A federal jury awarded Mattel Inc US$100 million in damages on Tuesday in a copyright lawsuit that pitted the house of Barbie against MGA Entertainment Inc, the maker of the saucy Bratz dolls.
MGA Entertainment Inc and its chief executive officer Isaac Larian were told to pay a total of US$90 million in three causes of action related to Mattel’s employment contract with designer Carter Bryant, who developed the Bratz concept. The jury also ordered MGA, Larian and subsidiary MGA Hong Kong to pay a total of US$10 million for copyright infringement.
The amount fell far short of the US$1.8 billion that Mattel attorneys had demanded in their closing arguments. Still, the world’s largest toy maker hailed the damage award as a victory and said it planned to file an injunction to stop MGA from producing the Bratz line.
“Mattel has pursued this case first and foremost as a matter of principle,” Mattel CEO Robert Eckert said. “We have an obligation to defend ourselves against competitors who choose to engage in fraudulent activities against us.”
Larian said he would appeal and MGA attorney Thomas Nolan contended that the three awards related to the contract dispute were duplicative.
US District Judge Stephen Larson must decide if that is true and determine a final amount to be paid to Mattel at a future hearing. Nolan said he planned to ask Larson to set total damages at no more than US$40 million.
The jury did not award any punitive damages and found that neither Larian nor MGA acted willfully when they used Bryant’s drawings, which could have increased the damages.
“We are thrilled that this jury sent a strong message that they want these companies to compete in the marketplace and not the courtroom,” Nolan said.
Larian said MGA would keep making Bratz dolls even as Mattel attorneys were to meet yesterday to discuss their legal strategies.
The same jury that decided the damages phase concluded last month that Bratz designer Carter Bryant came up with the Bratz concept while working at Mattel. Jurors placed the value of Bryant’s drawings at US$31,500 and awarded that plus interest to Mattel.
In his closing arguments, Mattel attorney John Quinn said MGA owed Mattel at least US$1 billion in Bratz profits and interest, while Larian aided in the breach of contract and owed about US$800 million for his complicity.
MGA attorneys countered that the jury should award Mattel as little as US$30 million because the company had built the doll line’s value with smart additions, branding and packaging.
The jury awarded damages Tuesday of US$20 million against MGA and US$10 million against Larian in each of three causes of action — intentional interference with contractual relations, aiding and abetting breach of fiduciary duty, and aiding and abetting breach of the duty of loyalty.
They also found that MGA owed Mattel US$6 million for copyright infringement, while Larian owed US$3 million in distributions he had received from Bratz-related sales and MGA Hong Kong owed US$1 million.
After their introduction in 2001, the Bratz line exploded in popularity among “tweens” — girls aged seven to 12. The highly stylized fashion dolls have oversized feet, heads and hands, curling lashes and huge, almond-shaped eyes daubed with exotic-colored eyeshadow.
NO RECIPROCITY: Taipei has called for cross-strait group travel to resume fully, but Beijing is only allowing people from its Fujian Province to travel to Matsu, the MAC said The Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) yesterday criticized an announcement by the Chinese Ministry of Culture and Tourism that it would lift a travel ban to Taiwan only for residents of China’s Fujian Province, saying that the policy does not meet the principles of reciprocity and openness. Chinese Deputy Minister of Culture and Tourism Rao Quan (饒權) yesterday morning told a delegation of Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) lawmakers in a meeting in Beijing that the ministry would first allow Fujian residents to visit Lienchiang County (Matsu), adding that they would be able to travel to Taiwan proper directly once express ferry
STUMPED: KMT and TPP lawmakers approved a resolution to suspend the rate hike, which the government said was unavoidable in view of rising global energy costs The Ministry of Economic Affairs yesterday said it has a mandate to raise electricity prices as planned after the legislature passed a non-binding resolution along partisan lines to freeze rates. Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) lawmakers proposed the resolution to suspend the price hike, which passed by a 59-50 vote. The Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) voted with the KMT. Legislative Speaker Han Kuo-yu (韓國瑜) of the KMT said the resolution is a mandate for the “immediate suspension of electricity price hikes” and for the Executive Yuan to review its energy policy and propose supplementary measures. A government-organized electricity price evaluation board in March
FAST RELEASE: The council lauded the developer for completing model testing in only four days and releasing a commercial version for use by academia and industry The National Science and Technology Council (NSTC) yesterday released the latest artificial intelligence (AI) language model in traditional Chinese embedded with Taiwanese cultural values. The council launched the Trustworthy AI Dialogue Engine (TAIDE) program in April last year to develop and train traditional Chinese-language models based on LLaMA, the open-source AI language model released by Meta. The program aims to tackle the information bias that is often present in international large-scale language models and take Taiwanese culture and values into consideration, it said. Llama 3-TAIDE-LX-8B-Chat-Alpha1, released yesterday, is the latest large language model in traditional Chinese. It was trained based on Meta’s Llama-3-8B
NOVEL METHODS: The PLA has adopted new approaches and recently conducted three combat readiness drills at night which included aircraft and ships, an official said Taiwan is monitoring China’s People’s Liberation Army (PLA) exercises for changes in their size or pattern as the nation prepares for president-elect William Lai’s (賴清德) inauguration on May 20, National Security Bureau (NSB) Director-General Tsai Ming-yen (蔡明彥) said yesterday. Tsai made the comment at a meeting of the Legislative Yuan’s Foreign Affairs and National Defense Committee, in response to Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Legislator Wang Ting-yu’s (王定宇) questions. China continues to employ a carrot-and-stick approach, in which it applies pressure with “gray zone” tactics, while attempting to entice Taiwanese with perks, Tsai said. These actions aim to help Beijing look like it has