Print

Mail

wiki links

FEATURE: Questions remain over EU's ability to weather storm

Can Europe's economy stay on track even if the US goes off the rails?

This old question is being asked with new urgency across the continent, after a startling divergence last week in how the European Central Bank (ECB) and the US Federal Reserve are reading economic tea leaves.

Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke said on Thursday that the Fed would cut rates to try to ward off a recession. Earlier that day, ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet told a news conference in Frankfurt that the signals on European growth were mixed.

A growing number of economists, convinced that Europe is not as insulated from US woes as many Europeans would like to believe, are questioning why, at such a sensitive moment, the ECB is warning it might raise interest rates.

"The ECB sees the glass as half full. The Fed sees it as half empty," said Thomas Mayer, the chief European economist at Deutsche Bank. "It's not a difference in the data; it's a difference in the analysis."

The simplest explanation for the ECB's hawkish demeanor is its inflation-fighting mandate.

Trichet, for example, has warned labor unions not to use Europe's inflation rate of 3.1 percent as a pretext for demanding steep wage increases.

But while Trichet has thrust himself into German labor negotiations, several economists argue that the bank may be underestimating the impact in Europe of a US recession.

The bank, Mayer said, still does not believe that the credit crisis originating in the US mortgage market poses a grave risk to Europe's economic prospects. That is why the bank, he said, is threatening a rate increase when it should be preparing for a rate cut.

Disputing another train of thought popular in Europe, Jacques Cailloux, head of euro area economic research for the Royal Bank of Scotland, said: "The ECB is wrong in its assessment that the emerging markets can offset the US downturn."

"The whole idea of globalization is at odds with the thesis of decoupling," he said.

Decoupling refers to the argument that Europe is not as dependent on the US as it once was because Europe's exports to China and other emerging economies have grown so much faster than its exports to the US.

The thesis became fashionable in the last year as an explanation for the growth rate in the US slowing as big European economies accelerated.

In its World Economic Outlook last spring, the IMF said that the faltering US economy had limited impact on world growth because US economic fragility was rooted in a troubled housing market -- a national phenomenon that was less subject to global contagion.

The chapter was titled "Decoupling the Train," but the authors put a question mark after the title, cautioning that housing woes could spill over into other areas of the US economy, in which case the troubles in the US could become the world's troubles.

This has proven to be the case, as the mortgage problems have mutated into a credit crisis that has become trans-Atlantic.

European banks, like their counterparts in the US, have been forced to write down billions of dollars in the value of complex securities backed by subprime mortgages.

The ECB responded as forcefully as any central bank to the turmoil caused by the credit crunch. Last week, it said it would inject another US$20 billion into the financial system, the latest in a stream of liquidity injections since August.

But Trichet has stopped short of saying that the financial crisis could halt European growth. At a news conference on Thursday, after the bank left its benchmark rate unchanged at 4 percent, he said the signals on Europe's growth were mixed.

"Our baseline scenario remains one of ongoing growth, but risks are clearly on the downside," he said.

For Mayer and other economists, the question is not whether the credit crisis will dent Europe's economy, but when.

Housing sales in Spain and Ireland -- two of Europe's hottest property markets -- have already dried up, he said, and France will not be far behind.

"Europe suffers from the same problems as the US does," Mayer said. "The trade linkages between Europe and the US may have come down in recent years, but that is beside the point."

Cailloux said there was even a correlation between Germany's exports to China and its exports to the US.

As China exports less to the US, Cailloux said, it has less demand for German exports, like machine tools.

"Europe's exports to Asia are indirectly related to final demand in the US" he said.

This coupling will soon become apparent to the ECB, Cailloux said.

The bank's next shift in monetary policy, he said, would be a rate cut, not a rate increase.
This story has been viewed 771 times.