On a busy day, contract employees in India monitoring nudity and pornography on Facebook and Instagram will each view 2,000 posts in an eight-hour shift, or almost four per minute.
They are part of a 1,600-member team at Genpact Ltd, an outsourcing firm with offices in the southern Indian city of Hyderabad that is contracted to review Facebook content.
Seven content reviewers at Genpact said in interviews late last year and early this year that their work was underpaid, stressful and sometimes traumatic.
The reviewers, all in their 20s, declined to be identified for fear of losing their jobs or breaching nondisclosure agreements. Three of the seven have left Genpact in the past few months.
“I have seen women employees breaking down on the floor, reliving the trauma of watching suicides real-time,” one former employee said, adding that he had seen this happen at least three times.
Reuters was unable to independently verify the incidents or determine how often they might have occurred.
Genpact declined comment.
The working conditions described by the employees offer a window into the moderator operations at Facebook Inc and the challenges faced by the company as it seeks to police what its 2 billion users post.
Their accounts contrast in several respects with the image presented by three Facebook executives in interviews and statements of a carefully selected, skilled workforce that is paid well and has the tools to handle a difficult job.
Facebook vice president of operations Ellen Silver acknowledged that content moderation “at this size is uncharted territory.”
“We care deeply about getting this right,” she said in January. “This includes the training reviewers receive, our hiring practices, the wellness resources that we provide to each and every person reviewing content, and our overall engagement with partners.”
While rejecting the Hyderabad employees’ assertions about low pay, Facebook has said that it had begun drafting a code of conduct for outsourcing partners, but declined to give details.
It has also said that it would be introducing an annual compliance audit of its vendor policies this year to review the work at contractor facilities.
The company is organizing a first-ever summit next month to bring together its outsourcing vendors from around the world, with the aim of sharing best practices and bringing more consistency to how moderators are treated.
These efforts were announced in a blogpost on Monday by Facebook vice president of global operations Justin Osofsky.
Facebook works with at least five outsourcing vendors in at least eight countries on content review, a Reuters tally showed.
About 15,000 people, a mix of contractors and employees at more than 20 content review sites worldwide, were working on content review at Facebook as of December last year, Silver said.
More than a dozen moderators in other parts of the world have talked of similar traumatic experiences.
A former Facebook contract employee, Selena Scola, filed a lawsuit in California in September last year, alleging that content moderators who face mental trauma after reviewing distressing images on the platform are not being properly protected by the social networking company.
Facebook in a court filing has denied all of Scola’s allegations and called for a dismissal, contending that Scola has insufficient grounds to sue.
Some examples of traumatic experiences among Facebook content moderators in the US were described this week by technology news Web site The Verge.
The Genpact unit in Hyderabad reviews posts in Indian languages, Arabic, English and some Afghan and Asian tribal dialects, Facebook said.
On one team, employees spend their days reviewing nudity and explicit pornography.
Meanwhile, the “counterterrorism” team watches videos that include beheadings, car bombings and electric shock torture sessions, the employees said.
Those on the “self-harm” unit regularly watch live videos of suicide attempts — and do not always succeed in alerting authorities in time, two of the employees said, adding that they had no experience with suicide or trauma.
Facebook said that its policies called for moderators to alert a “specially trained team” to review situations where there was “potential imminent risk or harm.”
The moderators who spoke to reporters said that in the instances they knew of, the trained team was called in when there was a possibility of a suicide, but the reviewers continued to monitor the feed even after the team had been alerted.
Job postings and salary pay slips seen by reporters showed that annual compensation at Genpact for an entry-level Facebook Arabic-language content reviewer was 100,000 Indian rupees (US$1,409) annually, or just more than US$6 per day.
Facebook contended that benefits made the real pay much higher.
The workers said that they did receive transportation to and from work, a common noncash benefit in India.
Moderators in Hyderabad employed by another information technology outsourcing firm, Accenture PLC, monitor Arabic content on YouTube on behalf of Google for a minimum of 350,000 rupees annually, according to two of its workers and pay slips seen by reporters.
Accenture declined to comment, citing client confidentiality.
Facebook disputed the pay analysis, saying that Genpact is required to pay more than industry averages.
The outsourcer, while declining to comment on its work for Facebook, said in a statement that its wages are “significantly higher than the standard in the industry or the minimum wage set by law.”
The Genpact moderators in Hyderabad said that Facebook sets performance targets, which are reassessed periodically, that are called “average review time” or “average handling time.”
“We have to meet an accuracy rate of 98 percent on massive targets,” one of the moderators told reporters. “It is just not easy when you are consistently bombarded with stuff that is mostly mind-numbing.”
Intel Corp has landed Microsoft Corp as a customer for its made-to-order chip business, marking a key win for an ambitious turnaround effort under chief executive officer Pat Gelsinger. Microsoft plans to use Intel’s 18A manufacturing technology to make a forthcoming chip that the software maker designed in-house, the two companies said at an event on Wednesday. They did not identify the product, but Microsoft recently announced plans for two homegrown chips — a computer processor and an artificial intelligence (AI) accelerator. Intel has been seeking to prove it can compete in the foundry market, where companies produce custom chips for clients. It
AI EFFECT: Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang moved up to 21st on the Bloomberg Billionaires Index on Thursday after his wealth skyrocketed by US$9.6 billion to US$69.2 billion The artificial intelligence (AI) mania sparked by Nvidia Corp’s sterling results has given a lift to Asia’s major chipmakers, but it has not closed the valuation gap with their US peers. A Bloomberg gauge tracking Asia’s top semiconductor firms, including Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) and Samsung Electronics Co, widened its under-performance against the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index this week. While the Asian index trades at 17 times forward earnings, the US measure is at 27 times, pushing the gap close to a record after Nvidia’s blowout revenue outlook reinforced investor conviction in the boom in generative AI use. Nvidia’s 8 percent
The arrival of Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) in Japan’s Kumamoto Prefecture marks the regaining of the area’s pivotal position established during the Meiji Restoration in the 19th century, a local business leader said in an interview with CNA. The first fab of Japan Advanced Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc (JASM), TSMC’s majority-owned manufacturing subsidiary in Kumamoto, is set to open today. After the 1868 Meiji Restoration, Kumamoto was of key importance as it was home to a major garrison national defense. However, that position was ceded to Fukuoka after World War II as Japan turned to foreign trade for post-war economic development,
OVERSEAS: The company is expanding with OSAT development in India, an EV factory in Thailand and possibly an 12-inch fab in Malaysia, Young Liu said Hon Hai Precision Industry Co (鴻海精密), the world’s largest contract electronics maker, is expected to forge deeper and more comprehensive collaborations with its main customer Apple Inc, the company’s chairman said on Tuesday. Speaking before a dinner banquet on Tuesday to mark the company’s 50th anniversary, Hon Hai chairman Young Liu (劉揚偉) said that the two companies would forge a deeper and more extensive partnership. “Everything that should be there will be there and nothing will be missed,” Liu said, when asked about the progress made in Hon Hai’s collaborations with Apple in the artificial intelligence and electric vehicle (EV) fields. Hon