One year after the 921 earthquake, tackling quake-related crimes remains a major task for Taiwan's legal system.
A recent indictment came on Tuesday, when 10 builders and architects involved in the construction of a multi-story residential complex that collapsed and killed 28 people in Tungshih (東勢), Taichung County, were charged with manslaughter and forgery. Tungshih was one of the areas worst-hit by the earthquake.
This is at least the 32nd indictment in this type of case, and the number of people indicted has risen to around 160, according to data from the Ministry of Justice and district prosecutors' offices. Few cases have reached a court ruling, however.
PHOTO: CHEN CHENG-CHANG, TAIPEI TIMES
Faulty building construction that resulted in deaths and damage is just one kind of quake-related crime being targeted by the judiciary. Others include embezzlement of post-quake relief or reconstruction funds and goods, and bid rigging in public reconstruction projects.
The progress of building collapse cases has been widely criticized as being too slow, and victims are still waiting to receive compensation from construction firms. A lawyer who volunteered to assist victims in Taipei City's Tunghsing Building (東星大樓) case, in which 89 died, attributed much of the delay to the complicated process of authenticating the causes of each collapse.
Shoddy building
PHOTO: CHEN CHENG-CHANG, TAIPEI TIMES
In the Tunghsing case, the prosecutor had commissioned the Taipei City Professional Civil Engineers Association (台北市土木技師公會) to carry out an authentication and accordingly five contractors and architects were indicted last November. "But further authentication demanded by the accused is still going on," said lawyer Justin Hsieh (謝政達).
Hsieh said that a major difficulty for Tunghsing's authentication is that the apartment complex was built 17 years ago -- when construction codes and decrees were not yet well developed.
"The lack of definite regulations might leave room for the construction firms to argue that they did not violate the law," Hsieh said.
PHOTO: CHEN CHENG-CHANG, TAIPEI TIMES:
Related information is also hard to gather in such cases.
He said in two other cases where the destroyed buildings were only five or six years old, such as the Doctors' Home (博士的家) complex in Hsinchuang (新莊), Taipei County, the legal process has gone more quickly and smoothly than that of Tunghsing.
Another major problem with the Tunghsing case, Hsieh said, is that of the five people indicted, one, a construction firm boss Hsieh Lung-sheng (謝隆盛), has became a vegetable after suffering a stroke some time prior to the quake, and two others are abroad, not willing to attend court hearings.
The Taipei District Court ordered the provisional seizure of the construction firms' real estate, valued at some NT$300 million, but no convictions or final settlement has been made for the Tunghsing case.
"A conviction will bring justice, but now the most important thing for the victims may be for them to reach a settlement and get compensation," Hsieh said.
He could not predict, however, when a settlement might be reached.
While a number of large apartment complexes collapsed in the 921 quake, the Doctors' Home case is one of only a few cases in which judgements have been reached and convictions made. A settlement is reportedly expected in a few days. But the court ruling has still prompted debate.
The Doctors' Home case is an example of "license leasing" -- a practice with a long history and prevalent in Taiwan's construction industry.
In license leasing, the construction company which undertakes to build a building does not really conduct the work itself. Instead, it leases its license to companies that are not necessarily qualified to do the work required for the project. It is these companies and subcontractors that actually carry out the construction work and for this reason, construction is often substandard.
In the Doctors' Home case, Panchiao (板橋) District Prosecutor Chen Ming-hsiang (陳銘祥) indicted for manslaughter not only the real builders of the collapsed block, but also officials of the company which had leased out its license.
Chen said at the time that the company possessing the license should also be held responsible for the shoddy construction and thus the deaths of the victims.
But the Taipei district court later ruled on June 12 that officials of the company were guilty of forgery but not guilty of manslaughter. The court convicted five builders and subcontractors of manslaughter.
The court said there was no evidence indicating obvious causation between license-leasing and poor quality of a building -- a conclusion with which lawyer Jhering Cheng (鄭文龍) does not agree.
"Of course there is a causal link between these two things. The companies leasing out licenses are able to assess that the companies without licenses are not capable of building houses of good quality. If they do not lease out licenses, these flawed buildings would not be built," Cheng said.
Public safety will not be secured if people who lease out licenses are not held responsible [for the casualties]," Cheng said.
He also said that the Taipei Bar Association (台北律師公會) is to hold a conference at the end of this month to discuss related issues.
Corruption
To the many who were deeply impressed and moved by the solidarity Taiwan society showed after the quake, the idea that government officials would take advantage of the unprecedented tragedy to embezzle relief and reconstruction funds intended for quake victims has come as a shock.
But this has happened.
