A little more than a year ago, a relatively small hedge fund, Alder Hill Management LP, went public with its relatively big bet — reportedly half of its US$200 million fund — against retailers and malls. It was dubbed the new Big Short — a reference to the bet against housing in the run-up to the 2007 to 2009 financial crisis that netted a few hedge funds tens of billions of US dollars.
A few other hedge funds came out and said that they, too, were shorting the CMBX 6, an index of subprime commercial real-estate debt that has about the most significant mall exposure that you can find, and a few Wall Street analysts recommended the same.
Some quickly declared the trade too crowded.
Photo: AFP
How is the bet playing out? Based on the news, you would think exceptionally well.
Last week, Toys “R” Us Inc, already bankrupt, said it was closing all of its stores. Mall jewelry chain Claire’s Stores Inc filed for bankruptcy on Monday. Department chain Bon-Ton Stores Inc decided to close more locations than expected.
And while not exactly mall news, though indicative of Amazon.com Inc’s march through retail, Southeastern Grocers LLC, the owner of Winn-Dixie, on Thursday filed for bankruptcy, the second of two supermarket chains to do so in less than a month. And that was just in the past week.
Based on the CMBX 6, though, you would hardly know it. The index has rallied since early last month, to US$0.85, not far below the US$0.86 it was a year earlier, and barely budged on the Toys “R” Us news.
Factor in premium payments on CMBX credit-default swaps — investors cannot invest directly in or bet against the index — and during the past year any short was surely a losing bet, even as the mall Big Shorters look more and more correct.
The outlook for malls and the likelihood that their owners will be able to continue to make their loan payments has worsened. The price of the CMBX 6, though, has improved.
One simple explanation is mechanics. Toys “R” Us stores are typically not in malls. More often they are next to them.
Two years ago, Toys “R” Us did a private-placement loan tied to about 125 of its stores. That deal, though, is not in the CMBX 6.
Of the US$23.7 billion in debt tied to the CMBX 6, just US$351 million in loans, or 15 percent of the index, are exposed to properties where Toys “R” Us is a tenant, according to Kroll Bond Rating Agency.
Moreover, the index has just 40 percent exposure to retail and limited exposure to the riskiest malls.
More generally, what made residential mortgages such a great short in the run-up to the financial crisis was how quickly the loans were going bad. Some borrowers did not even make their first mortgage payment. Retailers, on the other hand, are proving more resilient than expected. Sears Holdings Corp is still kicking.
And it was not just homeowners, and flippers, who were over-leveraged ahead of the financial crisis. The banks were as well, which forced the refinance machine to come to a grinding halt. Banks are in much better financial shape then they were a decade ago.
Another big difference is there is little else you can do with a house, other than live in it. Malls have restaurants. They can be converted into indoor experience centers. The trend has it limits — not every mall can be turned into an indoor water park — but, unlike homeowners, mall operators have options.
To be right on Wall Street, you have to be not only correct about your trade, but the mechanics of it as well.
Ever since the financial crisis, hedge funds have been on the hunt for the next Big Short. And after nearly a decade, the success rate is nearly zero. Betting against low-volatility exchange-traded vehicles would have generated some returns early last month, but not a lot, and the volatility index quickly reversed itself.
The same is true of short bets against energy high-yield bonds in late 2015, the euro in late 2011 and Greek banks before that.
The CMBX 6 might seem even more like the financial crisis Big Short than those before it, but it is not the first to disappoint.
And yet the fact that the CMBX 6 barely budged in the past week is worrisome. Even if the index itself has relatively little exposure to Toys “R” Us, the closing of the biggest chain of toy superstores is most definitely a negative for the retail industry and a signal that things could get worse for the brick-and-mortar crowd.
Sentiment alone should have dragged down the CMBX 6. That it did not could be another sign of an asset bubble fueled by low interest rates and markets divorced from fundamentals. That should worry investors, not just in retailers or banks, but everywhere.
The counterargument is that it is a good sign that the CMBX 6 is the best way for hedge funds to bet on the death of traditional retailers. No bank (so far) is willing to create synthetic derivatives tied to the debt of the US’ worst malls or retailers. That does not mean that investors should not be worried about the recent financial regulatory rollback.
However, Toys “R” Us can fail, and the index most tied to the health of retailers only slightly wiggles. Ten years after the financial crisis, that is probably as good a sign as any that markets are a lot more shockproof than they used to be.
Stephen Gandel is a Bloomberg Gadfly columnist covering equity markets. He was previously a deputy digital editor for Fortune and an economics blogger at Time. He has also covered finance and the housing market.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Bloomberg LP and its owners.
MULTIFACETED: A task force has analyzed possible scenarios and created responses to assist domestic industries in dealing with US tariffs, the economics minister said The Executive Yuan is tomorrow to announce countermeasures to US President Donald Trump’s planned reciprocal tariffs, although the details of the plan would not be made public until Monday next week, Minister of Economic Affairs J.W. Kuo (郭智輝) said yesterday. The Cabinet established an economic and trade task force in November last year to deal with US trade and tariff related issues, Kuo told reporters outside the legislature in Taipei. The task force has been analyzing and evaluating all kinds of scenarios to identify suitable responses and determine how best to assist domestic industries in managing the effects of Trump’s tariffs, he
TIGHT-LIPPED: UMC said it had no merger plans at the moment, after Nikkei Asia reported that the firm and GlobalFoundries were considering restarting merger talks United Microelectronics Corp (UMC, 聯電), the world’s No. 4 contract chipmaker, yesterday launched a new US$5 billion 12-inch chip factory in Singapore as part of its latest effort to diversify its manufacturing footprint amid growing geopolitical risks. The new factory, adjacent to UMC’s existing Singapore fab in the Pasir Res Wafer Fab Park, is scheduled to enter volume production next year, utilizing mature 22-nanometer and 28-nanometer process technologies, UMC said in a statement. The company plans to invest US$5 billion during the first phase of the new fab, which would have an installed capacity of 30,000 12-inch wafers per month, it said. The
Taiwan’s official purchasing managers’ index (PMI) last month rose 0.2 percentage points to 54.2, in a second consecutive month of expansion, thanks to front-loading demand intended to avoid potential US tariff hikes, the Chung-Hua Institution for Economic Research (CIER, 中華經濟研究院) said yesterday. While short-term demand appeared robust, uncertainties rose due to US President Donald Trump’s unpredictable trade policy, CIER president Lien Hsien-ming (連賢明) told a news conference in Taipei. Taiwan’s economy this year would be characterized by high-level fluctuations and the volatility would be wilder than most expect, Lien said Demand for electronics, particularly semiconductors, continues to benefit from US technology giants’ effort
‘SWASTICAR’: Tesla CEO Elon Musk’s close association with Donald Trump has prompted opponents to brand him a ‘Nazi’ and resulted in a dramatic drop in sales Demonstrators descended on Tesla Inc dealerships across the US, and in Europe and Canada on Saturday to protest company chief Elon Musk, who has amassed extraordinary power as a top adviser to US President Donald Trump. Waving signs with messages such as “Musk is stealing our money” and “Reclaim our country,” the protests largely took place peacefully following fiery episodes of vandalism on Tesla vehicles, dealerships and other facilities in recent weeks that US officials have denounced as terrorism. Hundreds rallied on Saturday outside the Tesla dealership in Manhattan. Some blasted Musk, the world’s richest man, while others demanded the shuttering of his