Home / World Business
Mon, Aug 23, 2004 - Page 12 News List

French think SUVs are cool at a time when fuel is costly


The French, who are never immune to fashion or status, have fallen in love with the sports utility vehicle (SUV) -- but at the worst possible time.

As sales of the macho four-wheel-drive vehicles continue to skyrocket, local and national governments are moving to nip this automotive fad in the bud.

According to figures provided by Toyota, SUV sales rose by nearly 20 percent in the first half of 2004 compared to the same period last year, with some 54,000 units sold in France.

This was the fifth consecutive six-month sales increase for the SUV and came at a time when sales of other types of cars were stagnating.

According to the French division of the manufacturer Land Rover, the success is easy to explain: "People like sitting high up in order to be able to see the landscape."

Whatever the reason, the increasing number of SUVs rolling down French streets and motorways has not pleased everyone and has provoked the first skirmishes in what increasingly is looking like a bitter war between car manufacturers and SUV enthusiasts on the one hand and elected officials on the other.

On June 8, the Paris City Council fired the first shot in voting a "wish to limit the use of" SUVs in the French capital because, according to the Paris Green Party, they produce "four times more carbon dioxide than other cars".

While this figure is not quite accurate, tests have shown that SUVs are the biggest polluters by far on four wheels, producing between 14 and 84 percent more carbon dioxide than other cars.

The reason is that it takes more power to propel the heavy all-terrain vehicle, which consequently requires a larger engine and more petrol. In the city, an SUV consumes 48 percent more petrol on the average than a classic automobile.

According to Green Party politician Denis Baupin, the Paris deputy mayor for transport who tabled the initiative, "SUVs have no reason to be in cities. They are unadapted to urban traffic because they pollute, take up to too much space and are a danger to pedestrians."

His comments echoed earlier statements by London Mayor Ken Livingstone, who labeled people that take their children to school in SUVs as "idiots."

The Paris City Council's move brought an immediate and angry response from the president of the French Association of SUVs, Eric Breteau.

Revenge of the SUVs

"SUVs have the right to drive everywhere, just like other vehicles," Breteau thundered, and denounced the Paris initiative as "whimsical and crude propaganda."

Breteau and his fellow SUV lovers have little to fear from the Paris undertaking; not yet, in any case.

More threatening is a move by the French government to tax purchasers of polluting vehicles such as the SUV and reward those who buy low-emission cars.

Beginning on Jan. 1, a person who buys an SUV equipped with a V8 diesel engine will pay a special tax of about 3,000 euros (US$3,700), while the buyer of a high-performance automobile will be asked to pay 1,500 euros.

On the other hand, someone who purchases a car such as the Peugeot 206 diesel equipped with a particulate filter -- that is, a low-emission vehicle -- will receive a bonus of about 800 euros.

The so-called "bonus/malus" plan is part of a wide-reaching environmental programme undertaken by the government of Prime Minister Jean-Pierre Raffarin to reduce air and water pollution in France.

This story has been viewed 5172 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top