Legal experts have urged the government to consider amending regulations to prevent more listed companies from taking controversial actions to maintain control of their boardrooms.
“Neither the Ministry of Economic Affairs nor the Financial Supervisory Commission have the tools to effectively address Tatung Co’s (大同) management dispute,” Huang Ming-jye (黃銘傑), a professor of law at National Taiwan University, told the Taipei Times by telephone on Friday.
After Tatung’s management — controlled by the founding Lin (林) family — retained full control of the nine-member board by depriving certain investors of their voting rights at a shareholders’ meeting on June 30, the Securities and Futures Investors Protection Center last week filed a lawsuit to dismiss Tatung chairwoman Lin Kuo Wen-yen (林郭文艷), and the ministry rejected the registration of the company’s new board members.
However, Tatung announced that it would appeal the ministry’s rejection and said it would defend itself against the center’s suit.
“Although Minister of Economic Affairs Wang Mei-hua (王美花) said that she did not consider the company’s board election legal, the ministry is not entitled to declare the election invalid. Only the court has the final say, if you really comprehend the Company Act (公司法),” Huang said.
Even if the ministry orders the company to hold a new shareholders’ meeting according to Article 195 of the act, Tatung is likely to insist on the legality of its board election held on June 30 and not cooperate, Huang said.
In an extreme scenario, the ministry would retract registration of the firm’s current board members, said Stephen Wu (吳志光), a lawyer at Lee and Li Attorneys-at-Law (理律法律事務所).
“However, the move would hardly affect the company’s operations,” Wu said.
That is because in Taiwan the registration of board directors is not a requirement for the board to execute their rights, but is only needed to be used against a third party, such as a former board director, Wu said.
“Put it simply, there is nothing the government can do if Tatung is determined to ignore all the government’s instructions and public opinion. Tatung must obey the court ruling, but the legal process will likely take a long time,” he said.
The minority shareholders led by Lin Hung-hsin (林宏信) have applied to the ministry to hold a special shareholders’ meeting, while another group of shareholders headed by Shanyuan Group (三圓建設) chairman Wang Kuang-hsiang (王光祥) plans to apply next week, which might result in a more complicated situation, Wu said.
Even if those activist investors work together to re-elect new board directors after convening a special shareholders’ meeting successfully, “it would be questionable whether Lin Kuo and her team would accept the new board members,” he said.
The commission is also not equipped to solve the situation, as it can only change the trading method for Tatung stocks or bar the firm from conducting shareholders’ services under current regulations, Huang said.
Huang said he was disappointed by the ministry, as he had urged it to set up stronger mechanisms to curb companies intentionally violating shareholders’ rights when it was amending the act in 2018.
“What Tatung did is wrong, but I am more frustrated that the government could not solve the situation quickly,” he said.
The ministry should establish a mechanism to prohibit disqualified directors from taking important positions for a long period and ensure that companies have a corporate secretary to ensure regulatory compliance, he said.
The government could consider amending the Securities and Exchange Act (證券交易法) first to protect investors, as it would be much easier, he added.
Japanese technology giant Softbank Group Corp said Tuesday it has sold its stake in Nvidia Corp, raising US$5.8 billion to pour into other investments. It also reported its profit nearly tripled in the first half of this fiscal year from a year earlier. Tokyo-based Softbank said it sold the stake in Silicon Vally-based Nvidia last month, a move that reflects its shift in focus to OpenAI, owner of the artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot ChatGPT. Softbank reported its profit in the April-to-September period soared to about 2.5 trillion yen (about US$13 billion). Its sales for the six month period rose 7.7 percent year-on-year
CRESTING WAVE: Companies are still buying in, but the shivers in the market could be the first signs that the AI wave has peaked and the collapse is upon the world Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) yesterday reported a new monthly record of NT$367.47 billion (US$11.85 billion) in consolidated sales for last month thanks to global demand for artificial intelligence (AI) applications. Last month’s figure represented 16.9 percent annual growth, the slowest pace since February last year. On a monthly basis, sales rose 11 percent. Cumulative sales in the first 10 months of the year grew 33.8 percent year-on-year to NT$3.13 trillion, a record for the same period in the company’s history. However, the slowing growth in monthly sales last month highlights uncertainty over the sustainability of the AI boom even as
AI BOOST: Next year, the cloud and networking product business is expected to remain a key revenue pillar for the company, Hon Hai chairman Young Liu said Manufacturing giant Hon Hai Precision Industry Co (鴻海精密) yesterday posted its best third-quarter profit in the company’s history, backed by strong demand for artificial intelligence (AI) servers. Net profit expanded 17 percent annually to NT$57.67 billion (US$1.86 billion) from NT$44.36 billion, the company said. On a quarterly basis, net profit soared 30 percent from NT$44.36 billion, it said. Hon Hai, which is Apple Inc’s primary iPhone assembler and makes servers powered by Nvidia Corp’s AI accelerators, said earnings per share expanded to NT$4.15 from NT$3.55 a year earlier and NT$3.19 in the second quarter. Gross margin improved to 6.35 percent,
BUST FEARS: While a KMT legislator asked if an AI bubble could affect Taiwan, the DGBAS minister said the sector appears on track to continue growing The local property market has cooled down moderately following a series of credit control measures designed to contain speculation, the central bank said yesterday, while remaining tight-lipped about potential rule relaxations. Lawmakers in a meeting of the legislature’s Finance Committee voiced concerns to central bank officials that the credit control measures have adversely affected the government’s tax income and small and medium-sized property developers, with limited positive effects. Housing prices have been climbing since 2016, even when the central bank imposed its first set of control measures in 2020, Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Lo Ting-wei (羅廷瑋) said. “Since the second half of
RSS