Kyushu revolted, driven in part by high food prices stemming from poor harvests. Their leader, according to Edward Drea’s classic Japan’s Imperial Army, was a samurai
Located down a sideroad in old Wanhua District (萬華區), Waley Art (水谷藝術) has an established reputation for curating some of the more provocative indie art exhibitions in Taipei. And this month is no exception. Beyond the innocuous facade of a shophouse, the full three stories of the gallery space (including the basement) have been taken over by photographs, installation videos and abstract images courtesy of two creatives who hail from the opposite ends of the earth, Taiwan’s Hsu Yi-ting (許懿婷) and Germany’s Benjamin Janzen. “In 2019, I had an art residency in Europe,” Hsu says. “I met Benjamin in the lobby
April 22 to April 28 The true identity of the mastermind behind the Demon Gang (魔鬼黨) was undoubtedly on the minds of countless schoolchildren in late 1958. In the days leading up to the big reveal, more than 10,000 guesses were sent to Ta Hwa Publishing Co (大華文化社) for a chance to win prizes. The smash success of the comic series Great Battle Against the Demon Gang (大戰魔鬼黨) came as a surprise to author Yeh Hung-chia (葉宏甲), who had long given up on his dream after being jailed for 10 months in 1947 over political cartoons. Protagonist
A fossil jawbone found by a British girl and her father on a beach in Somerset, England belongs to a gigantic marine reptile dating to 202 million years ago that appears to have been among the largest animals ever on Earth. Researchers said on Wednesday the bone, called a surangular, was from a type of ocean-going reptile called an ichthyosaur. Based on its dimensions compared to the same bone in closely related ichthyosaurs, the researchers estimated that the Triassic Period creature, which they named Ichthyotitan severnensis, was between 22-26 meters long. That would make it perhaps the largest-known marine reptile and would