Wu Chao-feng (
Chen Kuo-hsiung (
Lin Wen-sheng (
Chen Tsang-nan (
These cases are the most high profile ones and similar cases are not rare. Divisional head prosecutor at Nantou District Prosecutors' Office, Hsu Sung-kuei (
"This is a chronic disease of society. Perhaps because in the past too few [offenders of corruption] have been caught, now, that which is wrong has been practiced for so long that it has come to be regarded as right and commonplace by many public officials," Hsu said.
However, Hsu said, a major problem that has encouraged people like Wu Chao-feng to embezzle is the government's inefficiency in dealing with the relief.
"One year on, so much of the relief funds have not reached quake victims. This is evidence that the government's administrative operation is still in chaos.
"A lack of good management of relief funds and goods leaves opportunities for misappropriation to those who have access to these resources," Hsu said.
Gangsters
After the destruction wreaked by the quake there were numerous reconstruction projects. These have not escaped the grip of gangsters and corrupt officials.
"The invasion of gangsters into post-quake public reconstruction in disaster areas is severe," said Chu Nan (朱楠), prosecutor-general of Taichung District Prosecutors' Office.
In one instance of bid-rigging, gangsters manipulated businessmen who were bidding on a series of mountain road reconstruction projects in Taichung County, raising the price of the projects in an attempt to get profits out of the government. Fortunately, the criminal attempt failed and 17 people have been convicted.
In reconstruction of the collapsed Shihgang Dam (石岡水壩), 20 people and nine companies were indicted for bid rigging.
A Nantou County councilor, Pan Yi-chuan (潘一全), earlier this month was arrested and charged with using threats of violence to gain public contracts.
Many reconstruction jobs were categorized as emergency projects and in such cases, public bidding was not required. This enabled gangsters to manipulate the tendering process, Chu said.
Chu and Hsu agreed that post-quake corruption and reconstruction contract rigging cases have been a heavy burden on law enforcement agencies in disaster areas and that, more importantly, this has been due to the incompetence of the administrative system.
"For example, public construction or procurement projects undergo several stages of administrative procedures. If there is any problem it should be detected while in the administrative system, before the prosecution launches a criminal investigation," Hsu said.
Five district prosecutors' offices in disaster areas have, on the justice ministry's decree, set up a cooperative mechanism between prosecution and government ethics departments within several governmental agencies to facilitate the detection of crimes.
"However, the monitoring within the administrative system must function first," Chu said, "Otherwise offenders will not be deterred."
A car bomb killed a senior Russian general in southern Moscow yesterday morning, the latest high-profile army figure to be blown up in a blast that came just hours after Russian and Ukrainian delegates held separate talks in Miami on a plan to end the war. Kyiv has not commented on the incident, but Russian investigators said they were probing whether the blast was “linked” to “Ukrainian special forces.” The attack was similar to other assassinations of generals and pro-war figures that have either been claimed, or are widely believed to have been orchestrated, by Ukraine. Russian Lieutenant General Fanil Sarvarov, 56, head
SAFETY FIRST: Double the number of police were deployed at the Taipei Marathon, while other cities released plans to bolster public event safety Authorities across Taiwan have stepped up security measures ahead of Christmas and New Year events, following a knife and smoke bomb attack in Taipei on Friday that left four people dead and 11 injured. In a bid to prevent potential copycat incidents, police deployments have been expanded for large gatherings, transport hubs, and other crowded public spaces, according to official statements from police and city authorities. Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an (蔣萬安) said the city has “comprehensively raised security readiness” in crowded areas, increased police deployments with armed officers, and intensified patrols during weekends and nighttime hours. For large-scale events, security checkpoints and explosives
‘POLITICAL GAME’: DPP lawmakers said the motion would not meet the legislative threshold needed, and accused the KMT and the TPP of trivializing the Constitution The Legislative Yuan yesterday approved a motion to initiate impeachment proceedings against President William Lai (賴清德), saying he had undermined Taiwan’s constitutional order and democracy. The motion was approved 61-50 by lawmakers from the main opposition Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and the smaller Taiwan People’s Party (TPP), who together hold a legislative majority. Under the motion, a roll call vote for impeachment would be held on May 19 next year, after various hearings are held and Lai is given the chance to defend himself. The move came after Lai on Monday last week did not promulgate an amendment passed by the legislature that
PENTAGON ASSESSMENT: A US report said that even as China and Russia deepen their partnership, cooperation is hindered by a ‘mutual distrust’ of each other The Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) as of October had doubled the number of ships and airplanes deployed around Taiwan compared with the previous two years, Vice Minister of National Defense Hsu Szu-chien (徐斯儉) said yesterday, a day after the opposition-controlled legislature voted against reviewing the government’s general budget for next year, including a NT$1.25 trillion (US$39.71 billion) special defense spending bill. The legislature’s vote against the Ministry of National Defense’s spending plans was regrettable, as the budget was designed to respond to the developing Chinese military threat, Hsu said on the sidelines of a legislative meeting on the general budget. Defense
RSS